23 ms·
We're Replacing Comments with Something Better
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ablation 11y agoGreat example of innovation from Vice. If only those starchy ol' newspapers could have thought of something like a 'letters to the editor' section... What? Oh. In all seriousness, it's probably a good move for Motherboard to do this. By and large, comments sections are kinda terrible, but this appears magnified on Vice Network sites in my experience.
- yohoho22 11y ago>Great example of innovation from Vice. If only those starchy ol' newspapers could have thought of something like a 'letters to the editor' section... What? Oh. The very first sentence of the Vice post: >As a kid, whenever I'd get some BMX or car magazine in the mail, I'd always dive in first to the letters to the editor.
- mvanvoorden 11y agoYou failed to see the sarcasm ;)
- reitoei 11y agoIndeed. They seem to have a very loyal fanbase that spends an enormous amount of time telling Vice how much they suck.
- tefo-mohapi 11y agoMore and more publications are giving serious thoughts to user engagement. Some have gone with forums, some slack groups for readers and I like the letters (e-mail) by Vice. Better quality, definetly.
- intopieces 11y ago>some slack groups for readers Could you name some publications that do this? I miss IRC. I know it's still around but Slack could be a better implementation of it, with the file sharing.
- phonephone 11y agoMost IRC clients support DCC file transfer. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_Client-to-Client https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_Client-to-Client
- pkkp 11y agoAndrew Sullivan's blog The Dish[0] did this for its entire existence. It was a driving point of the site's culture, to the point where certain topics gained frequent contributors that were probably better recognized because of the advantageous signal-to-noise ratio. Many sites seem to be turning toward a manual moderation model now. This doesn't seem too whacky as a next step for many of them. [0] http://dish.andrewsullivan.com http://dish.andrewsullivan.com
- mturmon 11y agoAnd to pursue this point, one person greatly influenced by Sullivan was his ex-colleague at The Atlantic, Ta-Nehisi Coates (who just won a MacArthur fellowship). Coates had a very well-policed comments section, which for several years attracted some high-quality comments and really excellent exchanges - the equal of anything here on HN within its chosen domain (essentially, race and history). Coates is black, of course, so there was a lot of moderation needed. It proved unsustainable and his posts don't have comments any more. This retrospective article sums up the trajectory of a lot of high-quality comments sections, like Sullivan's and Coates': http://blog.longreads.com/2015/02/04/its-yours-a-short-history-of-the-horde/ http://blog.longreads.com/2015/02/04/its-yours-a-short-histo... Basically, it needs organic growth and a lot of personal attention. And it seems to have a finite lifetime.
- linker3000 11y agoI don't 'do' Facebook, Twitter or LinkedIn, so those contact options are out. Your editorial email address will be swamped for a while until people get bored with the lack of near-realtime debate. "...our readers are best served by dedicating our resources to doing more reporting than attempting to police a comments section...". That's why you appoint trusted moderators. Anyway, your 'resources' are now going to be split between processing email, visiting Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn... We'll see.
- reitoei 11y ago> people get bored with the lack of near-realtime debate You're making the assumption that people want this. They don't.
- RegW 11y agoAgreed. 16 people post the same comment 45 seconds after the article goes online (without reading it properly). 8 people post more thoughtful but identical comments 15 minutes later. I wake up 16 hours after the article goes online and post my tuppence worth into a rely to whatever is at the top. (without bothering to read the other 362 comments). [Updated to fix rubbish formatting]
- dspillett 11y ago> > people get bored with the lack of near-realtime debate > You're making the assumption that people want this. That might actually be a useful filter. The people out to cause trouble who seem to get off on the reaction to poor comments are more likely to be put off by the lack of immediacy than those who are more interested in a proper debate and take their time writing something well thought out and coherent.
- onion2k 11y agoI don't 'do' Facebook, Twitter or LinkedIn, so those contact options are out. They are, but only for you. They're still options for the author and everyone who hasn't opted out. That's what opting out means - your choice not to use a communication tool only affects you. The impact of your choice will be that you can't discuss something with the article's author directly. If the editorial email address is swamped then they'll close it, or make it harder to find. That's all.
- CookieMon 11y agoWhy not both? The comments section is where the errors and baiting and propaganda gets called out, which has exploded with click-revenue media. Plus you can get a feeling for different community viewpoints. 'Tis a shame.
- reitoei 11y agoLike YouTube?
