5 ms·
I must admit, after the NSA stuff, I feel safer without "Safe Harbor". But I guess a bunch of US companies are pretty scared about the financial implications r
by k__ 11y ago
I must admit, after the NSA stuff, I feel safer without "Safe Harbor".
But I guess a bunch of US companies are pretty scared about the financial implications right now. Kicking out EU citizens or moving their data to the EU.
- daxelrod 11y agoDo we actually know whether any of the Five Eyes nations are any better than the US in this regard?
- omouse 11y agoIf they're in the Five Eyes then no, they aren't any better.
- geofft 11y agoWell, this is the usual thing about whether you're worried about the NSA or you're worried about more mundane threats. If your threat model is "government coercion," sure, stay out of the US. But if your threat model is something like "an attacker broke into a cloud provider employee's account" or "the provider didn't take software updates", you're probably safer on the world's larger, more-staffed, more-well-run, etc. services, which are largely (though not entirely) in the US. The best outcome here, I think, would involve serious, secure competitors to things like AWS being run by European countries in Europe.
- sokoloff 11y agoYou can already choose AWS services and ensure that they stay located only in a single region (that you decide), so you can pick EU-West-1 (Ireland) or EU-Central-1 (Germany) and be assured that Amazon won't move your data into another region. If you are contemplating "pan-cloud root compromise", I'd worry more about the probability of that happening and less about in which countries that cloud provider operates. That would push me towards the larger, established provider (perceived lower probability of all-access-root compromise) over a smaller upstart whose value prop was "we ONLY operate in Europe".
- Aloisius 11y ago> and be assured that Amazon won't move your data into another region. Is this true? If Amazon received a US subpoena requiring them to provide a copy of data on EU-West-1, is violating EU privacy laws a reason to deny a seemingly lawful court order? After all, it is against the law in the US to withhold the information.
- sokoloff 11y agoFair question. I'd respond two ways: 1. You can still (as a user) avail yourself of user of AWS (aka "you") controlled encryption for most of the relevant data at rest. 2. There is still a legal hurdle for the US to provide a subpoena for data which doesn't reside in the US to be brought into the US and provided. I'm no legal expert, but I doubt that's going to be as simple as "because we said we want to look at it" as this is an issue of sovereignty of the counterpart nation, particularly given that the EU high court has just ruled that the export of this data is contrary to EU law. Of the two, #1 has significant mathematical assurance.
- geofft 11y ago#1 doesn't really help if you also want to use EC2, Lambda, etc. #2 assumes that the US national security apparatus is playing by international law, which the EU may not want to assume. Like the EU cookie law, regardless of the intentions behind the ruling/law, what matters for me as a developer is what the law thinks I should do to protect my users, not what I think I should do.
- sokoloff 11y agoIf you want to use lambda, going to a small EU-based cloud provider also doesn't work...
- geofft 11y agoYeah, but there's unfortunately a difference between wanting to use Lambda and needing to use Lambda, and I'm pretty sure that even an EU court can tell the difference. "We hosted in America because only Amazon supports Lambda." "OK, and what does Lambda do?" "It runs code for us when we tell it to." "And there are no European services that run code for you when you tell them to?" "Uhh...."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mercurial 11y agoI think Armin makes a good point that European intelligence services have as little, or even less, regards for EU citizens' privacy as the NSA. Getting spied upon by GCHQ, the EU branch of the NSA, or by the mothership itself, makes little difference in practice.
- neokya 11y agoPoint is intelligence based in Europe is still under legal control, NSA is not. If there is big issue in future, you can summon European intelligence at court.
- bmelton 11y agoYou're not wrong, but with Five Eyes, the OP's point still stands strong as ever. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes In practice, there's little advantage to living in Europe, being spied on by the NSA who then sends that data to European intelligence agencies.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoGCHQ's operation legality has been put under question more than once.
- neokya 11y agoThat hasn't happened in past does not mean it won't happen in future.
- mercurial 11y agoConsidering that France recently voted a law to make retroactively legal existing practices, I'd say this legal control is most often a farce (and it's not like the new law introduces strong judicial supervision, either).
- coldtea 11y ago>Getting spied upon by GCHQ, the EU branch of the NSA, or by the mothership itself, makes little difference in practice. It makes a difference depending on whether you're OK to be spied upon by a foreign power -- who might damage, take advantage and exploit your country. Would Americans be OK to be spied by foreign powers while in the US? And if yes, would the answer still be yes if the US wasn't the top dog, and the other country was, and could hurt them whenever they wanted?