4 ms·
The Unintended Negative Consequences of LEDs
- sophacles 17y agoMaybe they should sell led traffic bulbs with resistive wires to generate heat, like the rear-windshield defroster. They could be switched on during snow. Still saves a ton of money/energy.
- noodle 17y agoi'm sure they will, they probably just haven't had the time to produce and sell a solution yet. it hasn't been long since they discovered the problem.
- Retric 17y agoIt's a well known and solved problem, most areas are not willing to pay extra to have it installed when it's only a problem for a few days a year or even decade.
- bartl 17y agoGood idea, but I would put the wires in the (colored) glass, not in the LED bulb.
- hoggle 17y agoThis is really funny maybe U.S. infrastructure decision makers should buy european technology, because a simple combination of sensors(temperature and or light)/heating coils would solve all of these problems pretty easily.
- zyb09 17y agoThe issue was already discovered a month ago and it's not 'consequences' but one single consequence. Also the statement > None of the proposed solutions are foolproof is just simply wrong. Traffic lights will be upgraded with little heating systems (coil/wires) and everything will be fine.
- itistoday 17y agoThanks, you beat me to it. The sensationalism in this article is incredible. This is a simple engineering problem that does not justify an article titled "The Unintended Negative Consequences of LEDs". Put in a coil connected to a thermometer to melt snow if necessary. Problem solved, and energy is still conserved.
- mnemonicsloth 17y agoUnless we're talking about relativistic quantum traffic lights, energy will conserved regardless ;-)
- maw 17y agoIf so, will they still be cheaper to operate? I can buy that they'll still use less energy on net, but that isn't the only concern here.
- wildwood 17y agoIf the heating element is thermostat-driven, and not on all the time, then yes.
- ars 17y agoHopefully not a thermostat but rather a proximity or a frost sensor.
- evgen 17y agoNo, use a thermostat. It is much simpler, less prone to errors, you only need one per light housing, and the energy cost required to keep the shrouds above 34 degrees is quite insignificant.
- pavel_lishin 17y agoYou could probably get away with having one per block; aren't most traffic lights all connected? Or have I just been watching too many movies where hackers take over streetlights?
- aminuit 17y agoThere is a good point in the comments that isn't made in the article. Unlike a traffic light outage due to power failure, the ice buildup may only affect one of the signals, so the conventional rule to treat a dark traffic signal as a four way stop fails. One person may see a green light, while another driver on a perpendicular course stops at the affected light, but then enters the intersection because he expects the other driver to stop.
- maukdaddy 17y agoYou should never enter an intersection "expecting" another driver to stop under those kind of circumstances. After watching the driving abilities of the average American, I would actually wait at the intersection until no cars are in sight to continue on.
- mechanical_fish 17y agoCongratulations, you are officially qualified to drive in Massachusetts. ;)
- flatline 17y agoI had exactly this scenario happen years ago. I was driving to a four-way stoplight and the light was snowed over (only in my direction, as it turns out). The cars on the side road were stopped. I slowed to a near-stop and was trying to figure out what to do - some people coming from the opposite direction were going. Sure enough, the side traffic started entering the intersection and I tried to come to a complete stop and (in slow-motion) slid on ice into a car at about 5 MPH, who did not even bother to look to the sides, presumably because his light was perfectly clear.
- mnemonicsloth 17y agoThis article got written because economists have a limited vocabulary for talking about design. If you build a machine to solve a problem, and the machine doesn't act the way you want it to, that's a bug. Fixing bugs is easier than starting over would be. Bugs that make you wonder are called design flaws. You don't get unintended consequences until your system works, and things change in your environment (or maybe with your users) because of the way it works. Unintended consequences are hard to fix because they only show up in systems that are already doing what you want.
- mattmaroon 17y agoThis seems silly. "Heating up the LEDs would help defeat the purpose of saving energy". Not if you only heat them when they need heated, which I imagine is trivial to detect. Even then you've got a bulb that runs at the same energy usage during the winter as the rest, and then at a lower rate for 10 months per year.
- ajross 17y agoNot even "during the winter". You only need to run the heater during active snow or ice precipitation. That's what, a few dozen hours a year in most areas?
- mattmaroon 17y agoYeah I was just thinking temperature detection or just a schedule would be very cheap and easy to implement.
- mhb 17y agoDe-icing system for traffic signals patent: http://www.google.com/patents?id=8dJ_AAAAEBAJ&printsec=abstract&zoom=4&source=gbs_overview_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q=&f=false http://www.google.com/patents?id=8dJ_AAAAEBAJ&printsec=a...
- blahedo 17y agoIt seems strange that all the "solutions"---heating coils, diodes, whatever---seem to presume that the basic form factor of the light system would remain unchanged. But wouldn't it be easier to solve if you just rethought the shape of things? Instead of a three-light assembly with hoods over each light (where snow can build up on top of the hood for the next lower light), just reshape the traffic signal as a box with the lights on the back, the four sides opaque (to block glare and peripheral view), and the front side transparent plastic of some variety? There are surely engineering issues there too (like preventing glare off the clear plastic), but it seems like a more stable system, no worries about snow accumulation, and it's probably cheaper to manufacture too.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agosunk costs. infrastructure changes would cost an order of magnitude more than a tweak.
- teeja 17y agoUpvoted for the linked article (PDF) about horses/manure in the 1800s->1905 http://www.uctc.net/access/30/Access%2030%20-%2002%20-%20Horse%20Power.pdf http://www.uctc.net/access/30/Access%2030%20-%2002%20-%20Hor... well worth reading for it's analysis of all the problems with horses that the CAR solved (and, as always, it created new ones) -- like piles of manure 40-60 feet high in cities! Now that problem's limited to D.C.!!