- okasaki 11y agoWill they also be replacing writers like these https://archive.is/cEGD4 https://archive.is/cEGD4 with something better? I think that's the far more urgent task.
- scrollaway 11y agoThat is an absolutely pathetic article... Edit: And after reading it closer, it seems to be from someone who doesn't understand how neither reddit nor food work. I wonder why they felt the need to print it.
- kagamine 11y agoWhile that was a pointless article to write anywhere outside of reddit itself, as it is in essence just a reddit rant, it is actually spot on imo. /r/food is parody of a food blog by people who are either in on the joke or, due to heart disease, won't live long enough to get in on the joke. The description of your average reddidiot was also accurate.
- makomk 11y agoThis saves them from having to replace writers like that. Before, they were in danger of people pointing out just how slimy articles like that were in the comments. Now they can just not print those letters.
- clydethefrog 11y agoIf you look at those comments, you see nothing of value is added. They all attack the author personally or on his writing style, instead of explaining why they don't agree with his article. To be short, they're mad. They could have shown the many bright sides of the reddit cooking community if people claim the article is one-sided. But they didn't.
- aikah 11y agoUser engagement will drop. But again, open standards to the rescue. RSS and pingbacks were meant to solve this very problem at first place, but since content creators are focused on "impressions", they are unable to take advantage of it.
- pmlnr 11y agohttp://indiewebcamp.com/webmention http://indiewebcamp.com/webmention
- ddingus 11y agoWhat I don't like: Filtering of comments that may be valid and important critiques of the work published as well as the publisher / online venue. The thing I like most about the Internet is that many to many communication mode. Basic things like fact checking and or just awareness of something not being inclusive are powerful things. They force authors to really think hard about what they write. Obviously, there is a lot of noise too, and that's the standard excuse for strong moderation, but it's really difficult to understand when the moderation is strong in the sense of promoting signal and demoting noise, and when it's censorship or manipulation. Frankly, I'll take the noise because I would rather determine this myself, or at least have the data needed to make that determination. Traditionally, it's been an editorial thing. Major news outlets have been in the position to manage questions related to their product as well as themselves and aren't comfortable with the masses feedback. Though the noise level was high, it was also possible to see manipulations and just general lack of accuracy or inclusive commentary and reporting too. Net good, for those who went looking. This also brought bloggers and basically anyone really interested in something on par with the majors. One guy who really cares can make an impact and fact check the biggest of the big. It's important we continue to make this a reality. We may not like it, but we need it. The other bit that gets broken here is dialogs. People just saying stuff is kind of noisy. But where the moderation encourages dialog, that dialog can often have as much or more value than the effort being discussed does. Of all the things I appreciate about the Internet, having conversations with people all over the world is right there at the top! If anything, we should be finding better ways to have conversations. Efforts like this do not do that. I also suspect the strong desire to do that will see some corrective type service or norm that the conversations will move to. Maybe back to critical blogs again? Something else? For sure it's not gonna be Facebook. At least not for me. FB is a raging mess. Useless for this. Having a large degree of free speech online means our speech does bring others speech in response. So there will almost always be haters, but there will be validation and recommendation and augmentation in there too. We want this. It's important that we don't create a place largely filled with walled off, largely one way, broadcast type efforts no different than the already lame broadcast type, one way efforts that dominate so much media now anyway. Really, I've sworn off most traditional media for this reason. It's much more informative and inclusive to seek it globally, get various perspectives and see those be critical as well as affirmative. What I do like: Low noise. Maybe comments are just doomed. In some places they aren't, but in many they are just crappy. Perhaps it is time to turn off comments, but what then? I really don't feel good about a "best of" type action where they pick some they feel are representative. If they offer up something here, it could be meaningful. I have no idea what that would look like though. Here's to hoping... To a degree, discouragement of hate and or just a lot of ugly speech. Many comment sections are filled with some vile stuff that does not add value, other than to remind us that a few too many of us do not get the basics of being a good quality human yet. As for Sullivan, yes he did not allow comments, and I never did think much of his site for that. Mostly, I ignored it and read through the lens of other places, who would cite him, and then critical dialog could be incorporated as part of the experience. To me, this is vital. It's not that I didn't necessarily like Sullivan. It's more that I saw his work as a platform for discussion, not primarily consumption. I really don't like one way productions for that reason. This site is a great example. We link to a lot of stuff that may or may not allow comments, but then we enter into what generally is a pretty great dialog. There are lots of points of view, people adding value with other references and thoughts of various kinds, and fact checking happens fairly consistently. Additionally, as I get to understand others here better, that dialog improves in value. Sure, we've got some biases, but the dialog is constructive enough for it to work well anyway. Very high value here, and that value comes from "the hive mind" where our collective responses actually augment the piece and give us food for thought about that piece. Overall, given people actually do read and interact some, it's a great bull shit filter as well as a path to a more inclusive perspective. Maybe people don't understand the value in that, or maybe worse, people aren't able to, or simply do not desire that value. I harbor hope the former is true and we can get more people there more of the time. For me personally, it's just not acceptable to read and not go seek the thoughts of others related to some material I find online. I've simply lost the trust in the vast majority of cases related to media organizations. I do continue to trust individuals and some organizations that are focused in some way or other and who do not derive primary income from publishing. Vice is a cool platform, and they offer up some frank commentary and news. I've enjoyed a lot of what I read there. Maybe they can replace comments with something that works and that I can trust. Hope so.
