5 ms·
I think reddit's issues stem from a simple case of failing to manage expectations -- the users got the idea that Reddit was a bastion of free speech where they
by twblalock 11y ago
I think reddit's issues stem from a simple case of failing to manage expectations -- the users got the idea that Reddit was a bastion of free speech where they could post anything, no matter how offensive. Apparently the corporation never really believed that, despite some of its representatives making statements that seemed to confirm it.
Reddit ought to have been more straightforward with its content policy from the beginning. Some would argue that such a policy would have restricted the growth of reddit, but I think that as long as the content policy was not enforced in a heavy-handed manner, it would not have caused issues.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoThis is a very good point. For what Reddit has traditionally aspired to be, versus how it works, e.g. as an ebb and flow of community standards, it's a rock and a hard place in my opinion. Somewhere I've seen the perspective put forth that Reddit is essentially the gateway for things from 4Chan (etc) to make it into the mainstream, and I kind of buy into that.
- TarpitCarnivore 11y agoOne thing I've always found interesting with Reddit related news is users will say things like "You (Reddit) never told us..." or other similar statement. It just always came across as an odd sense of entitlement as if Reddit should run every idea, change or whatever by their users for approval.
- twblalock 11y agoSome users seem to feel like they are the true owners of the site, and that the corporation exists to serve them and fulfill their needs. This is another example of the corporation's failure to manage expectations. They seem to have lost control over the site they created.
- dgritsko 11y agoIsn't there an element of truth to that sentiment though? The situation with Reddit is reminiscent in some ways to Digg's downfall with the release of v4 (which ironically contributed significantly to Reddit's growth). What is Reddit without its users?
- twblalock 11y agoI'm sure Condé Nast has been asking themselves that question a lot lately.
- TarpitCarnivore 11y agoIs Reddit now directly comparable to Digg v3 -> v4? I feel like because Reddit has so many subs it can easily survive without people in some of the larger subs. When all the drama was happening a few months some sub reddits I read had a fair amount of members who had no clue anything was going on. I guess the way I'm thinking of it as is the vocal majority the right representation and worry for reddit? Think about the petition they tried to get going. The number of signatures was minuscule comparative to the total number of users.
- jtuente 11y agoI think that just exacerbates the problem though as the "power users" of reddit move away from the vitriol of the default subreddits, the vitriol becomes more visible on the surface. So the larger subs end up less and less attractive to users new and old.
- TarpitCarnivore 11y agoI understand this can work with some communities of smaller scale (here or MetaFilter) but I feel like Reddit is well beyond a tight, niche community. I would say that line of think is more appropriate for sub reddits.
- EdiX 11y ago> Some users seem to feel like they are the true owners of the site, and that the corporation exists to serve them and fulfill their needs So you think that reddit has any value at all after you remove the top 20% of users that generate 80% of the content? I think those users you speak about are fairly accurate in their assessment.
- Nadya 11y agoWhen your users quite literally run the site by adding and commenting on content - the user has all the power by design. Without the users, you have no content and without content you have no visitors and without visitors you have no advertisers. Do something your user base disagrees with? They'll go elsewhere. The site then dies out into obscurity like Digg and a new site will take over.
- tsotha 11y agoNot just adding and commenting - the users also moderate. IMO reddit users, particularly people who post topics and/or moderate, have every reason to feel some ownership. Not that they own it technically. But like you say, reddit dies if they leave.
- wodenokoto 11y agoIN the early days new features were almost always presented as ideas from the community. Subreddits started as a way to categorize posts, due to a certain influx of meme's and some users said "hey, can't we mark them, so I do t have to see them" and then later these tags developed into forums of their own. Apparently the idea was actually from Paul Graham, but it was never presented as a corporate idea.
- gherkin0 11y ago> an odd sense of entitlement as if Reddit should run every idea, change or whatever by their users for approval I think that's because Reddit has fostered the idea that its users form real communities and it has let them self-administer to a large extent. In modern society, that comes with expectations of something like a democratic process. People then get angry when Reddit violates those expectations and acts like an autocratic corporation.
- pron 11y agoThat is the issue for a (vocal) 1% of users who think that a bastion of free speech means a bastion of threats, shaming and bullying. The issue for 99% of users -- and therefore the actual issue for Reddit -- is that other 1%, that has made Reddit creepy, off-putting and downright scary. 99% of users couldn't care less about an unclear content policy or its heavy-handed enforcement because they've just never wanted to bully or shame anyone on Reddit.
- michaelt 11y agoParticularly in America, a lot of people interpret freedom of speech to include allowing hate speech. These people would say that you can't be a bastion of free speech and ban hate speech at the same time, so if Reddit has banned hate speech it means they're not a bastion of free speech. IMHO there's nothing wrong with /not/ being a bastion of free speech, though. Who'd want to be, given what it entails?
- 15155 11y agoIt's because "hate speech" must be defined by someone, and who is(/are) that someone(s)? Hate speech is protected by the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America. (see R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul, Snyder v. Phelps) If you disagree with that premise, you're free to lobby for a an amendment. If you're banning hate speech, you're not a bastion of free speech in the United States of America. I think if a company is more restrictive than the country you're incorporated in (reddit, inc. is a Delaware corporation), "not a bastion of free speech" is a fair description. Totally agree with you that there's nothing wrong with being restrictive (this is HN, after all, also not a bastion of free speech).
- rodgerd 11y ago> the users got the idea that Reddit was a bastion of free speech where they could post anything, no matter how offensive Except they don't - because the people yelling most about "free speech" are the first to throw a hissy fit when someone uses "free speech" to suggest that they're being racist or sexist or whatever. They believe in consequence-free speech, where they get to say whatever they want, and no-one is allowed to talk back, or even ignore them.
- copsarebastards 11y ago> Except they don't - because the people yelling most about "free speech" are the first to throw a hissy fit when someone uses "free speech" to suggest that they're being racist or sexist or whatever. What do you mean by "throw a hissy fit"? There's a difference between disagreeing with someone and saying they should not be allowed to say what they are saying. People who are saying that they are "triggered" when someone uses the word "rape" and therefore people should not be able to say the word "rape" are against free speech. If someone calls me sexist for saying that, I'll ridicule their opinion because their opinion is ridiculous, but I still they should be allowed to state their ridiculous opinion. The former is anti-free speech. The latter is not. Simply telling someone they are wrong is not taking a stance against free speech.
- taco_emoji 11y agoAmazing. Person A: "Certain conversations are sometimes hard for me to deal with, and trigger warnings are good and helpful for me." Person B: "I agree, and I think that you're even kind of a jerk if you don't provide such warnings." Delusional outrage addicts: "YOU GUYS WANT TO BAN WORDS"
- copsarebastards 11y agoUh, have you even been on Reddit? There are definitely people who want to ban words. But even without going that extreme, Person B in your example is way off-base. There's nothing wrong with Person A, they're just experiencing an unfortunate mental illness. But Person B is creating this moral obligation for everyone to participate in the treatment of Person A's mental illness, and that's an obligation which simply does not exist. It sucks that Person A is sick, and I'd even be happy to devote more of my tax dollars to help them, but I don't think that we should be curtailing our free speech to help treat the vast array of possible mental illnesses we might encounter on the internet.