6 ms·
> One current dominant media narrative is that any sort of intolerant thought is intolerable, and that the emotional state of a listener is the responsibility o
by pron 11y ago
> One current dominant media narrative is that any sort of intolerant thought is intolerable, and that the emotional state of a listener is the responsibility of the speaker.
Speaking out against gay-marriage is intolerant. Threatening blacks or publicly shaming fat people is violent speech. Violent speech is not a problem because of the "emotional state of the listener". It is a problem because it creates an atmosphere of fear, and fear is a means of oppression. Sure, fear is an emotional state. But if I point a gun to your head, I think most would agree that society should place the blame on your emotional state in my gun-holding hand.
> which is why it is a narrative, not actual reporting
Except that this is actual reporting. I had never read anything (good or bad) about Reddit (wasn't interested) until I started visiting the site (which has lots of great stuff, too), and was amazed at what was going on there. Because most threats weren't aimed at me, I found it fascinating, but I could clearly see how it could really make others afraid.
> Shame and guilt don't really ever teach the lesson that is intended, but those are the only tools the media truly has.
Shaming those who create an atmosphere of fear is not a goal. The goal is to take that fear away. Besides, it seems like you're bemoaning the fact that some sort of speech is more effective than others. Maybe that's a lesson for those who call for free verbal-abuse-and-bullying to make better use of their speech? They should most certainly regard this as a lesson.
- rhizome 11y agoWords are not guns, period.
- pron 11y agoTrue, and pointing a gun isn't firing it, and some people feel even guns don't require regulation. But that doesn't mean verbal violence doesn't cause real harm and shouldn't be regulated, and in fact, it is regulated in virtually all free societies (and even non-free ones). The debate is on the degree to which it should be regulated, and this varies from one society to another. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech In any case, the ideal of free speech originated in the desire to share novel ideas and speak truth to power. It's sad to see the same term used to justify tolerating bullying by angry mobs.
- mreiland 11y ago> verbal violence Is not a thing, you mean verbal abuse. equating verbal abuse with physical abuse doesn't make your point genuine, what it does is cause those of us who employ critical thinking to disregard your opinions as those of an unreasonable person. Words can be important, but you cannot try to manipulate language in order to alter reality without alienating a lot of people from your cause.
- pron 11y ago> you mean verbal abuse Right. Sorry, English is not my native language. In my native language, verbal abuse is called verbal violence. > what it does is cause those of us who employ critical thinking to disregard your opinions as those of an unreasonable person. It really doesn't.
- mreiland 11y agoI'm curious which country you're from. Googling the term pulls up a few the wiki article for verbal abuse, but even that article makes no mention of violence. The closes you can find are a few blog opinion pieces where people are doing exactly what you're doing, attempting to equate verbal abuse with physical violence. I would be interested in learning more. As for your response, you don't get to tell me how I react to people. Blunt, but true.
- pron 11y ago> Googling the term pulls up a few the wiki article for verbal abuse, but even that article makes no mention of violence Well, pull up Google translate and see which languages translate "verbal abuse" as "verbal violence". There are more than one, but I'm sure the process would be very educational. > exactly what you're doing, attempting to equate verbal abuse with physical violence. I never did such thing just as I don't equate murder with theft when I call them both crimes, or 53 with 75 if I call them both positive integers. Equating means putting things on the same level, not in the same category. I'm not even sure I did that. I may have only made an analogy, which is a rhetorical device using comparison to draw attention to specific properties with similar function in different categories in order to assist in understanding or viewing a subject from a certain perspective. > As for your response, you don't get to tell me how I react to people. Blunt, but true. I didn't. Blunt, but true. ---------------------- P.S. Your reaction, however, perhaps ironically, raises a difference between physical and verbal abuse (although, just to make sure -- I've never said there wasn't any), which is people who are victims of physical abuse usually know it, but those who are victims of verbal abuse may not. This opens the door to some very interesting discussions no only on the nature of humiliation (e.g. most people would agree that humiliation causes harm even if the humiliated is not aware of the humiliation if there are spectators), but also on the very core of ethics (and in particular ethical naturalism vs. non-naturalism and phenomenology).
- Nadya 11y ago>Speaking out against gay-marriage is intolerant. Are you tolerant of other peoples' religious beliefs? If so to what extent? I find people are quick to defend certain religious beliefs and people's right to believe in them; but start drawing lines where religious beliefs don't mingle well with their own personal beliefs. For example - a Jew's right to avoid pork and shellfish is respected but the right for an evangelical Christian to avoid people they see as ultimate sinners who could soil them and send them to hell for eternity is completely disregarded and not tolerated at all. >It is a problem because it creates an atmosphere of fear If I were a hell-fearing Christian I would be very understanding of being afraid of going to Hell and being afraid of anyone who might increase my chances of doing so. The issue is you do not have a concept of sin or that your interpretation of the Bible (and thus sin) differs from theirs. From their religious perspective, you're in the wrong. You're a sinner - and a good Christian doesn't listen to sinners. That's how you go to Hell. From their perspective it's very logical to not want to go to Hell and to condemn sinners. The issue stems from you not being tolerant or understanding of their religious beliefs. What's my point here? It's that arguing between right or wrong will depend entirely on beliefs. You believe you are right so they must be intolerant - they believe they are right so you must be intolerant.
- CocaKoala 11y ago>For example - a Jew's right to avoid pork and shellfish is respected but the right for an evangelical Christian to avoid people they see as ultimate sinners who could soil them and send them to hell for eternity is completely disregarded and not tolerated at all. The right for evangelican Christians to avoid people they see as sinners is respected just as much as the right for Jews to avoid pork and shellfish is; nobody forces a Jewish person to eat pork, and nobody forces evangelical Christians to interact with sinners. The right of evangelical Christians to enforce their beliefs on others, i.e. by making it illegal for homosexuals to get married, is a very different right, and you haven't made an argument for why that right should be respected at all; should Jews be allowed to shut down a restaurant just because that restaurant happens to serve pork or shellfish?
- Nadya 11y ago
- brazzledazzle 11y ago>publicly shaming fat people is violent speech. I don't dig generic jabs at fat people since it's in bad taste (calling out fat people that try to say being fat is healthy is another thing entirely) but I'm not sure how it's "violent". To go off on a bit of a tangent: Don't get me wrong, I know the power words have since I was bullied for several years. I also understand how much of a struggle weight loss can be. But part of the reason that those words are so powerfully negative for a fat person is because of the shame they already feel for being obese, unhealthy and having no self control. Besides the rare medical exception these people are in a bad place mentally and physically. Hiding external confirmation of what you already know about yourself doesn't do anything but reenforce the downward spiral of self destruction.