8 ms·
The Delinquent Borrowers Leading a Student Loans Revolt
- SixSigma 11y agoThose numbers are horrific. My entire UK degree debt will be about $60k at 3% and I won't have to make any repayments until I earn about $30k pa. For my degree it should be a net profit for me. For less well paid occupations one is insulated against low wages. I am happy that I contribute to the advancements in non vocational learning. My fellow students and I are said to contribute $40m pa to the local economy which is much needed in this deindustrialised part of the country - all accommodation is provided by third parties. But $45k per year is an outrage. It surely can't be based upon the cost of provision.
- Camillo 11y agoIt's based on supply and demand. Since anyone and their dog can get a student loan, and the federal government guarantees those loans, demand for college education is basically inelastic. You can keep raising prices without losing students: they're just going to borrow more money. It's basically the same mechanism as that of subprime loans, where anyone got to buy a house they couldn't afford, except that it's federally mandated.
- karissa 11y agoYou're right, it isn't. It's largely a for-profit industry, even the 'non profit' colleges. Most teachers, especially adjuncts, make very little in comparison to what the students are paying -- look at NYU, 50k/year per student in a class of 20 where the teacher is paid 5k/class. The math doesn't add up.
- x0x0 11y agoOf course the math adds up. You can't run a university without a home in Fire Island, and that shit's spendy.
- karissa 11y agoI rofled
- keithpeter 11y agoWould a self organised University be possible in the US system? A group of teachers using cheap space and online communications to provide lectures/support/assessment with students then taking exams accredited by another institution? Possibly with sponsorship/organisational support from a voluntary sector organisation? That is basically how most Universities outside Oxford/Cambridge/Edinburgh/Aberdeen started in UK in the Victorian period. The University of London was set up to validate degrees provided by various constituent colleges in the regions. There was a strong non-conformist (Baptist/Methodist) input on the funding and organisational side.
- karissa 11y agoI'd love that. I think a lot of teachers would be happy to get rid of the bloated administration in their university.
- derpud 11y agoFaculty would love to disintermediate the ever growing administration. Accreditation is an issue, and overcoming the importance of brand. Competing with the for profit niche might work though.
- keithpeter 11y agoUK Background: Last government (the coalition) decided to move part of the financial burden of a University education from the state (in the form of a 'teaching grant' paid directly to the University) to the student (in the form of a low rate loan as described by SixSigma). This was entirely within the ideological position of one of the coalition partners, but was a bit of a u-turn for the other partner with rather drastic results in terms of support. The Student Loan Company in the UK has to borrow money at commercial interest rates in the financial markets. The difference in costs between the interest rates paid by the company and the interest paid back by the students will be met by the government. It isn't clear to me if there will actually be any net saving to the taxpayer at all - I recollect seeing (but can't find a reference at present) an analysis that suggested that the policy will actually cost more money compared with the previous direct grant system for the next 20 years or so. I suspect the payback period will depend on the number of graduates who get stuck in low paying jobs. I would love to see any more recent analysis. Back on topic: good luck to these people!
- evanpw 11y agoThat $45k / year is for private non-profit colleges, which are the most expensive kind (even worse than for-profit), and not the norm. For an in-state public University, the number is more like a quarter of that. http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_cua.asp http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_cua.asp
- tome 11y ago> non-profit colleges, which are the most expensive kind (even worse than for-profit) This sounds strange. How does that work?
- evanpw 11y agoThere are a lot of old, prestigious private non-profit colleges (Princeton, Harvard, MIT) who can charge a lot because of their reputation. For-profit colleges are mostly very new and tend to have bad reputations.
