4 ms·
Ah. In my generation, who actually watched the program, there is no ambiguity. No intent to deceive was detected by me. Its not supposed to be a trick question.
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Ah. In my generation, who actually watched the program, there is no ambiguity. No intent to deceive was detected by me. Its not supposed to be a trick question. Its supposed to illustrate how far off our intuition is about statistical behavior.
Monty himself mentions that he would occasionally try hard to argue contestants into swapping. They would always refuse. He would even explain that 'his door' had the better chance - nobody would listen. But I suppose that's confounded by the suspicion that he was trying to trick them.
- proksoup 11y agoI agree it would help to see the problem in action. Again, the part I missed was "it would be silly for him to reveal a car". I get that now, but that was not something that I intuited, and so the omission of that information I will continue to argue is at least a little bit deceptive. Even if only to those like myself who have not seen the program.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tel 11y agoThis may be very true and I think that if you're more familiar with the program and recognize that the host must know the answer then it becomes more a question of statistical intuition. I'm confident that there are lots of people who still fail to make the connection (though we're getting to the point where I think people are failing less due to a lack of statistical intuition and more due to a symbolic/physical model mismatch issue), but I think this problem wouldn't be as renowned as it is if it weren't for all of the even expert statisticians who are getting fooled. In their case it's definitely a matter of them misinterpreting the situation and the way that it's worded, for someone unfamiliar with the show, is at least a little "tricky".