4 ms·
European privacy laws are very consumer-friendly and usually very reasonable. US companies should look at those laws as a guidebook on how to get your customer'
by scrollaway 11y ago
European privacy laws are very consumer-friendly and usually very reasonable. US companies should look at those laws as a guidebook on how to get your customer's privacy right in the US as well.
You build houses - think of it like fire safety rules. "What do you mean I have to keep track of all the fire safety rules for the country I build the houses in? Can't I just keep track of a set of rules of my choosing instead?" -- well, no, for one and even if you could, that'd be a bad idea. Almost universally, there's good reasons behind specific rules in the fire code. (And in the rarer cases the rules really are broken, that's a problem with the law, but not one that can't be fixed).
Unfortunately, most companies don't give a rat about their customers' privacy (we care deeply about it we swear). What really should happen instead is that US customers demand laws like the ones we have in Europe.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoSome EU laws may be intended to be consumer-friendly, but the intended outcomes don't necessarily line up. Case in point, the cookie law absurdity.
- vidarh 11y agoIn the end we ended up with a requirement to ensure more and more prominent information. Do you think it's bad that more consumers are aware of the potential privacy impact of their actions?
- JohnTHaller 11y agoBasically every website in the world except basic static sites use cookies. So the EU wants every website in the world to have a warning message about the dangers of cookies. That will show up every single time you visit every single website. Unless you accept the cookie that allows the site to see the fact that you saw a warning about cookies. So, websites have to use cookies to display a warning about cookies and if you don't accept the cookie, you get a warning about it on every single subsequent visit. It screams laws written by politicians for special interest groups none of whom have the first clue about technology or how it works. You could just have the web browser show an alert when a site wants to set a cookie and the user can click that alert or always allow it. Which is what we used to have in every web browser. Until users got sick of seeing the stupid warning because every single website uses cookies. And they got blind to the warning and paid no attention to it. Which made any other warning a browser shows more likely to just be clicked through. So browsers removed the warning because we all realized it was stupid and pointless and ineffective and served no purpose any longer. But politicians with no idea how the technology works and no understanding of the fact that we already went through all this decide that everyone should see the dumb, stupid, ineffective warning on every single website and have it show up every single time for the people who understand how to manage their cookies and only show up once for the people who have no idea how to use their cookies. Just brilliant. It serves no purpose and everyone just clicks it away just like any other popup ad.
- scrollaway 11y agoYou're incorrectly thinking the EU cookie law applies to all cookies. It only applies to tracking data, including tracking cookies. Don't use Google Analytics -> No cookie law for you.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoExcept that every single site with the tools to help businesses comply says it applies to all cookies. Fun fact, the EU excluded "third-party social plug-in content-sharing", which are used for more tracking than any of the other cookies.
- jcranmer 11y agoActually, I do. There's a fallacy that displaying information before requesting consent necessarily leads to informed consent. Many users have insufficient background to understand what they're consenting to, particularly since such info-dumps tend to not mention what the consequences of various choices would be. With no context for their decision other than "Accept makes things work," all you're doing is training users to sign away their rights without knowing that they are
- thfuran 11y agoBut the situation prior to this ruling is basically what you described: that there's a particular set of rules that you have to follow. Now you potentially have to follow everyone's rules for every house you build, but which rules you had to follow depends on who buys it.
- scrollaway 11y agoThe situation prior to this ruling is "There's a particular set of rules which you have to follow... unless you're an american company, in which case, we trust you".
- Niten 11y ago> European privacy laws are very consumer-friendly and usually very reasonable. Cookie notifications and censorship of the news under the guise of the "right to be forgotten" come to mind as obvious counterexamples.