3 ms·
As much as I am disgusted by the secrecy of these negotiations, the way they seem to be pushed down our throats, and indeed some of the stuff that was leaked (l
by mcv 11y ago
As much as I am disgusted by the secrecy of these negotiations, the way they seem to be pushed down our throats, and indeed some of the stuff that was leaked (like the ISDS), there does seem to be some good stuff in it:
"The worker standards commit all parties to the International Labor Organization’s principles for collective bargaining, a minimum wage and safe workplaces, and against child labor, forced labor and excessive hours."
and:
"The changes, which also are expected to set a precedent for future trade pacts, respond to widespread criticisms that the Investor-State Dispute Settlement panels favor businesses and interfere with nations’ efforts to pass rules safeguarding public health and safety."
Who knows? This might actually have turned into a decent treaty. But only because of all the massive criticism on the bits that leaked through all the secrecy.
- werber 11y agoAre there any primary sources about those claims? They sound great, along with the big pharma regulations. But still, I don't trust the NYT enough to fully buy it.
- emodendroket 11y agoThose are nice concessions, but I rather doubt that they aren't more than offset by other provisions.
- mcv 11y agoI want to see the concessions before I call them "nice". It's good that they listened to criticism, but did they listen enough? The basic idea behind ISDS is to me still a flagrant attack on justice and democracy. The article mentioned tobacco companies are excluded, which is certainly nice. But I'd also like to see everything related to public health excluded. I understand that corporations want to be protected against arbitrary protectionist law changes that disadvantage them, and I'm fine with that. But they don't deserve any protection from laws that intend to protect public health, labour conditions, civil rights, etc.
- emodendroket 11y agoI think we're basically in agreement.
- ck2 11y agohint: they aren't going to have anyone checking that the good stuff happens if no one is regulating child-labor, unsafe-labor, forced-labor, it can be done without penalty regardless if law or not but you can be damn sure cops will be breaking down your door in 1st world countries if you happen to do something that violated the TPP, they will make enforcement here profitable
- adevine 11y agoCan you explain your disgust about the negotiation secrecy? This is one complaint I really don't understand. Diplomacy is almost always done in secrecy until both sides are ready to propose something concrete. As the top comment says, trade deals are negotiated in secret but ratified in public. Everyone will get plenty of opportunity to review the full text of the deal to decide whether or not it's a good idea.