6 ms·
This is because of the field itself more than any other policies. I have an undergrad degree in Computer Information Systems. That was VERY appealing when I kne
by brightball 11y ago
This is because of the field itself more than any other policies. I have an undergrad degree in Computer Information Systems. That was VERY appealing when I knew nothing about programming, the field, etc.
After having been in the field for 15 years, there are a few things that become very clear:
1. I did not need an undergraduate degree to do this. Some fields you need formal education in a controlled setting. This isn't one of them.
2. There is virtually nothing in this field that I feel I couldn't learn given books and free time
3. I am married with 2 kids and a good job. To pursue a PhD I've got to either put my job and my income on hold to go pursue it (while taking on the expense) OR pursue it in my spare time and encroach on my children's childhood. Neither are worth it.
4. Virtually nothing to gain FROM the PhD
I also have a Master's but I got that in a business field instead, which is tremendously harder to just get from books. Experience and connections in business are huge and that degree was worth every penny.
At this point, if I went back to school for anything it would probably be Law, Statistics or Finance. There's just nothing in the field of computing that I believe couldn't be better learned by experience.
- yid 11y ago> There's just nothing in the field of computing that I believe couldn't be better learned by experience. The rest of your post makes sense, but you lost me at this sentiment. There is a lot more to computing that information systems and programming. I'm glad your career worked out, but there is certainly much in CS that you will simply never learn in the field.
- anthonybsd 11y ago> but there is certainly much in CS that you will simply never learn in the field. Like what? In other words, what parts of undergrad CS could you not learn on your own from the books given reasonable amount of time, you figure?
- minionslave 11y agoSomeone's got to research the theories that you've read in the books. These are the kind of things you won't be able to learn in your spare time.
- khyryk 11y agoThe issue comes down to whether it's reasonable to expect a very large number of people to try to emulate the work of the true professional theorists. For the average programmer, it might be nice to know once in a while, but why this continued emphasis on a (formal) theoretical background?
- yid 11y agoWell now you've changed the goalposts with "a reasonable amount of time" and self-study rather than industry experience. More to the "experience" point, I can't think of many jobs that will expose you to the sheer breadth of a good undergrad CS curriculum: think a solid foundation in algorithms, networking, calculus, linear algebra, databases, advanced algorithms (randomized, approximation), programming languages, compiler design, ai of various sorts, numerical methods, theory of computation, to name the big ones.
- imh 11y agoThe top comment literally said "given books and free time." Not exactly moving goalposts.
- yid 11y agoSee the part of the comment I quoted.
- dropit_sphere 11y agoOkaaaaayyy, but then it's you that's moving the goalposts. The part you quoted must be taken in the context of the rest of the comment.
- colordrops 11y agoDefinitely! This prevailing sentiment that practical experience can replace a CS degree baffles me. There's a vast array of topics in CS that aren't encountered in 95% of typical programming tasks. Then you've got the greater efficiency of learning when you learn things directly and can interact mentors and other students. No book or tutorial will have all the details down like a human that understands something. Then there is the crafting of a holistic program that ensures students get exposed to the right topics in the right order, building a strong theoretical basis. Also, more advanced or cutting edge topics are not going to be well documented so the academic world is a great place to get exposure. Also, you don't have career pressure to meet business goals so you can focus on learning. Also, the time structure and social environment helps with people that aren't completely self driven yet (the majority of young adults?). And then you've got the entire collegiate experience which gives you skills and learning and networking beyond your chosen field. I could go on. I think people who trash university education either never attended, went to a poor school, or were studying something they didn't care about and thus never engaged properly.
- outworlder 11y agoMy thoughts exactly. The worst part is: you don't even know what you are missing in the first place. Since we are all into anecdotes today, let me give you mine: My co-founder once called me with some aggravation, because he was developing a feature for a client that needed, in a nutsheel, to figure out which points, out of a few million, were inside some arbitrary geographical boundaries. His naive algorithm was taking minutes to process all the data, but the requirement was for real-time(ish). Turns out I didn't even get to apply the space partitioning techniques that I learned in class. Just explaining to him the concept of pre-calculating bounding boxes was more than enough for him to implement a solution in less than an hour. Since he had not even heard of them, he didn't know what to look for, or that there was an entire class of algorithms and data structures in computer graphics dedicated to that sort of problem. Don't even get me started with things like dynamic programming, or mathematical logic. Are you seriously going to study something like that for months, if there's no-one pushing you?
