3 ms·
In general it's fantastic that the FAA is finally loosening up on drone regulation. Overall the technology has huge potential and is pretty safe to operate in
by paulmd 11y ago
In general it's fantastic that the FAA is finally loosening up on drone regulation. Overall the technology has huge potential and is pretty safe to operate in most places if done responsibly.
Class B airspace is not one of those places. FOD can very easily take down an aircraft. These guys are going to get the book thrown at them, and they deserve it. It's very much in our best interest as a tech community to weed out people who act with such disregard. If there's an appearance that we aren't responsible enough for this, there will be a backlash and we will have a much, much shorter leash.
It's probably going to be a tension that we see repeated as we explore drone tech, since Class B airspace is often located near large cities that would be good target markets for drone-based businesses.
Even if the FAA grants the low-altitude airspace to drone traffic there will still be problems. The larger, faster high-altitude drone corridors with the most dangerous traffic would be placed the closest to other air traffic. Having better guidance, transponders, and collision avoidance is a start, but nowhere near sufficient. They still won't be responding to ATC guidance and commands. I imagine we'll probably see a tiered exclusion zone around airports for this reason.
- danudey 11y agoI've seen several news stories here in BC and other places on the west coast about rescue and fire fighting planes which were grounded due to unmanned drones in their airspace. One idiot hobbyist with no regard for anyone else can threaten thousands of acres of forest and countless human lives. Shut these people down, bring the hammer down on people being idiots, and let the responsible people keep going.
- paulmd 11y agoI mean, this isn't even someone toying around with a quad and not realizing there was serious air traffic in the area. They repeatedly ignored the FAA telling them to knock it off with the drones around jumbo jets. What exactly did they think would happen?
- cassoulet26 11y agoFrankly, I think the disparity between the cost of drones and the amount of damage that they can do in irresponsible or unskilled hands has put us in an untenable situation. We need to quickly develop technological countermeasures against unlawful drone use, or we can expect to see a draconian law enforcement response, just as we have seen in another similar arena: hacking.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoHere's the thing - this problem will only become more common. A side effect of scientific and technological progress is that individuals wield ever increasing amounts of destructive power. Technological countermeasures will only lead to an arms race, in which the defender is always at a disadvantage. In the very near future, how are we supposed to defend against a high-school kid who accidentally created a deadly pathogen? How about a deliberate bioattack? We really need to figure this out, and sooner rather than later.
- facetube 11y agoYeah, from what I hear Class Bravo airspace is one of those areas that you can flying toward in a Cessna 172, ask to enter, and be pretty much told "no thanks, not right now". (N.B. Not a pilot, you're all safe).
- cpncrunch 11y agoYou can definitely fly in class B in a Cessna. There have been articles on AOPA about this, e.g.: http://flighttraining.aopa.org/magazine/2013/June/feature-little-fish.html http://flighttraining.aopa.org/magazine/2013/June/feature-li... Barry Schiff even wrote an article about flying into LAX in a 172: http://www.aopa.org/News-and-Video/All-News/2014/July/Pilot/proficient http://www.aopa.org/News-and-Video/All-News/2014/July/Pilot/... I sometimes fly from YYJ (class C) and they're quite adept at fitting the Cessnas in between the 737s and dash-8s. There's no low-level class B here in Canada (only above 12500ft), but the Vancouver class C terminal zone is probably equivalent to the class B around SFO.
- facetube 11y agoInteresting, thanks for the links.
- swingbridge 11y agoNot really, a licensed private pilot can fly into class bravo airspace in something like a 172. Happens all the time and the NYC controllers are actually quite good with this. Flew with a pilot friend and ATC took him right over Manhattan and JFK in a little Cessna. However if you act like one of these drones and fly in with no radio comms and no transponder, that's when they scramble the fighter jets.
- tobinfricke 11y agoThis is true, but ATC can also deny your request to enter Bravo.
- tobinfricke 11y agoThis is correct. To enter Class Bravo airspace, one must have clearance from Air Traffic Control. Pilots are free to request clearance through Class Bravo, but it's not always granted. For example, flying a Cessna 172 out of San Carlos Airport in the San Francisco Bay Area, it's very convenient to travel through the nearby Bravo airspace of San Francisco airport. Sometimes it's granted, other times we have to go around. Furthermore, having obtained a Bravo clearance, you must pay close attention to and promptly obey any instructions from ATC (which can be of the form "turn left 10 degrees immediately for traffic avoidance"). By contrast, controllers have no means to track drones or communicate with their pilots.