3 ms·
> Commission negotiators are going to find that their hands are tied by the court ruling. They will be simply unable to make concessions that they might otherwi
by mtgx 11y ago
> Commission negotiators are going to find that their hands are tied by the court ruling. They will be simply unable to make concessions that they might otherwise be prepared to make, because they cannot ignore a constitutional ruling from the European Court of Justice without breaking the law. Any further negotiations will take place in the shadow of a potential veto from a European court which has staked out a very strong position on the fundamental privacy rights of E.U. citizens.
This is what I love most about this. Now the EU Commission needs to start from a strict standard of privacy imposed by the highest EU Court. The US government or companies can't lobby their way out of this one anymore. The EC, at least the previous one, was rather notorious for being easily manipulated by the US influences (remember ACTA?)
Whether the new EC likes it or not, it will have to start the negotiations for the new Safe Harbor and Data Protection Directive from the baseline imposed by the Court. Or risk having the new agreements invalidated as well a year or two later. I bet they had already made huge concessions on the new Safe Harbor and Data Protection Directive to the US, but now all of those will have to be canceled.
Also, the US Congress will now be forced to take action against the FISA Amendments Act and the Executive Order 12333, as well. That's another way in which this Safe Harbor "problem" could be fixed from the US side.
- rodgerd 11y ago> The US government or companies can't lobby their way out of this one anymore. Sure they can. They can make sure multinational trade agreements treat privacy laws as unfair trade barriers and allow companies to sue governments for fictional damages in kangaroo courts.