- pmlnr 11y agoNot all the things need a comments section. I welcome this change and hope it will bring good.
- erdojo 11y agoMistake #1: thinking reporters should be moderating comments (see quote below). Mistake #2: Sending their readers elsewhere on the web to comment on stories. Media outlets are looking for a revenue stream/value-added features. Web companies are all about engagement. What an opportunity they are missing! Why? Because they are scared of a little honest feedback? User-generated commentary can be done right. it can be done in a way that minimizes trolls. "I think that our readers are best served by dedicating our resources to doing more reporting than attempting to police a comments section in the hopes of marginally increasing the number of useful comments."
- stdbrouw 11y agoSo engagement is important, but not engagement with the author of the article (the person who, y'know, might actually be able to answer the questions people pose in the comments section)? And honest feedback – you mean like the honest feedback you see at the bottom of YouTube videos?
- Natsu 11y agoPart of the problem is that many people don't have (or want) any reputation on most sites they might comment on and creating accounts is generally trivial. I tend to worry, though, that what people label as trolling ranges from the idiots who spam bigoted nonsense to anyone who doesn't believe what the moderator does. I think it's better to moderate only incivility, bigotry and the like, as bans on "trolling" appear to have morphed into bans on dissent at some point, possibly due to some corollary of Poe's Law, even though what used to be labelled as trolling is still just as present and obnoxious. I say that as someone who moderated quite a lot of different forums and who has banned all manner of spammers, flamers, etc., but I'd never ban someone for expressing, in a civil manner, why they did not agree with me and I've been left feeling in the minority in that regard.
- DanBC 11y agoConcern trolls are civil and can do very great harm to a community.
- iamphilrae 11y agoI know I know, comments 99.9% of the time are non-constructive; but goddam it, I enjoy reading them. Sometimes they're good, but most of the time just a laugh. I like you're attempt to try something new (old) but as others have said, I don't do social media other than Twitter which is just too restrictive for decent comments. Its ironic though that I'm using HackerNews to comment on this. I'm a big fan of building a community who can self-police comments. It may be a pipe dream to be full proof that a bad comment will be down voted enough to remove it completely, but I really think there's a better way than resorting to email and social media.
- danpeddle 11y agoThere are similarities here to the adblocking debate, in terms of having to load 3rd party scripts. Disqus, FB etc - load through another request once the page is up and running, degrading the experience. Removing these parts will mean a quicker web, if as others have mentioned, at the cost of less immediate interaction. Vice seem to have correctly identified that the quality of that discussion (and the branding) was not adding much to their content. Thumbs up for trying something different.
- throwaway7767 11y agoI think this is a great idea. I've mostly learned to ignore comments sections precisely because the S/N ratio is so low. Now, given the decline in quality recently, one can only hope VICE employs the moderation tactic to their own articles too...
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoPersonally, I think third-party comment widgets are a terrible idea: security/privacy issues, page weight, loss of ownership of content, homogenisation, etc. It's interesting commenting about the quality of comments on a site that is nothing but. Maybe Hacker News, etc. is the future, although I'd like to think that on-site and off-site comments can co-exist (and for 'off-site' read twitter, facebook, etc.) The problem with all the off-site options is that you have to know they exist. At least on-site comments provide a fixed, available 'place' for discussion to take place. I have a feeling the solution is just better moderated comments sections. Many sites just chuck up a form and auto-publish anything entered into it; that might work at really small scale, but soon descends into chaos once a critical mass is reached. One day, I think, more comment sections will looks like mini-HNs.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> homogenisation That one wouldn't be actually bad if people stuck to good solutions in terms of usability. I mean, half of the forum boards on the Internet would be an order of magnitude better if the owners started them as a subreddit instead.
