6 ms·
You can't just charge people the same rate that an advertiser would pay for that person to view something; by charging for the article, you are going to certain
by cortesoft 11y ago
You can't just charge people the same rate that an advertiser would pay for that person to view something; by charging for the article, you are going to certainly get less viewership than if you publish it for free. To earn the same with a pay-per-view model as you would with free-but-with-ads, you are going to have to get paid more per viewer.
This is the same fallacy that content providers make with piracy; you can't just multiply the number of pirates by the cost of the item to see how much money you 'lost' to piracy. You will always get more viewers/readers/users when something is free.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoYou make the comment "... by charging for the article, you are going to certainly get less viewership than if you publish it for free. To earn the same with a pay-per-view model as you would with free-but-with-ads, you are going to have to get paid more per viewer." I don't believe this has been established yet. Sure there are lots of people who won't even give up their email address and they run AdBlock and they whine everytime an article to the WSJ or NYTimes is linked to on HN. But that preference for "free" information is being proven unsustainable as we type. And Apple's moves are going to make it that more obvious. And like Netflix which showed piracy was a service problem not a content problem, so is written text on the Internet. Imagine there was a service that you could pay $25 a year for, that in exchange for your $25 a year, would take all annoying ads off every page of every website you cared about to read. Think about that. And if that $25 got distributed, a third of a cent at a time, to every web site that participated in this, and you read their articles, that money flowed to them, for providing the content you wanted to read? It changes the dynamic, it changes the parameters of A/B testing, and I suspect that a large chunk of the 40 million AdBlock+ users would sign up for it. A web site with a million of those page views a day, would bring in $90,000 a month. Piracy, and articles on the web, is a mismatch between what the content provider thinks something is worth, and what something is really worth. If you artifically price it above what people think it is worth, you get piracy. If you provide a way for market dynamics to price it and capture the value you can see what it is really worth. So rather an author saying "This article is worth $10,000" you throw out that article into a networked system which has millions of "small" votes, all articles compete for votes based on their value to the community. Value wins. And like Netflix where a movie that is a dog may not make any more revenue by being part of the instant catalog, articles that aren't actually valuable won't suddenly have value by participating in this market. Conversely, articles that do have value, will automatically do very well financially.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> If you provide a way for market dynamics to price it and capture the value you can see what it is really worth. And here is the problem. Content creators are still finding out painfully that what they create isn't worth what they believe it to be. Welcome to price discovery!
- ChuckMcM 11y agoExactly this. Price discovery can really bite. But if you've been watching this develop as long as I have its really fascinating to see how these markets emerge.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- shostack 11y agoChuck, I appreciate your thoughtful insights on this. But what happens if it turns out that an insufficient minority are willing to pay for content to make businesses like the NYT and other publishers viable businesses (or at least viable at their current scale in their current incarnation)? My current thinking is that if they were to stop writing, people would just get their news from elsewhere, and other publishers would gladly fill their shoes. What are your thoughts around that? If enough people keep rejecting approaches to payment models (indicating they are not willing to pay), will we simply see the publisher space continue to shrink/degrade until it reaches equilibrium with the revenue they can manage to eek out?
- ChuckMcM 11y ago"But what happens if it turns out that an insufficient minority are willing to pay for content to make businesses like the NYT and other publishers viable businesses (or at least viable at their current scale in their current incarnation)?" I think about it slightly differently. If you ask the question "Will all the news organizations and publishers go out of business?" And the answer is obvious, no they won't. The reason they won't is because there is a demand for content and the only people left standing will be the ones who can deliver content in a way that pays their own bills. Will the NYTimes go out of business? Perhaps. This is the fallacy in a nutshell : "My current thinking is that if they were to stop writing, people would just get their news from elsewhere, and other publishers would gladly fill their shoes." Nobody will commit finanical suicide to serve a market. They have to believe that there is a way to make money at it, so the only way "other publishers" jump into the market is if they can do so without losing their shirts. What we're observing is the death of the "put up some content and slap some ads on it" way of making money. That it has worked this long has been very impressive as there is very little barrier to entry, but the commons is so thoroughly stomped upon with blog spam and content farms is finally killing it. Having service providers listen to their users and allow them to disable ads, puts the final nail in that coffin. Is it no wonder they scream loudly? The vote is being called as they say, "Either put up with ads, or pay for your content." The challenge though is how to negotiate what the content is worth? How do you make a market so that people can actually implement that choice over a wide range of pricing so that the market collectively they can arrive at a price? It is something I thought Bitcoin like systems might help with, but any microtransaction system if it has low enough friction would work. Publishers could tweak the price of page views, readers could read or not read the content provided. Prices would float up to equilibrium and people will be able to once again reason about what an article is worth, whether it was written by a hack in a third world country or written by someone with an established reputation for quality. The existing market is collapsing, and in its place a new market will emerge because people really do like reading stuff. And enough people like it to make it into a market. Capturing that value which was learned back in Ben Franklin's days for what became newspapers, will be relearned given the channels and technology we have today. Its cost structure will be different, I would hope more of the value would flow through to the authors but one can never predict these things. Music is in the middle of the same process. But the music industry won't cease to exist, but it could very easily transform into something we would not recognize.