4 ms·
What tedunangst says is true enough in the logical sense, but it makes me nervous in the human sense. Humans seem prone to the following logic failure: 1.
by jerf 11y ago
What tedunangst says is true enough in the logical sense, but it makes me nervous in the human sense. Humans seem prone to the following logic failure:
1. Object X frequently removes limbs from the user.
2. Object Y does the same thing, but more safely.
3. Wait, Object Y causes hangnails if you misuse it hard enough.
4. It's OK to keep using Object X!
Like many fallacies, this doesn't survive being clearly written out, but I still see it an awful lot.
- rhelmer 11y agoI don't know, I think it's a pretty fair treatment - there are links to an advisory that Ted thinks Rust could have prevented (http://www.x.org/wiki/Development/Security/Advisory-2015-02-10/ http://www.x.org/wiki/Development/Security/Advisory-2015-02-...) and to a blog post disagreeing with his http://tonyarcieri.com/would-rust-have-prevented-heartbleed-another-look http://tonyarcieri.com/would-rust-have-prevented-heartbleed-...
- jerf 11y agoI am saying tedunangst's treatment is fair. What I don't like is what people in general tend to do with the argument. I am not claiming tedunangst is doing that with the argument.