- karissa 11y agoHey! Glad to see this on HN. I'm a volunteer developer for this group, and we are looking for more hands. If you're interested in helping us out, feel free to reach out to me on GitHub (karissa) or Twitter (captainkmac). Here's the list of issues (signup/login related) that I'm working on now: https://github.com/debtcollective/debtcollective-web/issues/56 https://github.com/debtcollective/debtcollective-web/issues/... Here's a taste of the future: "Harnessing user data (and combining it with data gathered automatically from creditor websites and public data sets)" - https://www.newschallenge.org/challenge/data/entries/debt-collective https://www.newschallenge.org/challenge/data/entries/debt-co...
- Camillo 11y agoThe absurd student loan system is what fueled tuition inflation in America. It needs to be abolished.
- cheriot 11y agoDo poor students not get to go to college anymore or do you have another system in mind?
- jrs235 11y agoFederal and private grants would still be available for those that qualify same with scholarships.
- nemo44x 11y agoWork and save money before you enter a University. If you work and save for 2 years after high school you gain many advantages: 1) You will save some money to pay for school. 2) Because you are a bit older a new world of grants are available to you since you are returning to education. 3) Because your income will probably be fairly low you will qualify for more grants due to this fact. 4) Gives you time to figure out what you want to go to school for and possibly make you take it more seriously when you start. Another option is to join the military and qualify for a lot of additional grants that way. 4 years of service opens a lot of doors. There are many non-combat roles available. There are many ways for the poor to advance themselves and not cripple themselves financially for the next 40 years.
- cheriot 11y agoI like your reasoning, but I worry that the math of minimum wage jobs can't put people through school any more.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoHow about "free tuition for everybody, like they used to have in California."
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cheriot 11y agoThere's two problems when students choose an institution: 1. Poor and too often manipulated information about a school's job placements. 2. Students are short sighted about debts and schools don't care because the money is government guaranteed. Solvable problems! Have an independent party collect and report on job placement. Then tie a school's loan eligibility more closely to the ability of recent graduates to pay.
- evanpw 11y agoIt seems like it would be even better to tie eligibility to the borrower's major. Return on education expenses are more closely related to what you study rather than where you study it: http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2015/03/daily-chart-2 http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2015/03/daily-c...
- cheriot 11y agoIf we do both then both the school and student are incentivized! (I was thinking of the for profit schools owned by hedge funds)
- tomohawk 11y agoBorrowing money is risky, and includes risks beyond a straight up cost/benefit analysis. It also makes the borrow more vulnerable (not just to the lender, but to others as well). It should never be entered into lightly. I sympathize with these folks who have gotten themselves into this situation, but they did make the choice of their own free will. If they didn't do a proper analysis ahead of time, it doesn't seem fair to shift the cost of their decision onto others who did, or who are responsibly shouldering the burden that they took on. There is a definite moral hazard in the current system (it encourages indebtedness and inflates the cost of education), but that doesn't make it right to create another moral hazard in trying to correct it.
- m_fayer 11y agoFor those trying to escape poverty, disadvantaged teenagers must choose between debt and the permanent surrender of their hopes and dreams. Hardly a situation where the borrower can be expected to make a dispassionate calculation, nor is it a situation where there's a clearly correct course to be found.
- Rainymood 11y agoEducation used to be 'free' here in The Netherlands (certain amount of money each month for students). They recently turned this into a full fledged loan. Although the interest is very low it dramatically changes how students approach studies and immediately start to think in terms of ROI ... I fear for the future of Dutch education. I'm glad I just wrapped up my undergrad and am currently borrowing as well for my Master's but thankfully (I'm one of the few) who have 'great' career prospects. The American system is really really screwed up if you are trying to escape poverty.
- seibelj 11y agoI think in the USA college is too expensive, but I'm not convinced it should be free. I like the idea of students actually having some skin in the game. Also I don't want tax dollars to pay for someone to study poetry for 4 years for free. You'll get into a situation like Norway, where it takes a master's to get a foot in the door, and no one gets a job until they are 30.
