3 ms·
http://www.monetary.org/ http://www.monetary.org/ From the site above, and the related book, i got the impression that Rome didn't get into monetary issues unt
by digi_owl 11y ago
http://www.monetary.org/ http://www.monetary.org/
From the site above, and the related book, i got the impression that Rome didn't get into monetary issues until they started using gold and silver for foreign trade.
Internally they used "worthless" metals with few problems for generations, in large part because the "worthlessness" made them durable tokens rather than metals to hoard.
Meaning that they acted as an accounting system without a third party.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevekeen/2015/02/28/what-is-money-and-how-is-it-created/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevekeen/2015/02/28/what-is-mon...
- douche 11y agoIndia, China and the Arabian peninsula take one hundred million sesterces from our empire per annum at a conservative estimate: that is what our luxuries and women cost us. For what fraction of these imports is intended for sacrifices to the gods or the spirits of the dead? — Pliny, Historia Naturae 12.41.84. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Roman_trade_relations#Establishment) Like the rest of the world, the Romans wound up using specie when importing luxury goods from south east Asia and China. Aside from possibly glass production, there were not many goods produced in the Mediterranean that could survive transit down the Red Sea, around Arabia, and across to India on the monsoon, or overland, which were significantly higher-quality than what could be produced locally. Whereas silk, spices, incense and the like are high-value, low-bulk items, which can travel well, and are unique products not found in the Mediterranean.
- restalis 11y agoSomething that was being produced and exported from Mediterranean was jewels. At least in China the jewels were mostly jade based, any other kind of complicated jewelry was usually imported, and some of the most complicated ones, like those that were composed from layers of metal and glass, were being produced in the Roman Empire. India imported wine, which is a commodity that can survive transport and time quite well. From your quoted piece you deduce that the outflow of wealth and the disproportionate trade that most likely caused it was because of the poor selection of the trade-able goods made in the Mediterranean, but I think that it was because the Roman Empire was rich and the other markets - not so much (or at least not rich enough as markets to worth bearing the inherent risks of trade).
- douche 11y agoIndia and China produced just about everything locally that the West could export, and without having to ship it halfway around the world. Generally, they also produced higher quality manufactured goods, up until the Industrial Revolution. They also had botanical products that didn't grow in Europe, or were state secrets (like serriculture), which were desirable. Until the BEIC hooked a sizable part of southern China on opium, about the only reliable trade good was cold, hard cash. It's kind of hilarious to read through the annals of the British East India Company[1], for example. On their initial expeditions, they loaded ships full of wool, English broadcloth, leather, and other kinds of trade goods that they might shuttle around the Baltic Sea trade. When they got to Malabar or Indonesia, they realized these trade goods were basically worthless - on a couple of expeditions they were lucky enough to capture Spanish or Portuguese ships loaded with Indian cotton goods that it turned out could be traded for peppercorns or nutmegs, on others they had to use what little gold and silver they were allowed to ship. The silk, ceramic and tea trade to China vacuumed up a huge percentage of the output of the Spanish New World silver and gold mines. So much Peruvian silver came into Ming and Qing China that it wrecked the conversion rates between gold, silver and cash currency, and much of the mercantilist economic studies of the period were focused on finding ways to get the balance of trade to result in specie coming into, e.g England, rather than going out. I enjoy that Pliny quote, because it highlights the same problems of international trade in the Roman Republic that the various East India companies experienced. [1] https://archive.org/details/annalshonorable03brucgoog https://archive.org/details/annalshonorable03brucgoog
- restalis 11y ago"India and China produced just about everything locally that the West could export" Before I begin, let me say that "the West" is a very political term of the actual times and we were talking about the ancient times. Let's try to keep our heads lucid by avoiding sensitive topics, by avoiding blame casting (related to opium), and other such things. Now, pretty much every community in the ancient times "produced just about everything locally", at least everything they needed. Trade usually happens because of cultural differences (even when these differences are induced by other natural factors, like climate), and it just happened that the cultures in question (Roman, Indian, and Chinese) were different enough. Who were the usual consumers of the imported goods? Not the average Joes, mind you! They were the ones that: first - were open to appreciate foreign things for any reason (exotic tastes, cosmopolitan nature, etc.), and second - could afford to! You may assume here that for various reasons the Indian and Chinese high class could have been more closed and not so interested in foreign products, preferring only the good ol' local produced things, but I don't. I don't want to think that their nature was somehow lesser in this regard (because I like to consider human to be equals about that), and I prefer to assume that even if they wanted to, their collective potential that formed the market depth was not deep enough. India accepted the Roman gold. That's because Rome happened to have it (from its conquests, mostly), whereas India did not so much! A steep difference of their historical evolution that ultimately shaped their cultures and trade, you see? Another kind of cultural difference between Roman Empire and China shaped the trade between them. Who were the consumers of luxury goods in Roman Empire? Women, mostly! Did women in China have the same leeway in shopping spree? No! That's because unlike the women in the Roman Empire, which enjoyed equal social status with men, and many other things, women in ancient China bared a lower social status in comparison! So, another big cultural difference that heavily shaped the nature of commerce between Roman Empire and China. I'm glad to enlighten, thank you!