9 ms·
Users Have Been Betrayed in the Final TPP Deal
- walterbell 11y agoWhile we await public release of the final TPP text, here is a review of a draft IP chapter, http://www.freezenet.ca/an-analysis-of-the-latest-tpp-leak/ http://www.freezenet.ca/an-analysis-of-the-latest-tpp-leak/. We need specialists and journalists to present credible analysis for the hundreds of millions of people who would be bound by the proposed laws. "... breaking a copyright protection system (i.e. DRM, TPM, etc.) would land you in hot water ... if you need to circumvent a DRM for personal use, you are now liable for criminal penalties. Traditionally, for many jurisdictions, circumventing DRM is typically reserved for civil penalties. Criminal penalties implies that the government would foot the bill for enforcement. In civil cases, it is typically rights holders that go after individuals. ... civil damages do apply. How much are civil damages if an alleged infringer is found guilty? Well, that is up to rights holders, not a judge. Prosecution is able to determine the damages and a judge would have to accept whatever number comes out regardless of evidence to the contrary. A good example might be that a song may be sold for 99 cents, but the damages sought could be in the millions for all the prosecutors are concerned. ... an act of copyright infringement as set forth in this “trade” agreement doesn’t actually have to occur before the authorities are sent after you. There just has to be evidence that infringement is taking place or is about to take place. ... if you have a cell phone, and you have something on it that could be considered infringing, authorities have the right to seize it because you are suspected of trafficking. Of course, you could also be liable for civil and criminal penalties as earlier outlined and could be fined any amount copyright holders feel like. ... you could be fined on the spot because of your cell phone on top of it all. No need for a judge here. Also, no, you may not get your cell phone back. It could be destroyed ... Who gets to pay for all of this? According to page 77, you do."
- derekerdmann 11y agoI'm not convinced this analysis is reading the draft fairly: ... if you need to circumvent a DRM for personal use, you are now liable for criminal penalties. Traditionally, for many jurisdictions, circumventing DRM is typically reserved for civil penalties. Criminal penalties implies that the government would foot the bill for enforcement. In civil cases, it is typically rights holders that go after individuals." Except that here's the actual text: > Each [7] Party [US/SG/MX/NZ/PE/JP/BN/AU/CL/MY propose: shall] [CA propose: may] provide for criminal procedures and penalties to be applied where any person is found to have engaged willfully and for purposes of commercial advantage or financial gain in any of the above activities. That doesn't sound like "if you need to circumvent a DRM for personal use, you are now liable for criminal penalties" to me.
- hardwaresofton 11y agoDepends on how you define "financial gain". Bootleggers are one thing -- but if some big company decides that you saving money on DVDs you would have purchased otherwise is "financial gain", things could turn very quickly, right? The mere possibility of a criminal penalty POSSIBLY applying is a big move.
- walterbell 11y agoYour quoted text is a sub-clause of (ii) below, which applies to device supply chains. Personal, non-commercial circumvention of DRM is addressed in (i) below. "(i) knowingly, or having reasonable grounds to know,[174] circumvents without authority or any effective technological measure that controls access to a protected work,[175] performance, or phonogram;[176] or (ii) manufactures, imports, distributes[177], offers for sale or rental to the public or otherwise provide devices, products, or components, or offers to the public or provides services, that:"
- derekp7 11y agoSo this sounds like using one of the Youtube Downloader applications could land you in hot water -- even though there isn't any cryptographic DRM on youtube videos, it could be argued that since there isn't a Download button on the page, this is an "effective DRM measure", and that the downloader app could be a circumvention measure.
- anigbrowl 11y agoNo it isn't. It's part of the superordinate clause (a), and you can tell that because the subclause of (ii) that you mention has further subclauses ((A),(B),(c)) which end with a period. Think about how this would be indented: 1. *Blah blah blah.* Blah blah, blah blah blah blah blah: (a) blah blah blah; blah blah, blah blah blah where (i) blah blah, or (ii) blah blah blah, blah: (A) blah, (B) blah blah, or (C) blah blah blah. Blah blah blah, blah blah blah blah blah. *<< this is still part of subclause (1)(a)* (b) Blah blah blah [...] One of the depressing aspects of this whole TPP/TTIP debate here on HN is that although most people here either write code for a living or at least know how to do so, very few have ever thought through the fact that there are rules of scope in legal documents as well. I appreciate that such documents are very confusing, even more so when they are in draft form and include multiple 'live' options (rather like improperly declared constants in programming), and more so again when they're presented as just a big wall of text without any typographic structuring that would make them easier to read. Parsing such complex documents is difficult; if it were easy then courts would be less busy than they are. But a great deal of the 'analysis' of the impending trade agreements (as well as other legal stuff that is sometimes posted to HN) seems to start with an assumption about meaning or purpose, and then go through the text looking for clues to back it up. This is a fast track to self-deception and eventual defeat in the event of a dispute. I'm not a lawyer, just a law nerd.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> We need specialists and journalists to present credible analysis for the hundreds of millions of people who would be bound by the proposed laws. Let's hope we get them. Personally, I expect Reddit to be able to deliver the necessary attention and expertise to cover the issue thoroughly. EDIT to downvoters: that was not meant as a joke. Reddit is usually orders of magnitude better information source than any media outlet. Just ignore the front page and look at a relevant subreddit. Take a look at, e.g., https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/3nl4sz/eli5_the_transpacific_partnership_deal/ https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/3nl4sz/e... and tell me you've actually seen a better summary by a mainstream media outlet.
