3 ms·
Price-performance ratios for CPUs are completely bogus, because you never run a CPU by itself. If your case/power supply/motherboard/RAM/disk collectively $400
by cperciva 17y ago
Price-performance ratios for CPUs are completely bogus, because you never run a CPU by itself. If your case/power supply/motherboard/RAM/disk collectively $400 and you have a choice between a $100 CPU with performance X and a $200 CPU with performance 1.5 X, the faster CPU has a performance/price ratio which is 25% worse -- but using the faster CPU gives you a system with a performance/price ratio which is 25% better.
- boredguy8 17y agoAssuming the CPU is the bottleneck, which I'm not sure it would be for a $400 systems-sans-cpu.
- cperciva 17y agoSure. All performance tuning depends on figuring out where the bottlenecks are; but having found said bottlenecks, many people make the mistake of considering price/performance ratios for those individual components rather than for the system as a whole. This isn't just relevant for CPU performance -- people do exactly the same thing with disks. If you want the most disk space for the least expense, it's worth buying 2 TB drives even if they're more than 2x as expensive as 1 TB drives.
- wisty 17y agoAre you sure? A 2T drive puts all your eggs in one basket if it happens to fail. And you can't RAID it (though you can't RAID 2 x 1T disks either, unless you are crazy and want to strip). I still find it a useful list. It lets you focus on the stuff you know is well priced. My priorities for stuff to splurge on - PSU, case and cooling (all very important to protect your other gear, and reusable), monitor (since you'll probably be stuck with it for 10 years, and it pays off even when you are doing lightweight stuff like reading yc), hard drives, then finally RAM, CPU and mobo (in that order). For gamers, 3D card and a faster memory path (recent CPU, good mobo, fast RAM) are probably more important. But we always get sucked into caring about the CPU, for some primal reason.
- Tuna-Fish 17y agoThat is assuming CPU is the defining factor in the speed of your computer. For vast majority of users, this is just plain false -- a 60$ Athlon II dual core with a 200$ SSD massively outperforms a 950$ i7 975 that is paired with a traditional HD in nearly all of the use cases a normal desktop user encounters -- And if you are into gaming, that same 60$ processor paired with a 300$ HD5870 high-end graphics card easily outperforms the same i7 paired with HD5850, the next-best model that costs only 50$ less.
- manvsmachine 17y agoGood point, but not always true. It's a myth that game performance is universally GPU-bound. Most notably, most MMORPG's, many RTS's and pretty much anything made with the Source engine are more dependent on CPU performance.