- thisone 11y agoyes, people will. I'm of the opposite opinion to be honest. If you need to be pushed by someone else to learn something then why would you do it?
- cellis 11y agoI'm self taught, and I did. For game dev. Nothing like trying to build an RTS or 3D engine to force you to learn as much math as you can handle.
- icebraining 11y agoThat's a lack of higher education... or of Google-fu: https://www.google.com/search?q=algorithm+find+points+inside+geographic+area https://www.google.com/search?q=algorithm+find+points+inside...
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>To pursue a PhD I've got to either put my job and my income on hold to go pursue it (while taking on the expense) In other sciences, schools typically provide free tuition in addition to a decent annual stipend (for housing, food, supplies, entertainment, etc.). I'd guess most CS PhD programs are similar. >Virtually nothing to gain FROM the PhD That is probably true if you go into it assuming that. The idea is that you already have a longish (2-6 years) project that you want to work on. You gain whatever you'd like. >There's just nothing in the field of computing that I believe couldn't be better learned by experience. This is why one would work on a PhD.
- nmrm2 11y agoRight. It's fascinating how often I hear people saying that can learn by experience but wouldn't do a PhD. A PhD is a guaranteed salary for five years to do pretty much whatever you want (plus a bit of politicking to explain to someone why what you're doing is related to an existing grant, which is way easier than it sounds). And bonus: you get to work on things that no one has ever done before, instead of just teaching yourself stuff everyone else already knows out of a book.
- holdenk 11y agoPhD stipends tend to be much lower than industry pay.
- nmrm2 11y agoGive me a call when you find a company that lets its employees work on whatever they want with minimal effort put into politicking/explanation. Plenty of excellent engineers take unpaid time off work between jobs for the opportunity to work on personal projects without interruption. Point is, 30-40k/yr ain't bad pay for that sort of freedom. EDIT: I've been in a PhD program. The reply to this comment DOES NOT describe a normal or healthy advisor/advisee relationship. Ultimately, there should be a point in every PhD where the student carves out a project and works on that project, and it should probably happen before the student is spending most of their time on research. The student shouldn't have to play politics to convince people to allow him/her to work on their own ideas, as long as those ideas have scientific value. If you find yourself consistently working 80 hour weeks and answering 2am emails, switch advisors or switch programs. If you're just working on your advisor's stuff without any autonomy and/or don't have any say in the direction of your or your lab's research, switch advisors or switch programs. A lot of the "bad press" PhD programs get aren't indicative of a healthy PhD and are not as common as they're made out to be. And never necessary. It's usually a combination of an abusive professor and a niave student. Which, BTW, happens in industry as well ("death marches" etc) A phd isn't a 40 hour work week kinda gig, but it also shouldn't be abusive. But in general, it's really simple: don't let people abuse you, and if you're taking a pay cut in return for freedom, be damn sure you demand the freedom.
- varjag 11y ago> There's just nothing in the field of computing that I believe couldn't be better learned by experience. Not sure I would agree. School gave me a bunch of the knowledge I'd very unlikely picked autodidactically. For example, the basic advanced maths package, which is a key to understanding numerous CS concepts. Finite state automations, Fourier transforms, dynamic programming, formal grammars, graph theory.. are not something I could be able to casually pick up with just high school knowledge and fumbling around. No doubt some people could, but am pretty average in this regard and I think the majority would relate to that. I'd even argue non-academic things, like organizing a project, working in groups, being able to tell a dud from someone who delivers, meeting the deadlines and time planning, are better and less stressfully learned in the school.
- absolutenumber 11y agoWith all due respect,i disagree with you.I have a master degree in computer science from a university in Chicago and i can tell you that most of these courses can be learned by yourself.You just need to be self-disciplined and self-motivated.And constantly ready to learn.This field is all about continuous learning.Nobody teaches me Chef,Docker,Ansible,AWS in the university. Infact, American tech industry moves faster than most computer science departments in terms of new technology. When i look at the course outline of online Master in Computer science from Georgia Tech last week,i laughed.You know what,you can learn it by yourself.Please see http://www.omscs.gatech.edu/courses/ http://www.omscs.gatech.edu/courses/ I am a big fan of college education.But computer science is just not one of them.That is my experience.YMMV.My CTO has a degree in Visual Communication.He taught himself all what he knows.You know what,we both earn six figures,i can tell you that you wont know that he does not have any degree in computer science.
