3 ms·
What level of certainty is "beyond a reasonable doubt"? 99%? If we let the state take a prisoners life based on 99% certainty of guilt, 1 out of 100 prisoners t
by philwelch 11y ago
What level of certainty is "beyond a reasonable doubt"? 99%? If we let the state take a prisoners life based on 99% certainty of guilt, 1 out of 100 prisoners thus killed will be innocent. Is this an acceptable margin--to kill 1 innocent man for every 99 actual murderers?
- Tomte 11y agoYou can't quantify a level of conviction or belief like that. That's unreasonable. Other than that: since people indicted are more likely to have committed the crimes than the general population (oh, I can already hear them scream...), you'd have to take that into account if you really wanted to calculate probabilities.
- philwelch 11y agoIt doesn't matter what the number is, so much as to illustrate the basic principle that we can never be 100% certain, and if we can't be 100% certain than we are choosing to kill innocent people.