3 ms·
Don't be too hard on journalists. Humans, in general, think you write a sheet of vague wishes that you send off to an offshore developer, who will never tell yo
by Zigurd 11y ago
Don't be too hard on journalists. Humans, in general, think you write a sheet of vague wishes that you send off to an offshore developer, who will never tell you your specifications need work, or that you need a security specialist, or any other bad news.
The "several weeks" to open source the app smells bad, too. What horrors are being cleaned up? Did this NGO even get the analytics data or was that being harvested by their contract developers? Did anyone outside the contract shop, even an on-shore consultant, look at the code? Is the contract shop operating their back-end? That's deplorable, but also very common.
- LordKano 11y agoDon't be too hard on journalists. Humans, in general, think you write a sheet of vague wishes that you send off to an offshore developer, who will never tell you your specifications need work, or that you need a security specialist, or any other bad news. As a developer, I have seen what happens when you try to explain that there's an issue with the specs. "Oh, you can't do it? Do I need to find someone else?" I know of some serious vulnerabilities in a former employer's eCommerce system. When I brought them to the attention of my manager, I was told(Not in these exact words but the message was loud and clear) that we were being paid to add new features and no time would be wasted fixing security issues.
- Zigurd 11y agoThat's right, and the only cure, really, is smarter, more informed customers. I'm not blaming developers, especially cost-optimized offshore developers for not taking a client-protective advisory stance with their customers. They are not paid to do that. On the contrary, as you point out, the more agreeable they are to even the most harebrained customer requirements, the better for them.
- danso 11y agoAs a journalist, I agree with your sentiment :). I try to push my colleagues to adopt a more Unix-like mindset: use tools that are best at the one/few things they do...and stop thinking that technology can solve problems that you know to be intractably difficult. I'm not talking about recognizing the traveling salesman problem, I mean, if it seems complicated to keep your network of confidants both easily accessible and safe and hidden from outsiders...what is it about a piece of technology that makes you think it can all be wrapped up in a general-purpose user-friendly app? But to be fair, that's a difficult question for many engineers and developers to grasp as well...