- lagadu 11y ago> In the end, we just want to hear from you. No, you most obviously do not; Otherwise you wouldn't remove comments sections.
- pmlnr 11y agoThey want to hear those who's got something relevant to say. Usually these are blown away by non-relevant comment storms.
- caractacus 11y ago"We want to hear from you and use your material if (i) you take the time to actually email us; (ii) you do so with a coherent and well-thought out response to one of our articles; (iii) you decide to do this even though there is likely little prospect of us publishing your email; and (iv) if we do publish it, cutting and highlighting your material in a separate article from which we can make ad revenue."
- imaginenore 11y agoSeems like a huge step back.
- xiaq 11y agoA blog I frequent has more interesting thoughts on disabling comments: http://prog21.dadgum.com/57.html http://prog21.dadgum.com/57.html
- pmlnr 11y agoI could also add this: https://www.hughrundle.net/2014/02/27/why-i-moved-my-blog-from-wordpress-to-ghost-and-why-i-turned-off-comments-along-the-way/ https://www.hughrundle.net/2014/02/27/why-i-moved-my-blog-fr...
- mturmon 11y agoBoth this and your other link are nice summaries of the problem. Thanks.
- pmlnr 11y agoAnd this: https://adactio.com/journal/1331 https://adactio.com/journal/1331
- gloves 11y agoCouldn't agree with this more. Comments in my experience have been so spammed to death with bots that the benefit of a comments section is diminishing when valued in terms of time spent moderating vs. value added to the reader experience. Social media has effectively superseded the need for comment sections in my humble opinion, providing a similar experience.
- throwawaygeu 11y agoAnd that is how only favourable and aproved comments will be shown. No more diversity of opinion.
- blowski 11y agoNot necessarily. Newspapers have been doing this for years, and (the quality ones at least) frequently show letters that disagree and point out errors. If vice.com wanted to show only comments that agreed with them, they could do that already.
- throwawaygeu 11y agoAnd most sites (cant speak for these ) mostly do it alreadyly. Try saying that eg:wage gap doesn' exist and link some articles by economists - 9 out of 10 times such comments get "moderated".
- jamespo 11y agoI like how you have created a throwaway to express your opinions on commenting
- talmand 11y agoThese days anything coming close to controversial on the "wrong side" requires it.
- throwawaygeu 11y agoFYI this throwaway is my only unbanned account here. Hint - newer call out woman when she lies on hacker news.
- blowski 11y agoI personally doubt that 90% of dissenting comments are deleted by site owners purely because they are dissenting. Go to any article on the BBC, Economist, Daily Mail, Guardian, etc, and the majority of comments seem to disagree with the author. Perhaps comments are being deleted for not being respectful, because they're considered spammy, or for some other reason.
- downandout 11y agoWhy not create a comments section that runs split testing on the comments? So you enter a comment, and that comment will be randomly shown to a certain percentage of others. Based on up/down votes and response count, eventually the system could deduce the most relevant comments without moderation.
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoI like this idea. It's a bit like how slashdot works: random moderation.
- ckozlowski 11y agoA fellow IRC moderator once warned me: "Carefully handle your "troublemakers". They're both the bane and life of your site." In other words, it's often your outspoken (and sometime inappropriate) members that are driving the most interesting discussion. I see this on Facebook quite a lot (I moderate a very large group) where the people who are often stirring up trouble in one thread are also generating a very lively discussion in another. It's hard drawing the line sometimes between what seems like a vehement disagreement in opinion and insulting of someone else, and a tap on their shoulder to "hey, just keep in line please" can either set them off, or defuse the situtation. But either way, it is difficult. Too heavy-handed in moderation and you drive them off the site, leaving a lot of silent people sitting around with little discussion, and therefor, little reason to stay. Too little moderation and your comments and threads become a cesspool, eliminating any beneficial conversation and catering to the lowest common denominator. I don't blame Vice for finding this difficult, and really, I'm not sure I'd prescribe a solution for them. I agree with them in the sense that it comes down to their resources and best use of their time, and given that they produce their own content (and not reliant on their members to do it as in other social forums) then it may be better to dispense with them altogether. But dispensing with a forum is a sort of "scorched earth" policy of eliminating an out of control board, a "nuclear option" when you're just finished with it all. It'll provide some relief, but they lose at the chance of growing something better in the end.
