3 ms·
If those are failings of state not being strict enough, then let's state the corollary - that free market / competition are not saviours, but savage beasts that
by icebraining 11y ago
If those are failings of state not being strict enough, then let's state the corollary - that free market / competition are not saviours, but savage beasts that need to be controlled in order to put their power to good use.
I don't think anyone, not even ancaps, disagrees that market participants can be fraudulent or destructive. The disagreement is about what to do about it.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt's not that they 'can' be, but they will be (and are). A lot of people are in denial about it.
- icebraining 11y agoWho is in denial? That sounds like a strawman.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYou're right, I admit I was weasel-wording there a bit, but that's because of hurry (as I'm again on HN procrastinating before life-or-death (for me) deadline). By 'a lot of people' I meant the many people - from some of friends and colleagues to some members of various communities I participate in, HN included - that seem to be very convinced that total deregulation is the right thing to do and the market will turn benevolent if you remove all interference. I understand that there are subproblems for which deregulation indeed seems to be the right way to go; personally, I try to evaluate things on case-by-case basis. But it seems obvious that total, absolute deregulation would be disastrous and yet there are real people who seem to actually want exactly that absolute.
- icebraining 11y agoAh, yes. The confusion is assuming that advocating for deregulation means one thinks that markets are perfect - it doesn't. It just means they think that deregulation is not a good solution - much like someone can advocate against blood-letting as a cure for cancer without believing that cancer doesn't exist. For example, in this case the regulation didn't prevent VW from polluting, but it did help them fool people by giving fraudulent approval to the cars - it's not hard to argue it actually did worse than if it hadn't existed. Then there's regulatory capture, misguided policies that promote worse solutions, etc.