11 ms·
Hitler's Drug Addiction
- littletimmy 11y agoDude. The guy lost. You don't have to propagandize against him now. Let it rest.
- jbob2000 11y agoI thought it had a huge slant as well. I get it, the Nazi's did cruel things, but I'm a little leery of articles like this that are so demonizing. Can't we just talk about them as a facet of history?
- sageabilly 11y agoIt is a facet of history. It's a new fact about one of the most reviled and studied individuals in human history and it places his words and deeds in a new light. It is new information about not only Hitler but the entire Third Reich including everyone from the top down to the troops and as such means that historians might need to reframe everything that's been written about the time period up to this point. Also yes, articles about Nazis tend to have a demonizing slant, for as yet unknown reasons.
- DanBC 11y agoThe problem with demonizing Nazis is that it makes them seem uniquely evil. But they're not unique. There have been many genocides since the holocaust. And while what they did was certainly evil many of the individuals involved were just regular people.
- mtdewcmu 11y agoMy major problem with demonizing Nazis is that it's trite.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThere was an interesting question posed to the straight dope, "before World War II, who occupied the rhetorical role that Hitler occupies today?" (that is, the embodiment of evil on earth). Asking this question is pretty insightful; it becomes clear that Hitler fills the role now more because we need to have somebody in there than because his life was so shocking that everyone's perspective was changed forever after it happened. The answer to the question is also interesting, but a little less so -- at least for the US, it was a biblical reference, "Pharaoh".
- pvaldes 11y ago> The problem with demonizing Nazis is that it makes them seem uniquely evil. "In the air strike, witnesses said patients were burned alive in the crowded hospital of medecins sans frontieres. Among the dead were three children being treated". War crime, last week. Almost 200 patients and employees in the hospital. To talk about how crazy was Hitler this week seems really convenient. Very pleasant and distracting exercise of history. source: http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/10/05/us-afghanistan-attack-idUSKCN0RW0HC20151005 http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/10/05/us-afghanistan-att...
- dj_axl 11y ago> I'm a little leery of articles like this that are so demonizing Particularly when the article avoids comparison to either modern military drug usage, or allied military drug disbursement at the time. "British troops used 72 million amphetamine tablets in the second world war and the RAF used so many that "Methedrine won the Battle of Britain" according to one report." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alertness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alertness
- CPLX 11y ago> You don't have to propagandize against him now. But I mean the guy is, literally, Hitler.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoOkay I laughed at this more than I should, but a hat tip for employing "literally" in a cromulent fashion.
- learning_still 11y agoThis was posted about a week ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10306399 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10306399
- Retric 11y agoWhat's the point of linking to something that has 4 up-votes and zero comments?
- sarciszewski 11y agoFrom https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html If a story has had significant attention in the last year or so, we kill reposts as duplicates. If not, a small number of reposts is ok.
- matt_morgan 11y ago"Morell has documented 800 injections given to Hitler over 1,340 days, the first in 1943 ..." Not possible; Hitler committed suicide about 850 days after Jan 1 1943. There are some issues in this article.
- acqq 11y agoIf it were 1340 injections in 800 days, it would better fit and possibly support the story, especially the begin: "At the end, when he was already hiding in his wet and dark Fuhrerbunker and his beloved Eukodal was no longer available, the dictator was in a frail state." But the statement "the first in 1943, when the Americans landed in Sicilia" gives us the begin date: 10th of July 1943, only 660 days before the famous suicide.
- djyaz1200 11y agoFascinating book "A First Rate Madness" goes into detail on Hitler, JFK and other leaders drug use/abuse and mental illness.
- nostromo 11y agoJFK's drug history is fascinating. The amount of drugs he was on during the Bay of Pigs alone is alarming. The world was so close to nuclear annihilation, and JFK was on a half dozen drugs, including steroids, antipsychotics, and amphetamines, from the doctor the secret service called "Dr. Feelgood." It's fascinating what presidents could get away with pre-Lewinsky. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/08/the-medical-ordeals-of-jfk/309469/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/08/the-medi...
- at-fates-hands 11y ago>> It's fascinating what presidents could get away with pre-Lewinsky. I've seen several documentaries that comment if people thought JFK was bad, LBJ was much, much worse when it came to women. There's a famous rumor about him getting caught in the oval office having sex with his secretary and afterwards, installing a buzzer so the secret service could warn him if he was wife was on her way to his office. I can only imagine how the tabloid journalists would have a heyday with this nowadays.
- eastbayjake 11y agoWhen LBJ heard people talking about JFK's affairs, he "would bang the table and declare that he had more women by accident than Kennedy ever had on purpose."[1] It got worse: At his Senate office, his female workers were fondled, ogled and overworked. Though his own figure was flabby, he was quick to berate any of his "girls" who put on weight. He wanted to make sure the view was good when they walked away from his desk. "I don't want to look at an Aunt Minnie. I want to look at a good, trim back end." He boasted of his sexual prowess and had long affairs with at least two women, as well as casual flings with members of his staff. Robert Caro, who is a dogged researcher, has uncovered the story of LBJ's previously secret relationship with Helen Gahagan Douglas, one of the few congresswomen in Washington during the 1940s. A former actress, she was an attractive blonde whose political career came to an abrupt halt after she failed to join her lover as a member of the Senate. In a dirty campaign for an open seat in California, she was defeated by a Republican newcomer who spread rumours that she was a Communist sympathiser. His name was Richard Nixon.[2] [1] http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1998/04/three-new-revelations-about-lbj/377094/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1998/04/three-ne... [2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/4728473/A-lewd-crude-Master.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/4728473/A-lewd-crude-Mast...
