39 ms·
This sort of treatment is not distant history. It all boils down to the concept that women were their husband's literal property. A husband being bossed aroun
by sandworm101 11y ago
This sort of treatment is not distant history. It all boils down to the concept that women were their husband's literal property. A husband being bossed around by his wife was akin to a farmer being bossed around by his horse. And if you think treating people as legal property was abolished alongside slavery, think again.
"Wife selling persisted in England in some form until the early 20th century; according to the jurist and historian James Bryce, writing in 1901, wife sales were still occasionally taking place during his time."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wife_selling_%28English_custom%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wife_selling_%28English_custom...
- _yosefk 11y agoFrom the Wikipedia article: "Although the custom had no basis in law and frequently resulted in prosecution..." and "Writing in 1901 on the subject of wife selling, James Bryce stated that there was "no trace at all in our [English] law of any such right." (It also says that people did it despite it being illegal, but this doesn't seem very different from any subculture encouraging illegal behavior at any point in time, in that such subcultures always exist, and one can't extrapolate the attitudes within such a subculture to the entire society.)
- sandworm101 11y agoNo trace in the law doesn't mean it was illegal. What that means is that no court has reported a case on the matter. That can mean it was very rare, or just was so accepted that it was never challenged in court, or happened in those many places where courts were not much of an option. Even if something gets to some form of courtroom, the chances that a decision would be written down and reported were slim during most of english history.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoRead that quote again. "Although the custom [...] frequently resulted in prosecution..." It was illegal. I don't think, before the modern era, the law applied very well to the peasantry. It makes me wonder if the current system we aspire to, one law for everyone in the same country, really makes sense. There's something to be said for the rich ordering their society their way, and the poor ordering their society their way.
- _yosefk 11y agoSo what's the threshold separating "rich" from "poor"? What laws apply to me if my net worth fluctuates around that threshold? Different laws depending on the day? Now if being poor means you can't become rich legally then they do become closer to separate societies, but I sure wouldn't want to live under such a system.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThat was just phrasing. The principle isn't that we enshrine a division between rich and poor. The principle is that separate communities enforce their own norms among themselves. It happens that separate communities may differ systematically in many ways, including wealth. But taking premodern England as an example, all of the aristocracy would belong to the same group, while different impoverished villages across the country would not share a unified system; they'd all have their own systems, because unlike the aristocracy, they don't have much to do with one another. The laws applying to you are those of the community you belong to, irrespective of your net worth. If you want to change them, you need to be accepted by a different community (and then go live among them). The traditional way of doing that is to marry in.
- belorn 11y agoAs soon you look at any details it all fall apart if you try compare a husband and wife with a farmer and his horse. How many farmers raise, feed or pay child support for horses which the farmer doesn't "own", and rather was deceived about? How many farmers pay spousal support to horses that has left the farmer? How many farmers are expected to go to war and die to protect their horse or the horses home, food, and way of living? It is important both acknowledge that the problems that we inherited from the last few centuries had causes (if you feel like it, call them unjustified), but also that modern technology and policy can eliminate those. War and service can be conducted by both genders, paternity testing could be made standard so both parents know 100% whom the child came from, and any healthy adult can work and earn a living to support themselves and offspring. Gender differences could be removed permanently by society with enough effort to eliminate differences in gender competition.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoIn case anybody thought there weren't still a lot of people who get all het up about 'cuckolding' in two thousand and fifteen, Hacker News poster belorn is here to set you straight.
- dang 11y agoYou've posted many comments to HN that have been uncivil, unsubstantive, or both. Please stop doing that. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html