3 ms·
> I personally would feel privileged to be a part of a group that puts engineering excellence beyond anything I wonder if other -- perhaps more minor -- achiev
by pron 11y ago
> I personally would feel privileged to be a part of a group that puts engineering excellence beyond anything
I wonder if other -- perhaps more minor -- achievements that displayed engineering excellence like the Apollo Program, invention of the transistor, the first compiler etc. espoused this same "enabling" culture.
> including my own hurt feelings
This is a meme that keeps coming up and shows a complete misunderstanding of this situation and others like it. This is not about hurt feelings. It is about marginalization, which is pushing (or keeping) qualified people away. Sometimes, the means of the marginalization is a hostile environment. Sometimes there are other means.
The author's feelings have not been hurt; she just couldn't stand working in an environment of assholes.
> If a team culture that delivers doesn't work for someone, the best thing to do is to move on
The best thing for whom? That person perhaps. But the best thing for our industry is that people speak up -- as Sarah Sharp has -- people listen, and people change things.
- zeveb 11y ago> I wonder if other -- perhaps more minor -- achievements that displayed engineering excellence like the Apollo Program, invention of the transistor, the first compiler etc. espoused this same "enabling" culture. You might be surprised. While I don't know about those particular projects, I know that, for example, Admiral Rickover was direct and blunt with those in the U.S. Navy's nuclear propulsion programme. He didn't suffer fools kindly, or at all. But then, he had the health and safety of his men, the nation and the world to worry about. I'd take a few hurt feelings over another Therac-25. > It is about marginalization, which is pushing (or keeping) qualified people away. No, mariginalisation is about pushing or keeping away people rejected by the group. When it keeps the unqualified away, it's a good thing. In the pursuit of excellence, even someone who's excellent on an absolute scale may not be excellent enough. A team of the best dozen engineers in the world will necessarily not include the 13th-best engineer: he is incredibly good, but he's just not good enough for that team. Is the kernel team marginalising the good enough along with the bad? I honestly don't know.
- deng 11y ago> I'd take a few hurt feelings over another Therac-25. Therac-25 was headed by an abusive manager, and all the good developers quit because they knew they could easily get a job elsewhere. Did I pull that out of thin air? Of course I did, but so did you.