- walterbell 11y agoCould you recommend relevant subreddits? https://www.reddit.com/r/TPP/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TPP/ does not have many comments.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoNot yet. I expect that after the TPP becomes available to read, people from various political, news and law-related subreddits will pool up and revive /r/TPP or start something new. A sticked post will likely emerge, that will be linked to from various subreddits, which will serve as an entry point to the analysis of the topic. It'll be easy to find.
- JumpCrisscross 11y agoThat doesn't appear to be an un-biased sub. From its description: >The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) is a secretive, multinational trade agreement that threatens to extend restrictive intellectual property (IP) laws across the globe and rewrite international rules on its enforcement.
- zouhair 11y agoI dunno about the TPP but the work of /u/phlogistic https://www.reddit.com/r/mylittlelistentothis/comments/vnqae/moments_musicaux_1_introduction_to_classical_music/c6c9cqh https://www.reddit.com/r/mylittlelistentothis/comments/vnqae... is just mind boggling if you are interested in classical music. note: some of the early links to some YouTube links are dead but it is not hard to search for alternative given the information provided.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- codingdave 11y agoWhile I'm certain there will be areas of concern, I'm unclear how we are supposed to intelligently send our concerns along if the text of the agreement will not be available for 30 days. We'll look like idiots if we start quoting language from a 2 month old leak if that language was not in the final agreement.
- mhurron 11y ago> I'm unclear how we are supposed to intelligently send our concerns along if the text of the agreement will not be available for 30 days It doesn't matter, it's not like the peoples complaints will mean anything.
- guelo 11y agoSee SOPA.
- retrogradeorbit 11y agoBut as a counterpoint, the crypto war. The second one we're in right now. Didn't this get settled? Oh wait, new administration. Time for the powers that shouldn't be to try again.
- latj 11y agoInstead of telling Washington about my dissatisfaction I've decided I'm going to piss in the ocean. I suspect the outcome will be the same, except it feels so great to piss in the ocean.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoI just have to say - thanks for making my day man.
- angersock 11y agoThis is basically the catharsis of anonymous messaging boards.
- ck2 11y agoIf you think they would never hassle people over this stuff, let me remind you that every day the TSA holds people without the ability to contact a lawyer.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tosseraccount 11y agoAny free market policies being proposed for lawyers and doctors?
- thedangler 11y agoThis makes me think that it would be nice to have two passwords for your device. One to access it, and one to erase the device and go back to default settings. Unless that is illegal too.
- jdmichal 11y agoThat would be called tampering with evidence, and is very illegal in the United States. You would likely be able to be charged with that and obstruction of justice just for giving them the kill-password.
- archimedespi 11y agoBut there's always plausible deniability :)
- jdmichal 11y agoGood luck on plausible deniability when they have your device, enter the password that you told them, and see the device factory reset. The fun part is, regardless of whether or not the device held incriminating evidence, the act of clearing it is still illegal. Even if you cleared the device before it was taken into custody, they could still have a case if they can reasonably show that you cleared it with suspicion that it would be taken into custody. Obviously, that can be difficult to show, depending on the burden of proof required.
- hardwaresofton 11y agoMaybe this is relevant here, district court recently found that forcing suspects to reveal their phone passwords is forced self incrimination: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/09/forcing-suspects-to-reveal-phone-passwords-is-unconstitutional-court-says/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/09/forcing-suspects-... (but they might just have you enter them yourself instead :/)
- 11y ago
- spacemanmatt 11y agoWe are all Chinese, now.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vacri 11y agoI was thinking more "We are all American, now". China isn't in the TPP. However, the US is pushing a lot of it's IP law.
- Maken 11y agoOceania versus Eastasia. Does it really matter?
- josho 11y agoFor those that down voted the above is a reference to Orwell's 1984 where big brother watches us all and the above nations are in perpetual conflict to keep the population in line. In light of my understanding of some of the TPP provisions I thought it was an apt reference.
- danharaj 11y agoThe incumbent powers will say that this promotes a lot of freedom and a lot of rights. Free trade, free markets, freedom, freedom, freedom. Property rights are individual rights! You don't want to be a dirty socialist, do you? Property rights are the underpinning of all freedom. If you refuse to strengthen them, you refuse to strengthen liberty, you monster! Here we see property rights being strengthened to the point of undermining popular sovereignty! How can they be called rights when the stronger they are and the more aggressively they are enforced the more authoritarian the world feels?