- 6stringmerc 11y agoIf the sources have basis in truth, even if not to the extremity put forward, it's worth keeping in mind in the context of the person's worldly outlook. That noted, when talking about the effects of drug addiction on the mind, I find it relevant to point out Ayn Rand was an amphetamine addict for 30 years[1]. As a writer myself with an alphabet of substances consumed over the years, I can attest to different drugs having different influences on what gets put to paper...the most common in the field being alcohol. There's a long tradition of people saying things they wouldn't otherwise when their inhibitions are lowered, and that seems to hold true with the written word as well in many cases. [1] http://theweek.com/articles/493764/ayn-rand-speed-addict http://theweek.com/articles/493764/ayn-rand-speed-addict
- Uhhrrr 11y agoAs well as a number of the Beat authors. When I found that out, "On The Road" suddenly made more sense.
- acqq 11y agoIt's covered at the end of the article: "There is no doubt about Hitler’s guilt; he planned the mass murder of six million people well before he began using drugs. The “total rush,” the loss of reality and megalomania have always been his state of mind"
- oxide 11y agoOxycodone aka Eukodal is not a "preform" of heroin, period. Hydrocodone, aka Vicodin, has nothing to do with heroin either. This is seriously bad drug information. they're just opiates. If you don't know, now you know. Nothing I dislike more than bad drug information being passed off as researched fact.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoWhile you're spot on with "they're all just opiates" in nature, can you explain to me why Oxycodone isn't simply called Morphine?
- S_A_P 11y agoBecause it's not morphine. Where hydrocodone is a synthetic equivalent to the natural opiate codeine, oxycodone is a synthetic opiate roughly as strong as the natural opiate morphine. There are many different synthetic opiates of various strengths but oxycodone is not "heroin" or "morphine." edit: remove spurious iPhone capitalizations..
- 6stringmerc 11y agoI follow you. The formulations are indeed areas of distinction. As I'm not educated beyond layman's terms, do they work on different receptors?
- pygy_ 11y agoNo, they all target the mu opioid receptor. I don't know if they all bind the same site of said receptors, though.
- jobu 11y agoWhat is Enkodal? Google only turned up a few German pages that didn't seem to translate well. From the article: “After World War II, the Americans who captured Morell translated the word ‘Eukodal’ as ‘Enkodal.’ They thought it was a legitimate medical treatment and dosage.”
- andyl 11y agoWhat is the lesson to be learned? Is drug use correlated with high-performance? "People felt like they always wanted to: splendid, completely calm, clearheaded; it was a golden feeling." That sounds good! I'd like that... All I've seen in drug users is wreckage and death. Maybe I haven't seen the whole picture. Is there an upside to drug use? If there was a safe performance pill maybe I would try it.
- arbitrage 11y agoVery simply, drugs make you feel awesome. That's about all there is to it. The problem comes in when you want to maintain the level of awesome ... and can't. That's when the detrimental side effects hit. You can be quite a high functioning, normal member of society with a drug habit. As long as you can pay for it, and as long as it doesn't interfere in the aspects of your life you don't want it to, one can make a rational case for continuing drug use. Think about coffee. It's great. It makes you feel great. It's socially acceptable. It's also highly addictive, and the withdrawal symptoms can be nightmarish for some people. But it's not viewed as a bad drug.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoI'm not sure where the phrase / joke / saying came from, but "I only have a drug problem when I'm out of drugs" kind of fits in with your description.
- DanBC 11y ago> All I've seen in drug users is wreckage and death. Drug use is illegal and is taboo. Many people who take drugs are not going to talk to you about it. You won't have seen a lot of drug use. You'll only have seen the worse end of drug use. You have seen plenty of people who can have a few alcoholic drinks a week? That's drug use that doesn't end in wreckage and death, even though alcohol is very harmful and very addictive. (And physically addictive, not just psychologically addictive.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jobu 11y agoIs this a legitimate article? There are few factual errors mentioned here in other comments[1][2] that have my internet bullshit detector primed, and then I see this quote from Ohler highlighted in the article: “I have a good friend, a Berlin underground DJ, who told me once that the Nazis took loads of drugs. I couldn’t believe it.” That seems like a very spurious source of knowledge about Nazi drug use. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10355245 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10355245 [2]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10355418 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10355418
- hebdo 11y agoThe fact that Hitler was a serious addict is true. He was also bipolar, and it is quite likely that the combination has contributed a lot to the beginning of the end of Operation Barbarossa in 1943 (through his faulty decision about not attacking Moscow in 1941, before winter, and before Stalin realized what is really happening). The thing to remember is that amphetamines were way more acceptable in the early 1940s (because the bad side effects were not yet that obvious), for example Wehrmacht soldiers had "superpower chocolate bars" beefed up with amphetamine. They were allowed to consume it in a dire situation. There is a lot of unnecessary buzzing happening in the article though.
