9 ms·
There was a recent allegation that the Reddit administration had encouraged vote brigading with Tom Hanks' comments: http://i.imgur.com/Obafhpc.png http://i.img
by minimaxir 11y ago
There was a recent allegation that the Reddit administration had encouraged vote brigading with Tom Hanks' comments: http://i.imgur.com/Obafhpc.png http://i.imgur.com/Obafhpc.png
From the looks of the Upvoted front page, looks like they're doing it as a content marketing strategy, which doesn't bode well. Also, it seems like a BuzzFeed clone, which Redditors despise.
(Disclosure: although I have done a LOT of work analyzing Reddit [http://minimaxir.com/2015/10/reddit-bigquery/ http://minimaxir.com/2015/10/reddit-bigquery/], I have not been approached to write anything for Upvoted)
- oldmanjay 11y ago> Also, it seems like a BuzzFeed clone, which Redditors despise. I'll stipulate that some redditors despise buzzfeed, but the population of users is too big for you to be that assertive. I bet you despise it, though, and decided that you are the protoredditor. Am I right?
- minimaxir 11y agoNo, you are not right. https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/1vqs25/whats_up_with_all_the_animosity_towards_buzzfeed/ https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/1vqs25/whats_... Actually, many of the comments in the Reddit thread about Upvoted have this sentiment too: http://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/3npxm4/introducing_upvoted_a_redditorial_publication/ http://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/3npxm4/introducing_upv...
- Domenic_S 11y agoShouldn't it be more likely that a common attitude is true [0] within a big userbase? [0] Where "true" == many/most users feel the same way.
- alexis 11y agoThe top thread on the announcement is a great discussion of why it's so important to us to credit Redditors in every article, which folks seem to appreciate. https://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/3npxm4/introducing_upvoted_a_redditorial_publication/cvq6trw https://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/3npxm4/introducing_up... As for Tom, here's what I posted on r/defaultmods addressing that concern. >> I ran those ads when I learned Tom was using the site. I did that because for the last few weeks more and more celebrities have been coming on or reaching out to use reddit as members of the community. And we've run sponsored headline to draw attention to it, these ads have been viewed over 14M times in the last couple of weeks without incident. They've also performed exceptionally well (Bill Gates' for instance had 368% higher CTR than average). +That moment when Peter Mayhew (Chewbacca) shows up to compliment your Rebel helmet patch +Oh, just Bill Gates hanging out on r/infographics +Lil Dicky drops a new music video, shows up in the comments of r/Music thread Admittedly, these ads all went up at least 24hrs after the celeb showed up and left, whereas I jumped on the Tom Hanks one as soon as I realized it was happening. We're not going to do that again. Those ads also performed very well (63% higher than site average) but were a really bad look. To be clear: we're not paying them. They're coming because we're actually making progress showing them the value of joining the community. Wynter (u/808sandhotcakes) has been doing a lot of great work, by virtue of her great reputation in the industry alone, people are genuinely reaching out to learn how to join the Reddit community. We're excited about that, because it clearly makes our users very happy and by every account the talent enjoys it, too. edit: (See, I'm already getting better: Arnold + Adam Savage stopped by since Tom and no obnoxious sponsored headlines.)
- minimaxir 11y agoHi Alexis, thanks for the clarification regarding the ads. That said, I still have concerns about the power dynamic. I do see that users are credited for submissions, but Reddit is the one that mostly benefits from it, especially since ads are being run on the site. It's the same concern that people have with BuzzFeed that attribution alone won't solve. (There's also the issue of determining if Original Content on Reddit is actually OC, and that could lead to interesting problems.) As mentioned in the original image, Upvoting still does encourage brigading on submissions (https://www.reddit.com/r/Upvoted/comments/3ni1il/upvoted_weekly_vol_1_issue_24_hold_my_catnip_plus/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Upvoted/comments/3ni1il/upvoted_wee...), which can have fallout in the future.
- alexis 11y agoSure thing. You'll see from the content on Upvoted.com that the OP is usually just the start of the story and we're following up to learn more. e.g., Omari Nyaega http://upvoted.com/2015/10/03/omari-nyaega-machete-kenya-orphanage/ http://upvoted.com/2015/10/03/omari-nyaega-machete-kenya-orp... 202M+ people can surface his story and raise a ton of money, but our team of reporters has a much easier time following up to close the loop. We're working on anti-brigading tools. That's on us to get right, because a lot of "brigading" is AKA "how social media works." It's long been a very fuzzy definition, which is on us (e.g., how is it OK for a celeb to tweet to his followers about an AMA -- it's both "brigading" and "required for verification") and there's a more obvious and negative brigading we can thwart better with technology so that mods have the ability to throttle when, say, one community wants to all pile into a thread and sway it.
