3 ms·
I'd say the 95% of Americans were utterly right if you define poverty as "a standard of living which anyone raised in America would consider to be extreme pove
by notahacker 11y ago
I'd say the 95% of Americans were utterly right if you define poverty as "a standard of living which anyone raised in America would consider to be extreme poverty", as opposed to "below the income threshold of the latest World Bank redefinition", in which a person earning 10 cents per hour needs only the energy to work 90 hours per week to bootstrap their way out of extreme poverty...
- vidarh 11y agoNotably, assuming the linked PDF report of the survey is correct, when asking the question they appear to not have given any supplemental information such as a definition of extreme poverty. Which means the only thing the survey is good for is measuring peoples perception of what will likely be a very nebulous concept for most of them (e.g. I have no idea how much essentials you could get for $1.9 a day if you were actually forced to be cautious)
- BookmarkSaver 11y agoNo... The point of the survey is that 95% of Americans thought things were getting worse or staying the same. Regardless of what metric you are using, they are dead wrong. Things are getting much, much better. You are arguing about the specific definitions and qualifications of the terms. You are ignoring what the results of the survey are actually saying about the perception of Americans.
- notahacker 11y agoI'll ask you this: how many of the ~1.5 billion additional people living in the world compared with 20 years ago wouldn't be considered to be living in "extreme poverty" by US standards? (I'll give you a hint: more than half the world's present population lives on less than $5 PPP per day, few of them by choice, and it's not the richer countries where the rapid population growth is happening) If you think people earning as little as the equivalent $5 of US-equivalent purchasing power per day are extremely poor[1], that's more[2] people in extreme poverty than there were in the 1990s, despite all the incremental improvements to poor people's average incomes across the developing world and stark improvements in a few rapidly-industrialising regions. Where you draw the line matters. And the survey, notably, didn't draw a line. I'm the last person to defend Americans' knowledge of world affairs, but their belief that poverty is actually getting worse in terms of absolute numbers of people subject to it is not unreasonable. [1]which isn't exactly an unreasonable point of view for anyone used to earning more than that per hour even whilst on minimum wage, even if there's a lot of people in developing countries on that level of PPP-adjusted income that think they're doing pretty well compared with their neighbours. [2]edit: having had a play with the World Bank's model, it suggests that you end up with more people in poverty in 2012 than the early nineties if you set your threshold for extreme poverty somewhere between $5 and $6 per day of US purchasing power. The number of people below that threshold in sub-Saharan Africa - where much of the poverty relief narrative has focused - has almost doubled.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoYou keep talking about something completely different. The question wasn't based on the US standard and it didn't ask about absolute numbers. It asked about the proportion of people living in extreme poverty as defined by the WB, and their answers are completely wrong. And I don't think it's an American thing, ignorance about development issues is pretty widespread. Ask people how much they think the government spends on humanitarian/development aid and they'll say something like 25-30%, when it's about 0.18% of gdp in the US. But again it's not uniquely American. In the Netherlands they say ±6% when it's really about an order of magnitude less (just under 0.7%) for example, most people are unaware it's that low or that it has been lowered in recent years. Better yet though, the study that shows that only 5% of Americans knew the right answer was done in Sweden and Norway, too. While they do a bit better, not by much getting it right about 20% of the time, and wrong 80% of the time. (and as Hans Rosling would say, a monkey doing this test would be about 50% more accurate as an average Norwegian or Swede). Now it's a fair point, we can argue about the definitions of income all day and change definitions and have different answers that may not be very meaningful, I agree with you there. But just look at one indicator of poverty which has much less ambiguity as a statistic: child mortality under five. Kids who die, there's not a lot of room to juggle with definitions or semantics here. It's caused by societies with deeply entrenched poverty, societies that due to their poverty struggle to provide adequate healthcare, food, clean drinking water, education to parents, safe living environments etc etc. And if we look at child mortality, it more than halved since 1990, despite a much bigger population. It's now around 16 thousand per day, an astonishing number, but think about what it means, it means compared to 1990, about 6 million people (a holocaust-scale parallel is easily made) do not die every single year, year after year, that did die in 1990. That's an insane achievement and it's contrary to our public sentiment that looks at Ebola and ISIS and thinks the world is on fire and on the decline, when it's never been better. There are many more of such statistics we can look at, and they're not all expressed in some definition of poverty that changes to suit our desires. We also measure poverty in things like literacy rates, in things like the proportion of the population that has access to a toilet, or electricity, or a loan. Across the board the improvements are substantial, obviously never good enough and perpetually unable to meet our desire to solve every problem yesterday, but in the context of enormous challenges the progress we're seeing on tons of development indicators is truly inspiring and optimistic.