3 ms·
Yeah, a bit out of topic and I'm not a Biblical scholar or a learned man. Just another sinner trying to be a good person. Church elders have long sermons on h
by protomyth 11y ago
Yeah, a bit out of topic and I'm not a Biblical scholar or a learned man. Just another sinner trying to be a good person. Church elders have long sermons on how a religion changes with new discoveries, I just go with the flow and keep the theme. That said, I'll try.
Its not so much selecting, as knowing that the context has changed in thousands of years. Burying your poop and what hand to use eating were important things back then, but only really practical on a survival show now. I have plumbing and good soap. How to treat slaves is not something the modern world should care about. Its not about disagreeing with the text, its understanding that whole free will and gaining dominion over it all sometimes discards the old conditions by freeing people. Its was a survival manual after all too.
"Thou shalt not murder" and "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor" are not something that loses their context. They speak to how to treat others and don't lose any meaning with era. Our changes to the world have not changed such fundamental truths. We are still humans and some things are eternal. The parables are still good lessons.
- Jedd 11y agoThank you for your thoughtful response. At the risk of sounding churlish, however, I think you dodged my question : ) I know that I should not murder, and that I should not buy / keep slaves. Yet I don't need to refer to a text that agrees with my position on the former, but is (at best) ambiguous on the latter. (The precise mechanism by which I've come to know both things are bad is not something I can conveniently answer, before you ask. Quoting K-Pax may be necessary.) My question was if you have the necessary innate / internal / nascent / instinctive understanding to know slavery is bad (as one example) then what's the point of using a text that advocates slavery as the basis of a moral framework?
- protomyth 11y agoWell, I tried, as I said I'm not a scholar but a student. > I've come to know both things are bad is not something I can conveniently answer, before you ask Yet, you ask me the reason I use a text that is the basis of my church's beliefs that were taught to me to show those are bad. I don't think its instinctive to know its bad or else it would have not been such an institution in the first place. To be fair to the Bible, it doesn't advocate slavery, but it does have commands on how to treat slaves including freeing them. I guess there is a pragmatism in lessening the horror when its not ingrained to end it outright.