3 ms·
In partial response to tokenadult: There's absolutely no question that cognitive therapy (nowadays cognitive behavioral therapy) is a critical tool in fighting
by hga 17y ago
In partial response to tokenadult: There's absolutely no question that cognitive therapy (nowadays cognitive behavioral therapy) is a critical tool in fighting depression. On the other hand, it costs a lot more money than the "band-aid" of a 15 minute visit with a psychiatrist and an prescription of antidepressant. And "bending the cost curve" is the current zeitgeist....
The description of this study raises a few questions in my mind:
It's a meta-analysis of 6 studies, half with Paxil (paroxetine, which went generic years ago) and the other half with imipramine, which is the Gold Standard in the previous (pre-Prozac) generation of antidepressants. I'm a little uncomfortable with their using Paxil as a proxy for all the current generation drugs, e.g. not all are SSRIs, Lexapro is interesting because it's laser selective in acting only on serotonin, etc. etc.
Just to bring in some anecdotal experience: I have somewhat refractory depression of a bipolar nature (I only go manic when taking the wrong antidepressant, e.g. Paxil :-) and I've tried all of the above drugs plus Serzone.
Self administered cognitive therapy made a big difference (to the point that talking therapy afterwords has been entirely useless).
When things get bad enough, each of the above drugs made a difference, but weren't "miracles". And each was different in their own ways, not just in terms of side effects (the new generation is much better) but in terms of how they worked and how well. And it's well known that if a patient doesn't respond to the first drug at a sufficient dose, you try another till you (hopefully) find one that works.
The whole field is at an extremely primitive state, akin to poking at the brain with sticks. We've observed that sticks with certain shapes have good effects, and we've guessed why, but the distance from those guesses to what's really happening in terms of mood is huge.
So I wouldn't be inclined to push this study too hard, except to note what's no surprise to anyone, I'd think, that those with less severe symptoms get less benefit from these drugs. But I confess I'm not too interested in that issue, mine is how to treat the hard cases like myself and a few of my friends. And for us, antidepressants are most certainly a part of the picture.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe whole field is at an extremely primitive state, akin to poking at the brain with sticks. Yes, there is still MUCH work to be done on the issue of treating human mood disorders. And your point is entirely correct that a cost-benefit model of evaluating treatments tends to make cognitive approaches to treatment delivered by any person other the patient doing self-help look too expensive (as compared to prescription medicines with very occasional psychiatrist office visits). I've been a lot more interested in prompting discussion of mood disorder treament on HN since one thread a few months ago in which a participant (perhaps using a screen name just for that thread) mentioned having repeated bouts of depression that appeared to be seasonal and were definitely recurrent. That thread had many comments self-reporting the same phenomenon in other HN participants. Then, sadly, a few days later it was announced that a YC co-founder with high HN karma had committed suicide. I hope that if one person's anecdote is "antidepressant medication X didn't help me," the response will be "maybe your individual pattern of mood disorder is better helped by another medicine," rather than "people should try in all cases to do without medicine." It does appear to be consistent with the newly reported meta-analysis to say "people with severe depression should definitely try out medicines under medical supervision while also trying out other therapies" while people with milder cases of depression may not notice drug benefits much, but may still benefit from other therapies. I agree that people with the hard cases should keep seeking help and not give up. There is help even for those cases, although it is discouraging that the help can't be specified just by a simple blood test or something of that kind.