4 ms·
Encryption is not worthless. It makes mass surveillance more expensive. There's a huge difference between being able to hack into anything (which is what the NS
by mtgx 11y ago
Encryption is not worthless. It makes mass surveillance more expensive. There's a huge difference between being able to hack into anything (which is what the NSA has proven it can do) and being able to hack into everything, all at once, all the time, easily.
Our goal should be to move the scale closer to the former and as far away as possible from the latter, while also trying to make it explicitly illegal to do the latter and ensuring the abuses get punished (the rare times they are uncovered through whistleblowing or some lucky lawsuits).
- rl3 11y agoThis is true. Admittedly, I should have worded my statement differently. Yes, encryption makes mass surveillance more expensive. However, hacking everything, all at once, all the time is not a requium for successful masss surveillance in the face of strong encryption. The bulk of communications are centralized somehow, either via their networking model or via common client software. Take Skype for example. NSA/GCHQ would never give up their ability to conduct mass surveillance on that platform. If Microsoft refused to cooperate for whatever reason (unlikely), they'd simply compromise Skype's network and/or client application accordingly. Such an operation, while expensive, is a far cry from hacking every single Skype user individually.