4 ms·
It's a function of both. Pack enough people into a small enough area and the support + infrastructure gets really, really expensive. There are many stupidities
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
It's a function of both. Pack enough people into a small enough area and the support + infrastructure gets really, really expensive.
There are many stupidities in the original piece, but one significant one is the apparent lack of understanding that cities have to be supported by political, financial and physical infrastructures which extend far outside the geographic boundaries.
The effective footprints of London, NY, and HK stretch across the world. So you can make an argument for effective economic and ecological density being very much lower than the density you get from a naive division of population by immediate area.
When the effective density is much more constrained, you don't just get financial poverty, you get somewhere that's a shitty place to live in many different ways.
And when there's no political understanding of what an effective footprint is, you get disasters like the California drought - which is largely the result of to appreciate that water is a limited resource that comes from elsewhere, and has to flow into an area before anyone can use it.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoGenerally speaking, you don't get financial poverty at all as a result of density. You get wealth. London is wealthier than the rest of the UK. NYC is wealthier than the rest of the US. Hong Kong is the wealthiest city in China. Mumbai is the wealthiest city in India, unless Delhi has surpassed it since I last checked. I haven't checked, but I'd bet 5:1 odds that Dhaka is significantly wealthier than the rest of Bangladesh. The California drought is primarily caused by inefficient use of water in agriculture. City usage of water is pretty much irrelevant.
- xixi77 11y agoThat's a completely different argument though -- the way I read the article, this is about internal density of cities specifically. In particular, iirc the resource consumption of a person living in a dense city is shown to be smaller compared to that of a same-income person living in a low-density city or a suburb, so dense cities should contribute to a reduction in effective density that you are talking about here.