4 ms·
I don't 'do' Facebook, Twitter or LinkedIn, so those contact options are out. They are, but only for you. They're still options for the author and everyone who
by onion2k 11y ago
I don't 'do' Facebook, Twitter or LinkedIn, so those contact options are out.
They are, but only for you. They're still options for the author and everyone who hasn't opted out. That's what opting out means - your choice not to use a communication tool only affects you. The impact of your choice will be that you can't discuss something with the article's author directly.
If the editorial email address is swamped then they'll close it, or make it harder to find. That's all.
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoThe trouble is, opting out of facebook used to mean just that: opting out of facebook. Increasingly, however, it means opting out of engaging with a host of other sites. I think it's pretty poor form of a site to segregate its users by locking out those who don't happen to have an account on a separate third-party site.
- onion2k 11y agoBuilding on third party services is a brilliant, if not essential, part of the innovation process. The fact that people choose not to use the most third party service among content websites is their choice (and it's an understandable one), but they should learn to live with the consequences of that decision, which will include not being able to use some services they might want to. Saying "It'd be better if content sites didn't use FB!" is something that would have a detrimental impact on the web experience of more than a billion other people who have chosen not to opt out. That's something that you have to consider when you suggest an alternative solution.
- talmand 11y agoEssential? No one innovates on their own anymore? They have to rely on third-parties to be able to innovate?
- s73v3r 11y agoGenerally you want to focus your "innovation" on your core competencies. For other things, you kinda want to use 3rd party things
- talmand 11y agoI agree. But "essential"? As in the innovation can't happen unless you use these essential services?
- c23gooey 11y agoI believe s73v3r is saying that using third party services allows you to dedicate more time to innovation, rather than spending your time coding services that already exist and are probably better than you can write yourself anyway.
- talmand 11y agoThat's what I agree to, but I still balk at the term essential in terms of innovation. It is not essential. Helpful, yes. Essential, no.
- s73v3r 11y agoIt absolutely can. But now you're dividing your time between what you're trying to innovate in, and doing boilerplate stuff that has already been solved and set up for you. There are only so many hours in the day.
- talmand 11y agoI have not disagreed with that. Is it wrong of me to think that the word "essential" is far too limiting for the context of the statement? You seem to agree with the point I'm trying to make here.
- onion2k 11y agoIf you can build a good, working service without using anything from a third party then you can build the same service quicker, better, and cheaper using third parties and concentrating on just the innovative part. There is no sensible business reason to build everything yourself.
- sundarurfriend 11y agoYour comment struck a chord with me, that's a succinct explanation of the creepover of these services everywhere. Made me consider a shared (fake) facebook account - one that would be used just for such interactions, shared among folks that are averse to creating an account themselves. Sharing the username-password combo itself would soon lend itself to trollish password reset attempts though, so perhaps there could be a service that accepts email and makes facebook posts on your behalf using its own account. The email format could be something like: Type: Wall post [or "comment" or "private message"] Page Url: <Vice's page> Content: First! Facebook (or whatever other service this is created for) would probably catch up with the profile sooner or later, but that just means time to move to a new fake profile. Given the amount of disregard these companies show for user privacy, I have no moral compunction against such "deception". Perhaps a weekend project for someone with this itch to scratch.