- timdorr 11y ago> Also, it seems like a BuzzFeed clone, which Redditors despise. Primarily because Buzzfeed just copy-pastes content from Reddit with minimal credit. Upvoted at least looks to be providing genuinely improved-upon content with strong attribution linkage. To me, it gets rid of a lot of the scuzzy-ness associated with Buzzfeed, so I'm all for it.
- alexis 11y agoThank you! It's a minor thing, but one of my favorite things about the product is this brilliant widget u/comeforthlazarus came up with -- every article (e.g., this one on suicide survivors[1]) has a widget on the left rail[2] that follows the reader to display the OP, subreddit, and link to it. [1] http://upvoted.com/2015/10/03/survivors-of-suicide-spent-their-last-days-on-earth/ http://upvoted.com/2015/10/03/survivors-of-suicide-spent-the... [2] http://imgur.com/gGVdaHU http://imgur.com/gGVdaHU
- lobster_johnson 11y agoIt tastes pretty bland and artificial to me. For example, this [1] post is fluffy in the most aesthetically offensive, buzzfeedy way: * It doesn't link back to Reddit * There's no context * It's glib, impersonal and bland * It has an unnecessary illustration * It adds nothing to the original content Contrast this with what I presume is a comment from Tom Hanks about what his perfect sandwich is. That's meaningful. [1] http://upvoted.com/2015/10/03/perfect-sandwich-tom-hanks-reddit/ http://upvoted.com/2015/10/03/perfect-sandwich-tom-hanks-red...
- meowface 11y agoAgreed. This is an 8-word tumblr post stretched out to be an entire "article" of content. I honestly see no value added with any of the articles I looked at. Every single one could be replaced with links to reddit comments, maybe with some quotes of the reddit comments, and the images down at the bottom. It's a little less sensationalist than Buzzfeed, and I'd rather look at this than Buzzfeed, but I really don't want to use either of them.
- Reedx 11y ago
- redml 11y agoThey've apparently learned nothing from digg v4 and why users flocked to their community in the first place
- alexis 11y agoUpvoted.com does not affect Reddit.com -- like, not even developer attention -- we didn't move any Reddit developers off of community/mod tools, infra, or mobile.
- debacle 11y agoI think they're banking heavily on users not really having anywhere else to go.
- dageshi 11y agoAs a fairly old reddit user of 7 years and someone who was on digg before that, this is nothing like what happened to digg. Nobody changed the core site they just bolted an optional extra onto the side to appeal to a different audience. Not got a problem with it whatsoever.
- teach 11y agoAgreed. I've been on Reddit ten(!) years now and watched Digg rise and fall from the sidelines. This is not like that.
- samstave 11y agoAgreed. Digg fucked with the fundamental architecture of how the site worked with respect to the community's interaction. Reddit has many flaws, but it's still hands down the best method to massively consume information and share thoughts... The ability to navigate it and engage instantly while maintaining both thread context and inside-community-culture is unmatched...
- tcdent 11y ago> "...it seems like a BuzzFeed clone, which Redditors despise." Part of Reddit's weakness is the Redditor mentality. Do I have to adopt their way of thinking, acting, consuming when I sign up? No, but I'm sure a ton of the mainstream is turned off by it. Want to show some growth numbers? Target users outside of your core demographic. Re-purposed content re-presented for a different audience is a pretty easy way do that.
- clavalle 11y ago"the Redditor mentality" I don't think this actually exists. There are 'meme-storms' -- Libertarianism, getting riled up about finding some 'criminal' them getting riled up about the people getting riled up, and the anti-censorship crusades, etc but I think attributing these things to the hivemind is a mental shortcut that's found way too much purchase.
- Domenic_S 11y agoIt exists. Look at just the interface of the site itself. It's ugly and confusing, but if you say it's ugly and confusing, LOL @ U. Everyone knows you have to install RES+Hoverzoom for the real Reddit experience! > According to Google Ad Planner's estimate, as of May 2013, the median Reddit user is male (59%), 18–29 years of age [0] A lot of the reason Reddit skews young is the interface, which in turn results in a young-male echochamber. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reddit#Demographics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reddit#Demographics
- Karunamon 11y agoUgly? You mean it doesn't follow the latest Flat UI Design® standards where beauty means a lack of differentiation between clickable and not, is mostly text with a predictable layout, and degrades gracefully in the face of no javascript? ..because older-female people can't figure out how links and votes work? Huh? I don't think you'd be able to substantiate that connection you just made, and what's more, it's quite insulting.
- 11y ago
- gcb0 11y agoand reddit has gone full circle on copying digg. digg started to go down when they started doing that. i recall ad space being used for a survey to try to understand if the Rose guy was essential to digg. now this thing is exactly a copy of what digg become lately.
- armandososa 11y agoI love reddit. But sometimes I feel some people take it too seriously.