- Romanulus 11y agoI think you're on the right track... From what I've heard as well was that in the later stages of the war, the army largely marched on a stomach full of meth (so to speak). Facts like those could bolster the rumor mill in propping up semi-gossip style information. I did also have a history professor say that Hitler actually went blind for a couple of days when he heard that the Americans landed on European shores.
- togusa 11y agoIt's pretty common knowledge. My grandfather, a German conscript in WWII, used to boast about how fucked up they got on amphetamines (stolen, prescribed) leading to psychosis to the point they were discharged and ordered to drive food supply trucks around instead. Lucky for him as he was in Italy and was a civilian when they surrendered.
- codeshaman 11y agoThe third reich seems to have developed a relationship with Ephedra and Poppy (plus tobacco of course). And we saw the consequences of that. I've always been fascinated by the impact of various drug-containing plants on humanity and it's history. Plants, because most drugs are extracted or synthesised from them. Shamans say that it is the 'essence' or 'spirit' of the plant that is psychoactive - you're 'inviting' another 'being' into your consciousness. Those who smoked pot have probably noticed the alternative or alien 'voice' which appears in your head and makes you think and say funny things or think paranoid thoughts. This happens with all drugs - the drug (or, in shamanic terms - the spirit of the plant) becomes one's invisible councillor - an interlocutor in the user's internal dialogue. Take tobacco - the act of smoking a cigarette is an act of 'conversing' with the plant, an act of thinking and taking decisions. Notice the impact that tobacco has had on the development of the human race - it's impossible to claim that it was responsible for all our progress, but somehow it was present in the pipes of Einstein and Oppenheimer and in the cigars smoked after a successful space mission. It was also present in the trenches of wars. Today our world is more drugged than it has ever been. Besides all the classes of illegal drugs, we also have people eating tens of thousands of various synthetic chemicals - prescription drugs - and of course making all sorts of combinations between them. What will the consequence of this chemical experimentation end up being ? Time will tell. Clearly we're doing some radical changes to how our minds and bodies work and this has a direct impact on how our society looks and behaves and what decisions are being made.
- duaneb 11y ago>Those who smoked pot have probably noticed the alternative or alien 'voice' which appears in your head and makes you think and say funny things or think paranoid thoughts. I have never experienced this. Marijuana can exacerbate existing schizophrenia or expose it. If you hear voices after consuming it, I would talk to a doctor. It can be a quite strong drug, but it does not typically cause clear, audial hallucinations. (I would more describe it as distorting and/or decomposing the audio perception, kind of like the visuals you get from lsd. Pretty, but certainly not meaningful by itself.) But, I've watched someone go through a psychotic breakdown when smoking weed the first time. They were not aware of their family history of schizophrenia until after that happened and they asked around. Be careful. :)
- MichaelGG 11y agoThis brings into question how bad the drugs actually are. Hermann Göring, lauded fighter ace, rose high up in the Nazi command. He was addicted to morphine. He didn't perform well enough in the war, but apart from the whole being-a-Nazi thing, one would say he had a rather successful career. So it really kills the whole "injected opiates will ruin your life" line. Same for Paul Erdős and amphetamines. Though amphetamines might have more long-term damaging issues (psychosis or heart issues) whereas opiates are relatively benign. This should just re-enforce the truth that the real problem with many drugs is simply legality (which causes high prices which leads non-wealth users into a spiral). With an open market, anyone with a minimum wage job could afford to be on opiates. And in a military? Seems like a given. If you have soldiers that are feeling bad or otherwise having a crisis of confidence, opiates are a fairly good way to assuage that. To make them feel everything will turn out OK. Along with speed to give them lots of energy, and an environment conducive to actually doing stuff, it seems like a good military strategy (ignoring long-term effects on soldiers). The only real question is if they made large strategic mistakes due to the opiates and thinking things will be alright no matter what. Though this article indicates a late date for Hitler's use, and it was much earlier he decided to attack the Soviet Union, so...
- thiopental 11y agoThe article makes it seem like there's a lot of news, when in fact most of what we can learn from the article about drugs in the Third Reich has already been published in the 2002 title "Nazis On Speed. Drogen im Dritten Reich." -- two volumes with a wealth of information, of which she makes zero mentions in the article. I distantly remember attending a book reading and discussion about above book in 2003 with Werner Pieper, Friedrich Kittler and others providing a good overview, a lot of serious points and some fun facts. For instance, at some point, in Paris under German occupation, Pervitin pills were a legitimate currency in Paris brothels. It can also be shown that there was an unusually high amount of animal studies performed all over the country, testing the effects of Pervitin on all kinds of species and sub-species, that don't seem to make much sense academically, but did provide steady Pervitin supplies for the research team.