4 ms·
It could still be a civil suit - if someone actually got sick because you weren't vaccinated, they could sue you for damages. Also, once you give the governmen
by sp332 11y ago
It could still be a civil suit - if someone actually got sick because you weren't vaccinated, they could sue you for damages.
Also, once you give the government the authority to require people to be injected, they will probably start expanding it in various directions. That's really not a power I want to give to them.
- chaosphere2112 11y agoThe government has had this authority since 1905 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobson_v._Massachusetts); https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobson_v._Massachusetts); there's no "giving them" this power, they've had it for over 100 years.
- grotsnot 11y agoThat's the sort of tragedy-of-the-commons style fault that is prohibitively difficult to prove is due to a specific individual. Governments exist to solve such coordination problems.
- valarauca1 11y agoAppeal to fear is a logical fallacy not a rational argument. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_fear https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_fear
- jack9 11y agoRegardless of a fallacy or not, it's effective. So the argument works. Dealing with the populace, citing wikipedia doesn't get you very far.
- filoeleven 11y agoIf someone got sick because you weren't vaccinated, does that not imply that they were also not vaccinated? Or are there cases where e.g. you can only get vaccinated as an adult, and you're suggesting a civil suit if you infect a child?
- DanBC 11y agoVaccines are not 100% effective. Some people are unable to take vaccinations. That's why we want to vaccinate as many people as possible - herd immunity protects the people who are unable to get vaccinated or people at that edge of efficacy. And a child who is not vaccinated by their parent may want to get that vaccination when they're old enough to make that decision by themselves.
- mindslight 11y agoWhy, categorically, should one be forcibly vaccinated in order to protect someone else? Sure, it's the civilized thing to do, but why is the justification to compel it? (And yes, the "anti-vax" "movement" is disgusting - a fine example of the stupidity of crowds. Unfortunately, defending freedom often means defending scoundrels). There's a similar argument around fire coverage. The common argument against a more libertarian approach to fire fighting is that if someone's house catches fire and is left to burn, then it will easily spread to neighbors, increasing their risk. And this the obvious physical reality, especially where things are dense. But since those neighbors are the only concerned parties, then why (in principle) is that additional risk not theirs to bear and mitigate? It cannot cost any more than the neighbors splitting the cost of the fire protection on the unprotected building. Practically, the fire department would just pool that overhead across all customers. Of course there is the issue of long term second-order effects - freeloading - since most likely if you didn't pay the fire department would still try to extinguish your house as quick as possible (possibly just busting it up a bit more in the process). But making coverage mandatory also ignores long term second-order effects when an organization does not have to be responsive to the people it serves (which is usually then handwaved away with the wisdom-of-crowds fallacy). The root of the disagreement comes from different thinking about what society actually is. Is it a monolithic system we're all bound to and the only way to change it is top-down? Or is it the constructive result of the surplus that everyone is willing to bring to the table, implying that an individual should have the option to quit the game and take their ball - even if that individual then watches from the sideline or even returns to play but without their ball? Both perspectives are needed, but every society is predisposed towards over-centralization - most people have a very hard time seeing anything besides their own perspective, so they falsely think their desires apply to everyone. Yet as demonstrated by the success of free markets, only decentralization can satisfy and incorporate minority viewpoints. When creative destruction is prevented from applying to structures within the society, then it will inevitably occur to the society as a whole.