3 ms·
Other people getting married is not something you would care about since you have not emotions. With regards to the thunderstorm thats not how it works. It's n
by ThomPete 11y ago
Other people getting married is not something you would care about since you have not emotions.
With regards to the thunderstorm thats not how it works. It's not the rational request thats the problem but the intuition around when it feels right. Emotions are fundamental to making any kind of creative decisions.
- coldtea 11y ago>Other people getting married is not something you would care about since you have not emotions. They don't. They just copy what other people do because it's the default thing to do (everyone does it), and because they want to stop that annoyance (annoyance like we feel annoyance from a crappy seat belt or uncomfortamble shows, not emotional misery) and distraction (the nagging from other people, etc). No emotion mostly means that they aren't enthusiastic about getting married, and they are not miserable because they are not married either. You can conform to something just by thinking about it, you don't have to have any emotions on the matter. Same way people used to have arranged marriages back in the day (and still in some cultures). They didn't necessarily have any affection to the other person, not they had any great urge to get married. >With regards to the thunderstorm thats not how it works. It's not the rational request thats the problem but the intuition around when it feels right. You don't need to feel emotion-based intuition for when it "feels right". "Feels" is just a word we use to describe our selection process but it doesn't mean there have to be "feelings" involved. You just need to check that your sound effect sound as you remember those things to sound. No need to be dissapointed when they don't, or feel creative or elated when they do.
- ThomPete 11y agoIf they don't have any emotions they don't care what other people do or that they nag them. Nothings annoys them, nothing excites them. You getting the order wrong. Of course you need to build up intuition when you create things that doesn't have a matemathical formula. Thats exactly what intuition is a combination of rational understand, experience and emotional awareness of what decision is right and which one is wrong to you. Without it you would have a hard time making any decisions at all. There is a reason why humans have developed emotions. The point is that I don't believe this person is completely without emotions whatever biochemical function it boils down to.
- VLM 11y agoI think you're basically arguing that herd behavior or swarm behavior can't emerge without self conscious higher level adult emotions; I'm thinking that's a big stretch based on natural examples. I'm not even sure "monkey see monkey do" even is an emotion, if it is, which is it? Possession of empathy isn't possessing the observed emotion, its just observing it. For another weird concept look at humanities universal habit of rationalizing irrational decisions. For no good reason I did XYZ, now listen to my detailed rationalization based on emotions or Vulcan-level logic, which doesn't really matter because I really have no idea why I asked ABC out on a date or decided to buy that car or eat that second piece of birthday cake, although in detailed post-rationalization I can dream up all kinds of sand castles in the sky explaining elaborate logical reasons or stark emotions that I supposedly experienced before I made a random decision. This adds an annoying second level of analysis, why do some people do random things just like everyone else, but their societal or cultural failure is rationalizing it as logic or admitting it was just random, whereas "everyone knows" we must, at least in public, declare it to be the result of emotion.
- ThomPete 11y agoMarriage is a cultural institution NOT a biological one. There is a big and important difference between the two IMO. I agree with your empathy description. In fact a lot of people think empathy primarily is about the ability to feel other peoples pain but it's much wider than that. But thats another discussion.
- coldtea 11y ago>If they don't have any emotions they don't care what other people do or that they nag them. Nothings annoys them, nothing excites them. I think you conflate emotions with any kind of functioning at all. You can still function, think, try to avoid tension and people being angry or annoyed at you, without feeling any emotions. If you discover that something you do makes someone unconfortable for example, you can decide to stop it, despite not feeling bad about doing it. "Hmm, this guy says this thing I do makes him feel bad. I'm told that feeling bad is something people don't like. I should stop it, so that he doesn't feel bad, so that I'm like normal people or so I wont get into trouble for what I do". Motivation for going with the flow doesn't gave to be "oh, I'll be miserable if I wont". It can be mere rational reasoning -- "I better not make waves" or things like "last time I did that they punched me and it hurt. I'd want to avoid being punched again".
- SilasX 11y agoThat still sounds like "lack of specific emotions" and "acting mainly on response to irritation or loneliness", not "lack of emotional altogether". The have an extra-rational pull towards doing one thing rather than some other thing. There's no real way to "carve reality at the joints" in a way that excludes what this person is feeling/doing vs someone with "real" emotions.
- eric_h 11y agoI think the english language conflates intuition with emotion, referring to two separate actions (intuiting and emotionally responding to) with the same word: "feel".
- ThomPete 11y agoAnd I think I know you are wrong about this. Speaking as a former musician and now designer.
- eric_h 11y agoI wasn't saying the two were exclusive, merely that the use of the word "feels" conflates the two. "This (design|note|architecture decision|etc.) 'feels' right" could be taking from both column a and b (how much of each column would surely be dependent on the subject matter).