Every mental state is precipitated by the physical state of the brain. The only difference between a criminal who does something "intentionally" and someone lik

Every mental state is precipitated by the physical state of the brain. The only difference between a criminal who does something "intentionally" and someone like this is a difference of degree. Unless someone wants to demonstrate supernatural free will, we need to stop pretending that anybody does anything completely on their own. This doesn't mean we should let dangerous people roam free, but it means that we should let evidence decide the most effective response to unwanted behavior rather than our desire for retribution.