4 ms·
Does anyone else have the strange suspicion that, if we were willing to kill as many people doing it as we were in the history of aviation, we'd be wandering ar
by mcguire 11y ago
Does anyone else have the strange suspicion that, if we were willing to kill as many people doing it as we were in the history of aviation, we'd be wandering around on Mars now?
- jdub 11y agoAt the risk of sounding unsympathetic, it's cheaper to kill people at lower altitudes.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoIt's always a lot easier to talk about human loss when it happens to somebody else and in the abstract.
- troutwine 11y agoThat suspicion would be wrong. Spaceflight isn't something that you can wing, even if you are completely callous as to human life. Missions over long distances with very low margin for error imply an attention to detail that doesn't have an analog in early aviation. Even more, each human you kill in spaceflight is the loss of a highly-trained, highly-skilled engineering / pilot. They aren't just goofs along for a rocket trip. Similar story in modern aviation. Some things are just too expensive to get wrong. Some things are too specific to get wrong. Spaceflight is both.
- mcguire 11y agoYou're probably right. A closer analogy would probably be sea voyages in the "age of discovery", but in that case you didn't need skilled people; you didn't even need willing people. On the other hand, all of the test pilots killed by the Cutlass (and most killed by aviation since Thomas Selfridge) were highly-skilled people.
- troutwine 11y agoQuite so. I guess it depends on where you draw the line at "modern". I was implicitly lumping anything past the jet age in as "modern".
- berntb 11y agoCheck the Orion project (Freeman Dyson's son wrote a good book). We could have been further out than Mars... 40 years ago. :-( The motto was "Mars by 1965, Saturn by 1970" (but that was probably optimistic... by maybe five years or so. :-) ) And sure, there was talk about a failed launch increasing the background radiation by 1%. Some cancer risk would arguably be cheap to get an industrial infrastructure outside the atmosphere. (Also note the implications for the Great Filter theory regarding the Fermi paradox. With a bunch or Orion launches starting in the 1970s we could have viable colonies somewhere between now and 2030. So any big catastrophe as filter would need to sterilize a whole solar system, not just a planet.)