3 ms·
> hardware refusing to run anything other than a small list of signed binaries Other than that the owner should have complete control over the thing they own.
by mindslight 11y ago
> hardware refusing to run anything other than a small list of signed binaries
Other than that the owner should have complete control over the thing they own. I'd rather suffer the occasional hick "rolling coal" than be restricted in what I can read and write.
> turning ... your car into a socially offensive mechanism should be [illegal]
Sure, but police the violation - not the mere ability to violate.
- userbinator 11y agoSince minimum emissions, maximum fuel economy, and maximum performance are somewhat contrary to each other, I wonder what most of the population would choose if they were explicitly asked to decide on the tuning whenever they bought a car. The extremes would be minimum emissions with horrible fuel economy and dismal performance, maximum fuel economy with higher emissions and also not the best performance (around where VW seems to be aiming), and maximum performance with horrible "rolling coal" emissions and low fuel economy. I doubt most people would choose these extremes, but it'd be interesting to see where the majority would want their cars tuned. I'd probably choose the optimum somewhere between fuel economy and performance, meaning emissions somewhere in the middle.
- mindslight 11y agoOptimal self interest is maximum fuel efficiency when cruising or lightly accelerating, and maximum power when flooring it. If everything is computer controlled, then it doesn't seem like there is a tradeoff here. Besides altruism or avoiding repercussions, why would anybody choose to tune for emissions? It's a collective action problem. Maybe when slowing down / stopped, so a tailwind didn't leave you breathing your horrible exhaust. Thinking a little further, inspections won't be able to prevent this modification if flashing is really easy - just revert before and restore the modifications afterwards. My general stance is "fuck trusted hardware", because any contemporary implementation is likely to involve a foreign asymmetric key that makes it so someone else owns "your" hardware. But I do see a Free approach to it that involves time locks / hashing proof of work, and possibly logs changes. This way would provide some appropriate physical security and auditing, while not restricting any party in long-term possession of the device.
- userbinator 11y agoBesides altruism or avoiding repercussions, why would anybody choose to tune for emissions? At least for petrol engines, ultra-high emissions usually means low fuel economy and performance, as optimum combustion means negligible CO and NOx (and unburned hydrocarbons). In other words, turning for those will decrease emissions to a low point, although maybe not to the point where the environmentalists are satisfied. The three points are quite close together. With diesels the situation is somewhat different, since there's no throttle plate and the only thing that can be adjusted is the amount of fuel injected, and increasing that both increases power and emissions while decreasing fuel economy.
- mindslight 11y agoEmissions can benefit when you tune for something else, but I wouldn't call that tuning for emissions. My point is that if you don't care about emissions, then there is nothing to trade off. A computer controlled system can be tuned entirely for mileage at low power output and also tuned entirely for power at the high end.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoPolice the violation - I agree. Should have been clearer perhaps. i think we need to discuss why you should be able to write to your car. Or rather, there will become a OSL layer style to the car. Drive train, brakes, steering. These are things I question why you should be able to do more than verify the binary. If you want to, turn up the fuel mix or something (showing my clear understanding of cars), well, apply for a UEFI key and sign your own binary. If the GPS on the car shows you on a public highway with a unlicensed binary drive train, frankly they can pull out the tyre bursting chains. I don't think there should be some untouchable chip at the bottom of the stack able to stop the car if the "right" people send the code. Too dangerous. But I also don't want half coded ideas driving next to me at 100kph. Does this mean there won't be a Debian binary for Ford, undoing all the crap they throw in. No it should exist, but should also get on the highway approval eventually. Yes, you should be free to modify your car, to the bare metal. No you should not be free to drive your modified car on the road next to the rest of us. All our cars pass yearly tests assuring us they meet minimum engineering standards - why not the software in the car. And no, not so stringent on the rest of the OSL layers - you can swap binaries on the CD player
- mindslight 11y ago> Yes, you should be free to modify your car, to the bare metal. No you should not be free to drive your modified car on the road next to the rest of us. This type of cryptofascism is quite odd to me. You are not tolerant of modifications, so why bother pretending to be? Invoking some ambiguous authoritative "us" is ridiculous in light of actual reality. People are driving all sorts of modified cars, on the road, right now. People modifying things necessarily know about them in depth and are likely to do better maintenance and care than someone who expects a car to "just work" if they bring it to the stealership on the service schedule (and otherwise have no idea what a weird sound means or even how to react in the event their Toyota "suddenly accelerates"). > All our cars pass yearly tests assuring us they meet minimum engineering standards Lol. Vehicle inspections (I'm familiar with MA) cover the bare minimum of safety/signaling, plus emissions. You can technically be rejected for some types of aftermarket parts that don't meet FMVSS from when the car was manufactured, but only some shops check a couple specific things (say, headlight dispersion). If your comment had any basis in reality, we wouldn't nearly have as many idiots driving around with "HID retrofits" that blind oncoming drivers. Do you realize that in the US, most auto parts actually aren't tested or certified by the government, but merely "self certified" by the manufacturer as conforming? Sorry if I'm bursting your bubble here. > These are things I question why you should be able to do more than verify the binary You can currently take apart apart and modify any of these mechanical systems, yet people have a strong incentive to make sure they work before driving anywhere. Where exactly is this a priori worry and FUD coming from just because those systems are becoming software? Open software aligns incentives properly - it enables inspection, maintenance, repair, and design fixes long after the manufacturer has lost interest - just like standardized wrenches and threads. Our computerized devices should not be black boxes that we can only worship or discard.