3 ms·
Who is "they" that should be taking this up with the American government? You seem to think this is a new policy, but it isn't. Twenty years ago, the EU wrote
by icebraining 11y ago
Who is "they" that should be taking this up with the American government? You seem to think this is a new policy, but it isn't.
Twenty years ago, the EU wrote the Data Protection Directive, which said that companies handling personal data of EU citizens much abide by certain rules. The US Department of Commerce developed a process that would supposedly allow US companies to comply with these rules even if they copy data to the US. Recently, the European Court of Justice said that the mentioned process, considering what is now known, is not enough to ensure those rules are followed.
I'm not sure what you expected the court to do. It's those corporations that should take this up with their government, not the EU court, which has no business with the US government.
- iamnotserious 11y agoI never said that it was a new policy. Let's not pretend that current generation of companies have suddenly become incredibly incompetent in maintaining privacy. This entire development was the result of Snowden's work and the general public sentiment that all their data is at the hands of the NSA. It was born out of one Austrian man's visit to SF where he was convinced going against Facebook will somehow fix everything. Penalising corporations by imposing regulations which are implicitly directed at intelligence agencies serves no real purpose. Facebook will continue to use private data to sell ads. NSA will continue to spy on EU citizens and the rest of the world. My concern was that this namesake rebuke will only lead to more mundane work for a couple engineers in large corporations and small startups being forced to use their puny funds and grappling to deal with this new development.