3 ms·
The only problem with this is that this will be a zero sum game. If peak power consumption drops electric companies will start charging higher rates for off-pe
by dogma1138 11y ago
The only problem with this is that this will be a zero sum game.
If peak power consumption drops electric companies will start charging higher rates for off-peak hours or drop the off-peak rate completely.
Anything that will eventually lower the revenue of the electrical companies won't really be supported by them, however if they can employ batteries to "flatten" their peaks they might be contempt with keeping the current rates as long as is financially beneficial for them.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The only problem with this is that this will be a zero sum game. If peak power consumption drops electric companies will start charging higher rates for off-peak hours or drop the off-peak rate completely. Which will push those who can to local rooftop solar generation. We've already entered what the utilities refer to as a "death spiral" [+]. > Anything that will eventually lower the revenue of the electrical companies won't really be supported by them, however if they can employ batteries to "flatten" their peaks they might be contempt with keeping the current rates as long as is financially beneficial for them. Agree. [+] http://cleantechnica.com/2015/06/11/graph-of-the-day-what-a-utility-death-spiral-looks-like/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/06/11/graph-of-the-day-what-a-...
- dogma1138 11y agoSolar is still very expensive at around 10K$ an upwards in the US and considerably more expensive in Europe, solar is also not an option for the majority of residents in the big cities where electrical supply is usually a bigger issue. I'm personally not a big believer in residential solar, it can't be as efficient as dedicated solar installations and the cost overhead for so many small scale installations pretty much outweigh the benefits in the long run. I do however believe that many smaller communities should be powered with renewable energy where possible. It can allow you to build much bigger and more efficient installations of wind and solar, won't require you to convert it to high voltage in order to connect it back to the grid/transfer it along large distances and your energy storage is also much easier.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Solar is still very expensive at around 10K$ an upwards in the US and considerably more expensive in Europe, solar is also not an option for the majority of residents in the big cities where electrical supply is usually a bigger issue. It's $3.50/watt fully installed in the US currently. There is a 30% tax credit that expires at the end of 2016 (drops to 10%). That's a great deal for a system that will generate power (warrantied) for 25+ years. If you're in the city or someplace you can't get rooftop solar, you can usually purchase wind or solar specifically from your utility (depending on local utility regulations and laws). > I'm personally not a big believer in residential solar, it can't be as efficient as dedicated solar installations and the cost overhead for so many small scale installations pretty much outweigh the benefits in the long run. I do however believe that many smaller communities should be powered with renewable energy where possible. It can allow you to build much bigger and more efficient installations of wind and solar, won't require you to convert it to high voltage in order to connect it back to the grid/transfer it along large distances and your energy storage is also much easier. Renewables should be installed wherever feasible, whether on rooftops or at utility installations. We need every clean watt we can get.
- dogma1138 11y agoYeah you can purchase solar/wind from your utility provider usually at a huge premium, that combined with usually less efficient power infrastructure, single rate meters, and apartments which tend to be less energy efficient than private houses means that you either need to be quite well off or very dedicated to pay it. Yes renewables should be installed where feasible, but actually feasible not feasible because it's cool, good PR, or under the current tax credits efficient. Small installations are costly, you spend quite a bit of energy in installing individual setups, and maintaining them in terms of efficiency you are better off centralizing your efforts if you really care about the environmental foot print.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Yeah you can purchase solar/wind from your utility provider usually at a huge premium, that combined with usually less efficient power infrastructure, single rate meters, and apartments which tend to be less energy efficient than private houses means that you either need to be quite well off or very dedicated to pay it. It's only about 2-4 cents more per kwh to get 100% renewables. I don't find that to be a "huge premium", nor do you need to be "well to do" to afford that. If we properly priced the cost of coal and other dirty fuels into their per kwh costs, renewables would win by default. > Yes renewables should be installed where feasible, but actually feasible not feasible because it's cool, good PR, or under the current tax credits efficient. Small installations are costly, you spend quite a bit of energy in installing individual setups, and maintaining them in terms of efficiency you are better off centralizing your efforts if you really care about the environmental foot print. We'll agree to disagree! I'm not worried, as tax credits will be around for another 14-15 months, at which point solar and wind will be even cheaper than they are now.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIt's not zero sum. The peak hours are when electricity is most expensive to generate. And transmission lines etc. need to be sized to the peak. That's one of the reasons that rooftop solar actually makes a lot of economic sense anywhere that aircon is used. However, the people who generate that electricity receive no direct reward and will probably be accused, by the very utility that benefits, of being subsidy junkies or parasites. When utilities have calculated the "value of solar" its come out as much higher than the price currently paid to homeowners.
- caseysoftware 11y agoExactly. Personally, I love the idea of neighborhood-level collection and distribution. If everyone is collecting throughout the high-output times, when the high demand times come, less has to come from the overall grid. Also, when power is cut/damaged for an area, systems could be smart enough to prioritize across the neighborhood. Imagine a system that keeps the refrigerators and freezers running - to protect food - but doesn't run the AC or dishwasher or lights. Not perfect but way better than losing food.
- dogma1138 11y agoIt's a zero sum game from the point of the consumer, if you "exploit" the current day/night difference and the electric companies start to lose money they'll increase the tariffs to compensate.
- caseysoftware 11y agoIf dollars are the only thing you're counting. But I said nothing about money that in my comment.