3 ms·
"But it's not completely implausible that this really was the decision of a few individual employees." Oh, I fully believe it was the decision of a few individ
by jerf 11y ago
"But it's not completely implausible that this really was the decision of a few individual employees."
Oh, I fully believe it was the decision of a few individual employees. I just don't believe those individuals were the actual coders. Coders will code to the spec they are given; problems are far more likely to lie in the spec layer.
It is possible it will turn out the coders should have known better. But it isn't even that hard for me to create plausible circumstances in which the coders didn't have any reason to believe they were doing anything wrong. Remember, we're only seeing the end-results, but it's not hard to imagine a combination of specifications where the programmers are assured each little step is legal and OK, and a combination of other optimizations combining together to produce this result, with no one person quite understanding the interactions.
And just to be clear, I work a lot in security, on the defense side. I'm familiar with taking the possibility that coders will be actively hostile seriously. But I'm also very familiar with seeing five intelligent people each acting according to their own best info and with their own best interests at heart interacting to produce blithering stupidity. It's not always as simple as it looks when you're just looking at the outcome.
- eridius 11y agoThe article did say > The German automaker has suspended 10 senior managers, including three top engineers, as part of its internal investigation. So it could be a few engineers and their managers that colluded together on this.