5 ms·
> Why not make this open knowledge? Suppose Alice tells me that Bob is flaky and can't be relied on. I need a lot of information in order to be able to evalua
by klodolph 11y ago
> Why not make this open knowledge?
Suppose Alice tells me that Bob is flaky and can't be relied on. I need a lot of information in order to be able to evaluate that claim.
* Maybe Alice and Bob were in a relationship a few months ago, and there was a bad breakup. Alice's experience of Bob would probably be different from my experience of Bob.
* Maybe Alice also told me bad things about Carol and Dan, so I think that Alice just has a dim view of people in general, and isn't willing to give them the benefit of the doubt.
* Maybe Alice heard everything from Eve, so I need to consider whether I trust Eve.
* Maybe Bob got chosen over Alice for a promotion at work, even though Alice has seniority. So Alice might have an axe to grind.
* Maybe Alice hangs out with Frank and Grace, who bully Bob. So Bob naturally wouldn't want to be friends with people who bully him, even though Alice isn't doing anything wrong.
When I get this information from Alice in person, I can ask questions or just listen to Alice's tone of voice to figure out the kind of things I want to know about Bob. Putting the information in text form in an application makes it much harder to evaluate Alice's claims, because it only make's Alice's opinion open knowledge.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoSuppose the app was smart enough to do some clever analysis. For example, if all the people who leave bad reviews of Bob are all friends with each other, it should count as a single bad review (so as to not double-count the evidence), and if Alice left bad reviews of several of your friends, it should know that you will probably find Alice untrustworthy, because she dislikes the people you like. Not that we can trust Peeple or any other app to get that right, but it sounds like it should be possible.
- klodolph 11y ago> Suppose the app was smart enough to do some clever analysis. When Alice gives a bad review of Bob, I think to myself, "Why is Alice giving a bad review of Bob?" I'm putting myself in Alice's shoes. There is absolutely no hope that a computer program would be sophisticated enough to do that, not yet, not for at least a decade (translation: possibly not in my lifetime). Computers can't even solve the "simple" problem of matching people in romantic relationships. When we throw computers at the more general problem of human interactions and trust, we should naturally expect them to completely botch it.
- mdpopescu 11y agoThis is something I was thinking about as a solution for traffic violations: have drivers rate each other; increase the "trustworthiness factor" of anyone who thumbs down few people and those people are also negatively rated by others and/or have accidents; decrease the multiplier for those who just negatively rate everybody and so on. Unfortunately, I think you can hit some mines related to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow%27s_impossibility_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow%27s_impossibility_theore... but who knows? Maybe it won't happen given that you don't want a transitive relation, you want a numeric score for each driver. (Such a score could be used to influence insurance premiums; as an anarchist, I'm generally thinking about solutions for problems like "suppose we don't have patrol cops".)