6 ms·
The total rule against dogs is a relatively modern interpretation in islam. It isn't even to do with the dogs themselves, but that most dogs were smelly and un
by sandworm101 11y ago
The total rule against dogs is a relatively modern interpretation in islam. It isn't even to do with the dogs themselves, but that most dogs were smelly and unclean creatures. There is plenty of evidence that the ban really only applied to mongrels, unclean street dogs. Working dogs (hunting/herding/guarding) particularly those similar to salukis, were not considered unclean and were kept. The Quran specifically states that animals caught by trained hunting dog may be eaten (005:004) with the necessary implication that they may be kept and trained.
The fear of black dogs is very much ingrained in many Muslim countries. But that tradition predates islam altogether and is widespread even in the west (black dogs are far less likely to be adopted).
- digi_owl 11y agoWell i'll take em. How can someone say no to this? https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/BlackLab2009.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/BlackLab...
- DonHopkins 11y agoAnd I'll take the black cats, which are also less likely to be adopted. To make up for that, August 17 is Black Cat Appreciation Day! [1] [2] #BlackCatsMatter #BlackDogsMatter [1] https://www.aspca.org/blog/celebrate-black-cat-appreciation-day-on-august-17 https://www.aspca.org/blog/celebrate-black-cat-appreciation-... [2] https://www.daysoftheyear.com/days/black-cat-appreciation-day/ https://www.daysoftheyear.com/days/black-cat-appreciation-da...
- DanBC 11y ago> #BlackCatsMatter #BlackDogsMatter Do you realise how tone deaf you sound here?
- DonHopkins 11y agoNo, please educate me. Should I have said #AllCatsMatter #AllDogsMatter ? Why the hissy fit? Are you accusing me of dog-whistle politics? Does this make you feel better? [1] [2] [1] https://www.pinterest.com/foundanimals/black-dog-appreciation-day/ https://www.pinterest.com/foundanimals/black-dog-appreciatio... [2] https://www.facebook.com/BlackDogAppreciationDayBlackDogWalk https://www.facebook.com/BlackDogAppreciationDayBlackDogWalk
- coldpie 11y agoThe objection is to your making light of protests focused on people being executed in the streets by their government because of their skin color.
- DonHopkins 11y agoSo do you believe that by discussing black dogs and cats being executed in animal shelters, I'm taking away from the focus on people being shot in the streets? Do you think I'm only capable of being concerned about one problem at a time, and I shouldn't care about black dogs and cats until all of our world's other problems are solved?
- DanBC 11y agoYou know there's a "Black Lives Matter" slogan, right? Feel free to talk about the death of animals - it's an important topic - but linking your campaign the the murder of humans by police officers is, and I say this as politely as I can, fucking stupid.
- DonHopkins 11y agoAre you aware that you sound like a right wing concern troll trying to make #BlackLivesMatter activists sound stupid?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jerf 11y agoI promise you that the following is a true story. When I was going to Michigan State University, my wife was getting a degree in Zoology. We're white, which is relevant to the story. As part of one of her classes or internships (can't recall which), she had to go speak to a school class about a topic in Zoology. At the time we had quite a few pets, including a black Labrador, and a white rat and a black rat, which she ended up bringing in as a way of engaging the students in the topic. The classroom was mostly African-American kids around the second grade, and the kids actually expressed amazement that the white woman had black pets. I'm typing this at least ten years later and I still don't really know how to react. Anyhow, point is, there's more here than you might think. For better or worse.
- megaman22 11y agoTo be fair, these are real hashtags that real people use. Some people are focused on living their lives, not tilting at every social justice windmill.
- _nedR 11y agoI don't know whether there has been a modern reinterpretation. The way i remember being taught in school, Muslims are allowed to keep dogs for hunting and guarding purposes, but we are not allowed to touch them (except perhaps on the head?), or let them into our houses. Not sure what exactly has changed except perhaps we don't hunt much any more.
- sandworm101 11y agoIt's like the jewish rules about food. The evidence is that the original rules were probably much less strict, but over the years various scholars tighten some rules just to be on the safe side, or to see more devout than everyone else. So it will depend on which modern expert you talk to.
- sudoherethere 11y agoAs far as I know, dogs are okay according to Quran but hadiths are against dogs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animals_in_Islam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animals_in_Islam