2 ms·
There are some situations in which this might work, but many other where it wouldn't. The asteroid would have to be small enough that the bomb could fragment it
by simonh 11y ago
There are some situations in which this might work, but many other where it wouldn't. The asteroid would have to be small enough that the bomb could fragment it sufficiently, we'd also have to be able to hit it early enough and fragment it enough that most of the fragments would miss the earth. If the asteroid was above the fragmentation capability of the warhead, or if it was detected late enough that the fragments would mostly still hit the earth then it wouldn't help.
Bear in mind that if most of the fragments still hit earth, the net energy delivery would still be about the same. This could actually be worse for the planet as a whole than a single hit. Finally, whether such a bomb could be effective would also depend on the structure of the asteroid or comet. This is due to the bugsplat effect, army slang for the fact that when a bomb hits a building or vehicle, the energy seems to be expended very asymmetrically. If you crush a bug with your boot, one part of the exoskeleton will weaken before the others and the insides get sprayed out in that direction. Similarly, if a bomb hits a vehicle often the majority of the explosive effect tends to get directed primarily in one direction. There are cases of people close to one side of a vehicle surviving unharmed, while people much further away in other directions get incinerated or hit by fragments. Similarly if the internal structure of the asteroid is asymmetrical, you could end up with material on one side of the asteroid (perhaps made up of already loose boulder material and dust) being thoroughly fragmented while larger more dense parts of it on the other surviving. Instead of many similarly sized fragments, you might well end up with a large percentage of the object remaining intact and all you did was scrub off looser material.