4 ms·
Glad ajko is at least attempting something. This is one of the meme's I've been posting on for years. I think the problem is different, though. So much wisdom a
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Glad ajko is at least attempting something. This is one of the meme's I've been posting on for years. I think the problem is different, though. So much wisdom and so many capabilities are in papers, sometimes software, created in academia. However, nobody knows they exist. Coursework isn't the reason. The reason seems to be two-fold: (a) the main sources for all of it are pay-walled ACM and IEEE that professionals never use; (b) the non-paywalled links are scattered across the web in University sites instead of one or more central, organized sources for such information. These problems must be solved somehow because the opportunity cost is gigantic.
I try to get this info to people by pulling batches of papers, skimming them, finding the worthwhile stuff, and mentioning it in online forums or to specific people in projects. I have over 10,000 papers in my collection from ACM/IEEE that were organized at some point (sighs). Anyway, when a topic comes up, I can just search them and (surprise!) many modern problems have already been solved. People just aren't applying the solutions when they know about them and more often just don't know about them.
So, the second one was my idea. A resource, crowd or taxpayer-funded, that's essentially an organized encyclopedia of papers and software developed in academia pertitent to aspects of software development. It would start as a manual effort that pulls in the links and paper that represent the best of most topics. As it got buy-in, the professors might have their students categorize and submit their own stuff. I thought an invite-only forum for serendipidous discussion among people that know their shit (esp researchers, professors, industry vets) could also get ideas across. Might be a fee for all of this charged to users, universities, someone that's way cheaper than ACM/IEEE. Basically, enough to cover the servers, bandwidth, and at least one employee.
Ran it by Epstein at NSF. He thought it was a nice idea but wisely warned it might not take off at all without buy-in ahead of time. The buy-in would have to come from a ton of places, too. So, bootstrapping that might be tricky. Even worse, many people I talked to in academia indicate the people and organizations on that side don't care about practical things at all. The ones that do are an exception and the norm actually filters out that stuff in favor of publishing/citations.
Well, we could hit it from the other side. Closest thing I've seen from industry was Dr Dobbs with articles on Cleanroom, Design-by-Contract, etc. Many professionals read that and could get exposed to cutting-edge via practical treatments from a trusted source. Additionally, the likes of Microsoft, IBM, Google, and Facebook do the cutting-edge academia and practical stuff simultaneously while publishing some and deploying others. This brings attention to it. Some results at these companies got widely deployed and are standard fare today.
So, I'd say the easiest route is a hybrid between companies and the nonprofit concept. Anyone wanting to try it can look at the kind of stuff companies are working on. Package up the cutting-edge stuff for those things to make it the first deliverable of the site. Add in plenty of IT and INFOSEC stuff on top of that which has immediate value for them. Get those companies as members to sponsor the initial development. Simultaneously, try to get University groups on the bandwagon who operate in key areas of IT or INFOSEC where the research results need attention. For big ones, maybe let them pay to have a dedicate person doing nothing but pulling in and curating their research as a brand boost for them. The site/service should grow in both usage and material as businesses pull on it for info while Universities push theirs into it.
Outside an effort like this, I'm not sure how else we're going to bridge the gap between academia and industry in a major way.
- hga 11y ago(a) the main sources for all of it are pay-walled ACM and IEEE that professionals never use Balking at the $200/year ACM cost wouldn't signal to me that you're a professional (in the First World, then again, they have Developing World discounts). IEEE, though, is $40/month for 25 articles with a max of 10 unused carrying over to the next month, $17/month for a "Basic" level of only 3. Plus membership; that's prohibitive.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoOh, I totally agree. It's not just them: it's about everyone outside ACM/IEEE's target audience and then even them when they graduate haha. Just too expensive with an unknown value proposition for most. I capitalized on my access to a proxy to them to pull whole batches of papers out. I looked at "related work," etc, searched them, and pulled them too. Repeat, repeat for hours every week or two on related topics until years later I'm beyond the point of organizing or reading all of them lol. Just use my search bar now to find the local copy. However, even limited explorations found great stuff that solved or might solve problems people talk about. An example we see on HN a lot is storing data safely in the cloud. There's so many ways to do that in academia with prototypes and detailed analysis it isn't even funny to see someone ask that question. Yet, they won't see it unless they knew their University had ACM/IEEE access or they paid for it themselves. I think this is a huge problem given how much of a gold mine it's been for me. Good news its that CiteseerX and university web sites have many of the papers, too. Just gotta type keywords of the title, their name, and pdf (or PS) into Google to see if it's there. Sometimes Wayback Machine is only source. Great stuff disappears every year without getting mainstream attention. It's sad.
- lfowles 11y agoI was looking at renewing my IEEE membership yesterday to get article access... Naively I assumed the THREE articles per month level was included in regular membership dues. What a racket :/
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI didn't even know about the limit until he said something. My University had no limit in their proxy: I pulled over 10,000 papers from it sometimes 50-100 a night. :O Wonder what they pay. Anyway, might help to get affiliated with a University or enlist the help of a student. ;)