4 ms·
Hm. That guy writing the intro was extremely optimistic about human nature. Most folks find statistics very unintuitive. Folks routinely overestimate extremely
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Hm. That guy writing the intro was extremely optimistic about human nature. Most folks find statistics very unintuitive. Folks routinely overestimate extremely unlikely events (lotto) and underestimate near-certainties (auto accident). Its the idea that we might get away with something, or maybe it won't happen to me, that guides most human activities.
Its this warping of the probability curve that is responsible for major facets of human society: war, witchcraft, gambling, marriage, on and on.
- darkmighty 11y agoI think those problems are a little different. For example, no matter how you approach it, from a rational point of view joining a war for your country makes no sense. You are highly likely to die and highly unlikely to change to outcome of the war. But if you think in an evolutionary sense, if each individual in a tribe acted rationally, we'd get a sort of Tragedy of the Commons: the enemy tribe wins the war, and slaughters your men. So it may happen that if each individual acts rationally the group, each individual included, suffers; so it makes sense individual sense to develop mechanisms to go to war, which by symmetry must include yourself. Even less intuitively even if the probability of death is lower by not going to war (no tragedy of the commons in traditional sense), which means no individual would rationally choose war or develop mechanisms to force going to war, it would be rational for the tribe to choose war, in an evolutionary sense, provided many more of your men are killed than the enemy tribe (so they do better in evolutionary terms).
- SixSigma 11y agoOr: if you don't go to war to protect your community you will be shunned forever by that community; so the rational decision is "war"
- adamlett 11y agoThe consensus among biologists today is that group selection does not occur: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection
- SapphireSun 11y agoI know I've heard this before, and I've not taken an evolutionary biology class before so I do give a lot of weight to the idea that there is little influence at the group level, but one of the first paragraphs states: "As of yet, there is no clear consensus among biologists regarding the importance of group selection." In particular, when selecting for war, there's a clear individual level selection pressure: if you don't cooperate with your group, you likely die. This is a just so story, I have no idea how irrationality actually developed, but say you have small groups of hunter gatherers and one individual develops a preference for cooperating in raids against their best interest. If this means that on average you now have two versus one whenever this individual participates, there's a clear competitive advantage which could allow that gene to propagate. The key here in this hypothetical is that the mutation occurs at the individual level in a lone individual, who then cooperates with someone else who wouldn't necessarily follow them, but is happy to have the help. This results in a disproportionate gain (100%) in effectiveness vs lone opponents. As time evolves, the gene becomes more widespread by its early disproportionate effectiveness and groups that fail to cooperate are killed on average, thus eliminating individual competitor genes. Again, I have no idea how war actually evolved, but it seems easy to believe that when a trait influences whether one group kills another, that it would cause the killers to have a reproductive advantage. I'd love someone more educated on this topic to send me up though.
- nicklaf 11y agoHm. That guy writing the intro "That guy" was Pierre-Simon Laplace, and the book he was introducing was his own seminal Théorie analytique des probabilités!
- PavlovsCat 11y agoBetween the skinner box gaming industry and web, and the circus that is politics and war, the fact that we are both unabashedly exploiting this and unabashedly being exploited by this, makes me kind of pessimistic. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3845016/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3845016/ > Studies have shown that reward uncertainty rather than reward per se, will magnify mesolimbic DA, both in monkeys (Fiorillo et al., 2003; de Lafuente and Romo, 2011) and healthy human participants (Preuschoff et al., 2006). In PG, accumbens DA is maximal during a gambling task when the probability of winning and losing money is identical—a 50% chance for a two-outcome event representing maximal uncertainty (Linnet et al., 2012). Although non-dopaminergic neurons might also be involved in the coding of reward uncertainty (Monosov and Hikosaka, 2013), these results based on electrophysiological and neuroimaging techniques indicate that DA is crucial for the coding of reward uncertainty. This suggestion is corroborated by a large number of behavioral studies, showing that mammals and birds respond more vigorously to conditioned cues predicting uncertain rewards (Collins et al., 1983; Anselme et al., 2013; Robinson et al., under review) and tend to prefer an uncertain food option over a certain food option in dual-choice tasks (Kacelnik and Bateson, 1996; Adriani and Laviola, 2006), sometimes despite a lower reward rate (Forkman, 1991; Gipson et al., 2009). According to Greg Costikyan, an award-winning game designer, games cannot hold our interest in the absence of uncertainty—which can take many forms, occurring in the outcome, the game's path, analytical complexity, perception, and so on (Costikyan, 2013).