- untog 11y ago> In other words, it's often your outspoken (and sometime inappropriate) members that are driving the most interesting discussion. I disagree. I'll admit that I haven't done any kind of exhaustive analysis, but every now and then I'll click on the profile of an obvious troll on HN or Reddit. 9/10 times they are consistently trolling and contributing nothing to the community.
- ckozlowski 11y agoNot quite disagreeing with you, but I think in this case there's a difference between your trolls and the "argumentative/easy to be offended" types. The latter are what I'm referring to.
- aeris 11y agoClosed comments on a website are clear sight that the editorial staff can't take public criticism.
- ghaff 11y agoOr simply that they feel low quality comments detract from the site relative to whatever engagement/informational value they add. Some types of sites in particular (consumer gadgets for example) seem to attract lots of warring fanboy-ism without much in the way of signal. Yes, turning off comments is something of a nuclear option but you can't chalk it up purely to blocking criticism.
- talmand 11y agoWhy not both?
- RegW 11y agoI think this is a matter of value. If someone puts work into an article, then it must be disappointing to find credit being given to a pile of dross attached to the bottom, by people who can't be bothered to think before they type. I notice theregister.co.uk has shoved comments off onto a separate less important page. So you only follow the link when your blood is really boiling (and put yourself into a self-selecting group). Comments work for the www.dailymail.co.uk because their articles are generally written to bait their readers, and drivel in the comments is how they measure success. Stories are marked up with how many thousand comments they have generated. The real challenge is to get your comment to the top of the "worst" rated category.
- erikb 11y agoWhy something better? The title (of the article) should read "we close comments, write an email if you really need to". And being a Linux nerd who uses a lot of "old tools" like vim, grep, etc. I still can't understand why people switch from any communication technology X to email nowadays. Email is slowly dying, no reason to jump on that train if you don't have a lot of fancy configs/setup/knowhow in that area already.
- ckozlowski 11y ago"Something better (for us)". I'm gonna take a stab at this and say that I think what they're banking on is that the added effort needed to compose an email (and the lack of a public audiance) is going to raise the barrier of entry and lower the potential payout to eliminate all of the "low-quality, impulse commenting" they felt they were getting flooded with. And that they're basically equating email to writing a letter in magazine days says a lot about the state and view people have of email, in line with your point.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>"What percentage of comments on any site are valuable enough to be published on their own? One percent? Less?" What percentage of "articles" on the web are valuable enough to be published on their own? One percent? Less? Most sites, including HN, I visit because of the comment sections. Many times the comments are the most insightful part of my interaction.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoOn HN the comments are the product. On Vice the content is.
- eimai134 11y agoI agree with the OP. Vice is pretty much a trash site.
- acheron 11y agoYeah, that's pretty rich coming from a clickbait trash site like vice. I'm not sure I've ever seen a worthwhile article there.
- eimai134 11y agoThat's very true. I find that many of the commenters do better research into the topic than the writer.
- mashed_potato 11y agoWhat we really need is a nice and cosy safe space. Throw Web 2.0 right into the trash.
- jalfresi 11y agoI remember when people would post stuff on their website and people would respond by posting their own retort on their own website, linking to the original article. Then there might be another retort back, or others would chime in on their own websites... And it was great! People took time to formulate arguments or counterpoints (this didn't guarantee they were correct or even sensible) in a long form that actually contributed to the discussion. If you want to troll people in response to a post, it meant you had to do it on your own website! I hope we go back to this. It's dirt cheap now to get a wordpress blog or similar. I wish wordpress came with comments disabled by default and all that pingback and RSS stuff would get more attention. It was a much more interesting time to read on the web.
- catbird 11y agoHave you taken a look at Tumblr? It's almost exactly what you are describing.
- pmlnr 11y agoNot really; tumblr makes reposting too easy, not requiring any effort to do so, therefore it's not as it's described. http://indiewebcamp.com/webmention http://indiewebcamp.com/webmention is the one you're looking for.
- ck2 11y agoSo you are saying broadcast TV media had the right idea all along and communication should be one-way. I think not. Basically you either build a community for two-way discussion from the start or instead you end up with a blog that tries to tack on discussion later on and end up "surprised" that there aren't quality comments.
