3 ms·
There has never been clear consensus over the ethical acceptability of acts hostile to specific individuals while also being beneficial to public safety. My op
by logfromblammo 11y ago
There has never been clear consensus over the ethical acceptability of acts hostile to specific individuals while also being beneficial to public safety.
My opinion is that forced vaccination is acceptable when everyone receives uniform compensation for their loss of self-determination, with prepaid care for all side effects and complications. That means whomever is doing the forcing has to weigh the benefits of universal vaccination against the massive additional cost for compensation and insurance.
So you're not going to force vaccinations for rhinovirus. You might for smallpox, or polio, or ebola, or something else that costs a hell of a lot to control by other means.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoAnd when duly constituted authority orders it. Random teams of doctors don't get to decide to order it, even if they're willing to take on the cost of compensation and insurance. And, in the actual situation we're talking about, those doing it did not take on the cost of compensation and insurance.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThere is no such thing as duly constituted authority when you are forcing people to do things against their will. There is only the ability to enforce your edict, and possibly also the ability to offer reasonable compensation to your victims. The concept of authority is simply a synonym for overwhelming force in my ethical reasoning, wherein any reasonable person would flee it or surrender to it rather than openly resist it. So when you say duly constituted authority that just tells me that the teams of doctors have enough men with guns behind them that they don't have to bother with explaining their actions or chasing down stragglers. In the situation under discussion, the cost of compensation would certainly be little more than pocket change, especially given that the victims may not have even noticed the intrusion, or even the more invasive prior compromises. And we don't know the actual cost of damages to the victims. The grey-hats' failing was in not allocating resources for those things, however small they may be, before launching the program. Did they sit down and ask themselves, "What will we do for the people who don't think we're doing the right thing?" and "How will we fix anything we might screw up with this?" If not, they probably should have, but now that the deed is done, I won't get worked up over it.