3 ms·
Guess it depends on where you live. We have had days where we couldn't sit in the garden due to the smell. Also I had to through away my home grown tomatoes bec
by teekert 11y ago
Guess it depends on where you live. We have had days where we couldn't sit in the garden due to the smell. Also I had to through away my home grown tomatoes because they were basically growing in cat-shit.
- megaman22 11y agoHow's that any different than fertilizing them with, say, cow manure, which your store-bought organics might be using? I'm not certain of the chemical composition of cat manure, maybe its nitrogen content is too high or it screws with the soil pH?
- crpatino 11y agoI not an expert on the science behind it, so please correct me without freaking out if I get some detail wrong... but herbivore' manure may be applied directly to the soil. Pet's (dogs and cats) manure must be composted first. There are 2 plausible reasons why this may be so. The first is that large farm herbivore's (cows and horses mostly) are different enough from human beings that the diseases they carry cannot cross the species barriers so easily, not so with pets. Composting kills bacteria in at least 2 ways: it heats up and all but the thermophilic bacteria get killed, and competition from sturdier aerobic non-pathogenic bacteria in the compost pile drive off the rest after a couple dozen generations. This is specially important for dogs since we have been co-evolving to eat roughly the same foodstuffs for a couple million years. But I really don't see much of the same concerns for cats. The other idea is that cat's feces are what gardeners call "hot" themselves. It has nothing to do with temperature, but with overly high nitrogen contents. I don't have a reference at hand, but the basics of compost chemistry say that nitrogen based substances react and break down cellulose in the plant derived parts of the compost pile, making the carbon in it usable by the lifeforms in the soil. This has the side effect of coupling the toxic nitro in the catalyst (urine and feces) with carbon atoms, changing it into non-toxic forms that are themselves usable by the lifeforms in the soil as well.
- seunosewa 11y agoAll organic food grows in shit. It's called manure. You probably bought some.
- teekert 11y agoCarnivore feces are not considered to be advantageous for gardening and in the case of cat dumpings you also have the risk of toxoplasmosis to consider. Any manure you use for fertilizer should be well composted, as using fresh poop of any kind will tend to kill off your plants due to the high ammonia content and the heat of decomposition. Also, fresh herbivore poop tends to have undigested seeds in it which can lead to strange weeds in your flower beds. Toxoplasmosis is dangerous to pregnant women, it is why they shouldn't do gardening for 9 months.
- seunosewa 11y agoGood points, but none of this means that fruits grown in soil contaminated with cat poop must be destroyed. You just need to wash them.
- mordechai9000 11y agoI have two large dogs. When I was investigating the possibility of composting their waste, I ran across several sources that said even composted dog waste should only be used for ornamentals, not food plants. This may be out of an abundance of caution, but the idea is that plants drawing up nutrients and water from the soil can become contaminated with viable bacteria as well.
- seunosewa 11y agoThere is no evidence of the existence of cat/human diseases that can infect plants or plant diseases that can infect cats/humans. Plants and animals are enormously different biologically. A pathogen that has evolved to infect one is very unlikely to to be capable of infecting the other. It's just as likely as the existence of a nobel prize winning physicist who is also the heavyweight boxing champion of the world.