2 ms·
> I can't help but wonder if the author's characters were slightly sexist. What if the characters were written this way on purpose? You often run across simila
by Someone1234 11y ago
> I can't help but wonder if the author's characters were slightly sexist. What if the characters were written this way on purpose?
You often run across similar criticisms of Game of Thrones in particular.
In the GoT world there are legitimately bad people, and not comic book style evil villains but instead bad people that feel true to life, and often have legitimate motivations for doing the bad things that they do.
So you run across these long articles criticising GoT, the author, or just asking things like "why did this [bad thing] have to occur? Wasn't it avoidable? Did we really need to read that? What was the motivation for putting it in?"
You often don't notice this style of complaint when the fiction is either more unrealistic or less true to life. I think people get disturbed by the plot/world/characters, and then lose sight that it is perfectly reasonable for "bad things" to happen in fiction. And yes it can contribute to the narrative, and the author doesn't need to apologise for it, or justify it.
I am not suggesting that anyone cheer for sexism in this book. But is it inherently wrong that there IS sexism in the book if that is the world the book's story ache takes place in?
PS - Of course anyone can criticise anything they wish. But they aren't immune from their criticism being in turn criticised.