3 ms·
I am perfectly happy to have my arguments picked apart, and my expression of the arguments is frequently in need of improvement. Sometimes I even learn from my
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
I am perfectly happy to have my arguments picked apart, and my expression of the arguments is frequently in need of improvement. Sometimes I even learn from my interlocutors.
But cryptofascist?! Honestly ?
I mean this is HN. You are supposed to play the ball, not the man, and certainly not call the ball a cryptofascist ball.
Do you do this to people in real life? Have you actually used the word "cryptofasist" to a living breathing police officer? Did it come with the word "Man!" as well.
Really, stop it.
I should probably comment on the rest of your points, but it's hard to get over the first point. :-)
Edit: so, actually trying to respond.
It seems you say that open source software will align incentives, in a similar manner to (openish) standards of wrenches and parts.
I am a big supporter (can't spell proponent) of OSS in place of black box solutions - it opens up an enormous range of positive solutions. However OSS does not produce or guarantee standards. And standards are the issue I see here.
The ability to freely inspect is vital to produce a market of reliable products. It however is not sufficient - open inspection, agreed tests and measurements, and enforcement, are just parts of that.
Fake spare motor parts (OK, spare parts not meeting standards and with no accountability) should be prevented from entering the market - they increase the risk of failure, and even if it is possible to inspect the goods to determine their suitability, why should we impose that cost on every market participant? We have standards and enforcement to avoid such a problem - it could be seen as nanny state keeping people safe, or it could be seen as encouraging markets.
The method of ensuring markets are not polluted to the point of market failure will vary - most people relying on licensing and enforcement. It usually works.
I am arguing that someone who wants to inspect and play and learn about their car software should be allowed to just as they should be allowed to strip and clean an engine.
But even the cursory annual inspections (MA I assume is similar to UK's MOT) are supposed to catch below standard modifications. Even when I was younger, engines were too complex to be learnt, Father to Son, without a Hayes manual.
These days I am sure it is possible for a motivated, intelligent person to become sufficiently skilled that they could modify a modern engine, but I doubt they could do that and learn how to spot fake medication, determine if an aircraft jet engine was properly serviced and if their office block is using the correct steel joists.
The world is way to complex for us to trust God and test the rest. We have to trust that there are sufficient standards and enforcements in place that we can rely on goods and services - otherwise we see market failure.
And finally in my rambling, I do not see it sufficent that if someone has modified their car, their own self preservation instinct will prevent them driving it if it could kill us both. That's never going to fly.
We need standards, inspection, accountability to ensure we defeat market failure.
We want to move beyond markets that deal in goods or services that cannot be trivially inspected by each participant.
Ps
The code of Haranumbai (?) is an interesting example of regulatory failure and where standards are needed. There is a part
- mindslight 11y agoIn the context of discussing modifications and purporting to be open to the idea of end-user modification ("police the violation"), you wrote: > If the GPS on the car shows you on a public highway with a unlicensed binary drive train, frankly they can pull out the tyre bursting chains To me, it's a bait and switch to lead off as if you're open to end-user modifications, only to draw a line ruling out doing so on a public road - the normal and only use of 99% of consumer vehicles. And I don't think my characterization of your solution as "fascist" is overzealous either - it's based on fundamental reasoning that if someone breaks the rules they deserve immediate and severe punishment. Also FWIW, I don't think I've ever encountered any police officer who was a cryptofascist. Perhaps the ones in unmarked cars. Now, looking at your profile I see that you are in the UK (although I should have perceived based on spelling and kph). And I know regulation works much differently in the EU, with deny-by-default whitelisting instead of only reacting to problems. Perhaps in that environment, an individual working on their car really is different from an "official" mechanic. Or maybe the more cohesive regulatory environment just has you believing that it's more foolproof than it actually is. In the US, an individual and a mechanic are the same thing, both philosophically and practically. And while the US's ad-hoc regulatory environment causes its own problems, I wouldn't say that an epidemic of mechanically unsafe cars is one of them. So the only difference I see between modifying software and modifying hardware is that software has developed an insidious culture of "seems to work; good enough", even while being much more complex. But I think the answer to that is to push for openness and proper engineering, rather than entrenching manufacturers' sloppy processes of cobbling together reams of C and then keeping cameras out of the sausage factory. edit: I'll respond to the points in your substantial edit tomorrow, since it requires internalizing the two very different philosophies of top-down guarantees vs bottom-up flexibility. But I will say that in the US, the self-preservation instinct has indeed been enough for people to mostly self regulate (and when it fails, insurance). Perhaps not as much as the UK (no idea about the relative stats), but it is sustainable.
- Tomte 11y ago> And I don't think my characterization of your solution as "fascist" is overzealous either No, it's not "overzealous". It's insulting and a clear violation of https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html You defending that word choice shows a blatant disrespect for others here on HN. I'm really surprised you haven't been flagged to oblivion.