- varjag 11y agoHorses for courses I guess. Personally, I don't see the basic volatile tech belonging to CS curriculum at all, it's the things you pick up from user manuals on your way of doing bigger things.
- 11y ago
- tluyben2 11y agoNot sure what business field education you did but the experience and connections vs kicking your brain into a state of formal proofs makes me always say my CS degree was worth far more than my business education which was boosted more by contacts and networking long after uni.
- kailuowang 11y agoI am curious what point are you trying to convey in regards to this article. The fact that PhD in the CS field is not so useful is the reason why more foreigners pursuing it? I am a bit confused.
- marincounty 11y ago"There's just nothing in the field of computing that I believe couldn't be better learned by experience." I don't know what it's like on the Ivy League School level, but on the community college level; it seems like the courses are at least five-ten years out of date. (I'm not dumping on community colleges either. I have gotten more out of community colleges than state, or UC courses. I've alway been a huge supporter of community colleges.) I really wanted to support my local community college, and learn something new, but every year I look through the offered courses, and even the catalogue, and it's just not worth the time, and now the money. The course are just too basic, and dated. I honestly think tenure is to blame. Plus, I don't think most administrators know anything about computing, and just rubber stamp these antiquated courses. It's a shame because my local community college is surrounded by tech workers, and kids/adults who want to learn this stuff.
- p1esk 11y agoWhat do you mean "five-ten years out of date"? Most CS topics are decades old: algorithms, computer architecture, language/compiler/OS design, basics of networking, basics of databases, etc. All that hasn't changed much in the last 10 years.
- senekerim 11y ago> There is virtually nothing in this field that I feel I couldn't learn given books and free time Nah, you just don't know what you don't know. There are subjects that are hard to pick up outside of a real course with an instructor, peers, projects, etc. Some areas of CS depend on graduate level math and would be very tough to pick up on your own.
- brightball 11y agoThis kinda blew up after I left so let me elaborate. When I say some fields you need formal education in a controlled setting, there's a few examples I can give to provide context. If you want to go into medicine, you can't borrow a friend and just try things on them. By the time you go into the field any mistake you make becomes critical and it's difficult to log hours and gain experience without a formal educational environment. To practice law you need to be able to pass the bar, you need to understand decades of case history, legal precedent and how the entire system functions so that you can feasibly operate within that system. To get into management you can potentially gain experience in volunteer organizations but to do so you're likely going to have enough of a go-getter attitude to be elevated to those positions in the first place. It's not quite the same as saying "I'm going to read these books and learn management." To go into various fields of engineering there are a number of systems to be understood, sometimes expensive equipment involved and literal danger to other people if things aren't done properly. You can certainly tinker your way into an interest, but you need the formal education in a controlled environment. There are many other fields that fit within that bubble. For most of computer science you can pick up and book, sit in front of your laptop and work, learn, experiment, try, fail, learn, improve continuously for virtually no cost other than your own time. You need a goal, then to work towards that goal you learn what you need to accomplish it and pick up those pieces to begin. When it sucks, you learn why and figure out how to improve it. You start optimizing. You need to make something faster you learn how it works under the hood. You need to hook up to some other system you learn about apis. You need to make the interface better, you learn about UX. The cost to learn is time and that's why this field is constant learning. I agree with other posters that most people are pursuing advanced math in their spare time. Neither am I but I don't often need to invoke advanced math. I know there are areas where one would need it more, but these days I do not know many people in this field who do. The crux of my point is simply that, some of the best programmers I know have never gone to college and are 100% self taught. There are very few other fields that you can say that about. That's all I was getting at.
- Spooky23 11y agoThere wasn't a return on investment for pursuing a PhD for me, I'd venture to guess that I took a salary hit by staying in school for my bachelor's degree vs. dropping out. But the work that I do isn't research, and I'm not advancing the field -- just solving business problems. If I was born in the late 60s vs late 70s, pursuing an academic career would have been a great option, but that ship sailed.