- ryandrake 11y agoProperty rights are only "individual rights" for those individuals who happen to own property.
- noonespecial 11y agoAll this is true. The sneaky thing they are doing is to quietly define more and more of the things you pay for to no longer be your property.
- hijjjdbind 11y agoThe only effective protest would be mass coordinated breaking and flaunting of these laws if TPP gets passed.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- narrator 11y agoMusic, entertainment, simple generic drugs and many other things are being made too inexpensive thanks to technology and globalization. I think these trade deals are attempts to put that genie back in the bottle and increase the price through extension of artificial rights and enforcement of criminal penalties against violators.
- waqf 11y agoThere's a big difference between drugs (which did legitimately cost someone at some point many millions to research and prove effective and safe) and music (which anyone with a modicum of talent can make in their garage and which costs millions only to market). As a corollary, get your music from people with no marketing budget. They'll be forced to charge what it actually costs.
- montecarl 11y agoRegarding drug cost and development, I wonder what the drug market would look like without patent law? Right now, and for the foreseeable future, drug R&D is expensive. If companies could not patent their drugs they would not make enough money off their product to be profitable. What would this do to the market? One possible way it would work is that all drug development would be done by non-profits and government sponsored labs. Then drug R&D would be paid for directly by the people who want the drugs upfront and anyone could produce them. The final cost of drugs would be just a markup on the manufacturing cost. The alternative is that people would not develop drugs, but I find it hard to believe that this would be the case.
- Frqy3 11y agoThe problem with drug research is that current incentives reward companies to focus on new (or sufficiently new to patent) medicines of little advantage and compete for market share at high prices, rather than to develop clinically superior medicines by focussing on social benefit vs costs. More publicly funded research into drugs with high social benefits would also help.
- nerdcity 11y agoWho fights for the User?
- gnaritas 11y agoTron.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hodwik 11y agoThey're really hurting themselves with this legislation, I for one welcome it. If pirating Beyoncé will put you in jail, more people will be willing to listen to all of the great free music on sites like bandcamp and soundcloud. That's the major benefit to this legislation as I see it. Overpriced pop media garbage will become decreasingly popular in exchange for better but less-popular works. As recording and film companies see large swathes of the population leaving their works for independent producers, they'll lower their prices to try to stay relevant. I say this even as a frequent media pirate -- this is not the end of the world, far from it. If this legislation has teeth, it will birth a new world of free creativity, of the people and for the people. Edit: The same, I propose, will be true of opensource hardware.
- bad_user 11y agoI think you're going to be disappointed about the future. Given I need music to keep focused at work, I got a subscription to Google Play. Now I've got access to all the Beyonce I need for $10 / month. It kind of sucks because my desktop is not capable of caching music for offline use, only my Android can. Plus, if I end my subscription, I get to keep nothing. It's a great way to discover new music though. And I don't like SoundCloud because the signal to noise ratio is not that good and I don't have the patience. My point is that the notion of buying songs and albums is coming to an end. I personally don't like it, but there you have it. And sorry to say it, but for this future in which we rent music, I also blame piracy. I also think ad-blockers will be the catalyst for a similarly dark future for websites. The underlying cause is always people illegally using and not willing to pay for other people's work.
- shkkmo 11y ago> for this future in which we rent music, I also blame piracy Um, how? Why not blame high-speed internet instead?
- retrogradeorbit 11y agoExcept the law will not be applied to protect the rights of independent musicians. Only of big business. Everyone will pirate the indies and those rights holders will be ignored. This law, like all laws today, will not be applied evenly. It's not meant to serve us. It's meant to serve power.
- pc2g4d 11y agoA little early to freak out, don't you think, EFF? Sure, there was some nasty crap in the leaked text, but what's going to actually be debated and potentially passed as law is the text that was agreed in the wee hours of the morning and isn't available yet. Some things in the negotiations seem to have actually gone against the U.S. IP approach, e.g. biologics protection term. To me it seems wiser to wait until the final text is out before deciding whether/in what ways to oppose it.
- hackuser 11y agoPaul Krugman's take from March: I’d argue that it’s implausible to claim that TPP could add more than a fraction of one percent to the incomes of the nations involved; even the 0.5 percent suggested by Petri et al looks high to me. These gains aren’t nothing, but we’re not talking about a world-shaking deal here. So why do some parties want this deal so much? Because as with many “trade” deals in recent years, the intellectual property aspects are more important than the trade aspects. Leaked documents suggest that the US is trying to get radically enhanced protection for patents and copyrights; this is largely about Hollywood and pharma rather than conventional exporters. http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/11/tpp-at-the-nabe/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/11/tpp-at-the-nabe/
- ranprieur 11y agoYou can't be betrayed if you weren't promised anything. Users simply have no power inside the system.
- PSeitz 11y agoNot everyone has a twitter account, and not everyone wants one.