3 ms·
> If you want to reject it on principle alone, you'll have to address why your liberty in principle is more important than my health concern in practice. Nope,
by Someone1234 11y ago
> If you want to reject it on principle alone, you'll have to address why your liberty in principle is more important than my health concern in practice.
Nope, they really don't.
The default should not be for the state to force someone to inject a substance into their body, and if they refuse or raise concern, that it is then on them to explain/justify why NOT. The state should justify why they're doing it, and make a good case to each individual so they make the right choice.
If you think the first amendment is an important right in the US, then the right to not have complex chemicals and or living organisms injected into your body should be an even higher right (since you're entrusting your very health on the state).
I fully support vaccines and we are CHOOSING to vaccinate our kid. I understand herd immunity, but your fear doesn't trump other people's individual rights.
I dislike both anti-vaxxers AND forced-vaxxers. One is scientifically ignorant and the other is morally bankrupt. Pick your poison I guess.
- ceejayoz 11y agoI'm fine with "you can't force me to get vaccinated" if it includes an acceptance of civil liability should you be part of an outbreak of vaccine-preventable disease.
- Someone1234 11y agoThat's just petty. Even assuming liability, you cannot sue dead people back to life, or sue an epidemic away. So, no, that is silly and helps nobody. If you're going to do that just go full hog and fine people, at least it doesn't feel like petty revenge. Ultimately it is the fact that vaccines AREN'T required that forces the government to spend the time, resources, and effort promoting vaccines. Without that they can just arbitrarily start demanding we inject things and outright reject all requests for information/data/etc. We are actually in a good-ish place. Most of the population is vaccinated, there's plenty of data on vaccinations available to the public, and many of the concerns have been debunked using good solid science which cannot easily be refuted. Essentially the forced-vaccination people are arguing for worse science, they just haven't figured that out yet because they aren't looking far enough into the future. If they are forced, what is the justification for the science? Or are you just going to rely on other countries where it isn't mandated for the science (in particular follow up studies)?
- ceejayoz 11y ago> That's just petty. As the parent of twins born the day before the third trimester, I assure you my motivations here are not petty. > Even assuming liability, you cannot sue dead people back to life, or sue an epidemic away. Negligent homicide is punishable both civilly and criminally in most other situations. Why not in refusing to be vaccinated? > We are actually in a good-ish place. Most of the population is vaccinated, there's plenty of data on vaccinations available to the public, and many of the concerns have been debunked using good solid science which cannot easily be refuted. And we're finding that a certain percentage of the population is immune to scientific refutation. They're not going away, and they're causing some areas to drop below herd immunity levels. http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/01/27/californias-epidemic-of-vaccine-denial-mapped/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/01/27/ca...
- Karunamon 11y agoNegligent homicide is punishable both civilly and criminally in most other situations. Why not in refusing to be vaccinated? Because it doesn't actually do anything with the problem of there possibly being an outbreak of some disease with the potential for widespread death. Okay, great, you can hold the one person accountable for not vaccinating their kids liable for the deaths of ten people. Fantastic. Ten people still died. Our justice system is very much a "If X, then Y" system - but what if your goal is not to deal with X the consequences of X, but to prevent it in the first place? You could argue the deterrent effect, but if someone is irrational enough to ignore the conclusive logic that vaccines prevent you from getting sick, they're probably not going to be much more convinced by a (low) possibility that they might end up in front of a court and possible face prison. (And that's even if it can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the one person not getting vaccinated was the direct cause of the deaths beyond a reasonable doubt)
- arethuza 11y ago> That's just petty. I think it's pretty fair actually - I don't want anyone (particularly children) to be forcibly vaccinated. But people should realize that choosing not to be vaccinated may cause harm to others and in that case it seems fair to be able to obtain compensation via the courts.
- aggie 11y ago> The default should not be for the state to force someone to... I agree. > The state should justify why they're doing it And they do: herd immunity, which is supported by convincing scientific evidence. I didn't say liberty should be violated by default. We are no longer in a default position -- the argument has already been made and it is apparent that vaccination is justified as a social good. As a member of a society, sometimes social good takes priority over individual liberty. My argument is that if people still want to reject it, they need to explain why their liberty should come before others' health. (This is a rhetorical request I don't expect someone will be able to convince me of, though some may hold this view.)
- tracker1 11y agoYou have no right to be protected from getting sick... One's personal liberties should generally extend just shy of infringing on an other's rights.. That should be the default. That said I'm not an anti-vaxxer, but I'm medically unable to take most of them now as they would dramatically increase the chance of a deadly side effect. Once in my life was enough (and the 6-figure hospital bill after insurance cap), and a 5% chance of reoccurrence is bad enough without tempting fate to make that risk much higher.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> You have no right to be protected from getting sick... Conversely, you have no right to infect other people (this is a unconsented harm inflicted on others, the most basic thing that is a violation of rights.) To the extent that doing so is neither intentional, reckless, nor negligent, you also shouldn't be held responsible to prevent doing so -- the question with mandatory vaccination largely boils down to whether failing to use particular vaccinations without a special medical reason is such a failing of a duty of care.
- tracker1 11y agoGood luck tracking down and suing patient 0.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The default should not be for the state to force someone to inject a substance into their body, and if they refuse or raise concern, that it is then on them to explain/justify why NOT. Even most "mandatory" vaccination regimes don't generally do this. They require people to vaccinate themselves (or, most often, their children) if they are medically able to be vaccinated as a precondition of use of certain public accommodations, as a means of protecting the health of other users of the same accommodation, including especially, but not exclusively, those medically unable to be vaccinated.