- RaSoJo 11y agoI am a big fan of letters to the editors in my local newspaper. I try often to send in my opinions. (though they rarely get printed) But that is the only NewsPaper I consume and my relationship with it is way more personal than any online portal. All websites that I visit are based on links shared via my friends on FB, people on Twitter and Discussions on HN. I really have no personal connection with any online content platform. So unless Vice has a captive audience that visits it religiously and has that personal connection, I am not sure how this section is going to help. It is pretty much the same as stating that “Comments are Turned off. Period.”
- krapp 11y ago>"What percentage of comments on any site are valuable enough to be published on their own? One percent? Less? Based on the disparity in quality between emails we get and the average state of comments here and all over the web, I think the problem is a matter of the medium." The problem is not the medium, the problem is sites seem to expect the medium to be something it isn't. Vice seems to consider it an obvious flaw that most comments aren't publishable as standalone articles, as if users should be expected to run every comment through several drafts and past a copy editor before posting, and yet comments by definition tend to produce low quality content, because they're discussions between individuals, or between an individual and the site. The immediacy and lack of polish is the feature, not the bug. Do you want your community to be a tavern or a symposium? Focusing on the comment as a standard of quality is understandable for a site which is using comments as an easy way to drive engagement, but I think doing so disregards the actual purpose of the medium. If what you want from a comments section is a steady stream of high quality, long-form content you can control then what you don't want is comments, what you want is to crowdsource copy writing without compensation. Even on HN, which is obsessed with "quality" above all else, most comments are worthless on their own, but in aggregate the entire conversation has value. And yes, comments can be full of trolling and bigotry and stupidity and chaos. Hacker News has its share of that as does any active forum. But that has to be the price you're willing to pay, even with moderation, to have an open community. Many sites are discovering the return for the amount of effort required to maintain even moderate civility is not worth the effort.
- desult 11y agoIt's not Vice. It's just Motherboard, Vice's tech and science site. Every other Vice site except Broadly (the newest) still has comments.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoWhen Reuters did this (shut down comments), I wanted to chide them for giving up, yet I couldn't disagree with the rationale. Tough call.
- gwbas1c 11y agoI really like contextual discussion, specifically what we're doing here. The article is linked to on Hacker News, and then we return to Hacker News to discuss. The same thing happens on Facebook. Slashdot has discussions on Slashdot; and then they link to sites on their Facebook page. Another discussion happens on Slashdot's Facebook page. What's interesting about contextual discussion like this is that the flavor changes quite dramatically. Slashdot's discussions are a bit more lively... Hacker New's discussions are a bit more, uhm, "grown up." Sometimes, an article linked to on Hacker News has a much better discussion on Hacker News than whatever is on the article's message board.
- eimai134 11y agoI see a number of websites that don't have comments. I also notice that when an article is controversial, sometimes a site that usually has comments has them turned off for that article. I think this is a kind of censorship. Newspapers used to do this by taking letters to the editor, but carefully selecting the ones they wanted to print. Obviously, every website owner has the freedom to choose to have comments or not - I hope that things don't shift that way though. One of the great things about online comments is seeing what the public thinks vs. what the media is portraying.
- anigbrowl 11y agoI used to think that was a great thing about comments. Now I quite like websites where they're switched off, because comment communities can be easily dominated by a small number of stupid or malicious people who drive out more thoughtful or nuanced commentary that doesn't suit their worldview. So often you're not really seeing what the public thinks, you're seeing what particular interest groups think, and if comments are dominated by bitter fights between adherents of, say, different political parties then a lot of people will just check out because there's no point in trying to have a civil discussion in a roomful of screaming ideologues.
- chestnut-tree 11y agoThe BBC news website used to do something similar. You could submit a comment below an article but it would be up to their editorial staff to pick which comments would be published. In typical BBC fashion, they would try and publish equal numbers of consenting and dissenting views. Later, they modified this practice so that "The comments published below reflect the balance of views we received." (their words). Naturally, this method of commenting raised the ire of many who accused the BBC of 'censoring' views. Now anyone can comment on BBC news articles and, in my view, the comment sections are of such low quality, they are completely unreadable. So in a way, as a reader, I preferred the old practice of publishing a selection of comments (a bit like sending a letter to the editor of a newspaper), because what was published was varied, generally well-composed and of managable reading length. But as a user commenting I can see how frustrating it would be to repeatedly submit comments that were never selected for publication.