- WBrentWilliams 11y agoI like the way that these articles and the comments ignore the elephant in the room: The cost of living while attending college. Here is a data point for my local State University. I happen to work there, so I can verify that these numbers are pretty much correct. You can pay cheaper rent, but you'll pay back the difference in car mileage and/or roommate drama. Tuition is (roughly) 40 percent of the cost. What really drives up the student debt is the cost of living. If we really wanted to do something about student loan debt, I think we'd do better to apply the same political pressure to the cost of living as we do to the rate of tuition. Indiana University [1] Tuition: $10,388 Room and board: $9,794 Books and supplies: $1,230 Transportation: $1,030 Personal Expenses: $2,096 [1] http://admissions.indiana.edu/cost-financial-aid/tuition-fees.html http://admissions.indiana.edu/cost-financial-aid/tuition-fee...
- saturdaysaint 11y agoThe "books and supplies" section would be interesting to break down. How much of it is due to needlessly churning out new editions to cut off the used book market? In the age of the iPad, shouldn't someone be producing first rate, open source textbooks in core subjects? It's a pittance of the total, but that $1,200 (x4) could still add up to a lot with interest.
- WBrentWilliams 11y agoLet me answer that with a statement and an anecdote. The statement: The proportion of costs I outlined, from my point of view, have always been true. I finished my first degree in 1997. The anecdote: All the professors in my computer science program (I'm not going to name-drop, but I had some great teachers that insisted that I learn scheme, then Java, then C, then assembly) either had no required text or gave syllabi that referenced several versions of their listed texts. The context was that we were free to get the best deal possible on the texts.
- icewater0 11y ago> How much of it is due to needlessly churning out new editions to cut off the used book market? And there is all the more incentive when the instructor requires a book he has written himself.
- UserRights 11y agoFree Education is the primary attribute of a free and cultivated society. If you are living in a primitive country with no free (+higher) education, all available resources should be focused on reaching this goal as the most important evolutionary step. Many underdeveloped societies and failed states can be identified by looking at the education situation. In the worst cases education is held hostage by a leading group of brutal oligarchs that are raping education into a "business-model" - these societies will need a lot of help from other nations to overcome the dark neandertaler age they are stuck in and it is important to teach them about the basic abilities of Homo Sapiens Sapiens - solidarity, compassion and love. Good Luck!
- evanpw 11y agoEducation is never free; it always consumes some resources. The question is who should pay the cost: the student or everyone else? In cases where basically everyone needs the education to succeed in society and the positive externalities are large (e.g., teaching young children to read), I think that the case for "everyone else" paying is pretty strong. In cases where the education is mostly consumption (i.e., the benefits all go to the student), the case for subsidizing is weak (e.g., a trust-fund kid getting multiple PhDs in impractical fields to have something to do). So the main issue becomes: where does a Bachelor's degree lie on this spectrum? 1. Fields of study are very heterogeneous. Some majors have a much larger return on investment than others, so subsidizing all "higher education" equally probably doesn't make sense. 2. Even in Western Europe, college attendance rates are only around 1/3. Is it right to have that 1/3 subsidized by the 2/3 who don't go to college, and who on average have lower income? 3. (More speculative) To some extent, the payoff to a college education is not because of what you learn, but in signaling that you're a smart, conscientious, perseverant person. In that case, a degree becomes less valuable the more people that have them, and the case for subsidizing what has become an arms race becomes a lot weaker. 4. If we spend a lot of money and effort propping up the current, very expensive, forms of higher education, we might discourage better ways of educating from emerging. One example is something like Coursera, where the marginal cost of adding one more student is basically zero, and everyone can learn from the very best educators in the field. Another would be separate institutions for education and for testing / accreditation. This would help with grade inflation, bring back the focus in the educational institutions to teaching rather than credentialing, and provide more accountability (% of graduates passing a common exam is a lot easier to compare than future income of graduates, and is less confounded by things like socio-economic status of students).
- douche 11y agoI have to be honest, if some kind of student-loan amnesty ever goes into effect, I'll be a little pissed that I prioritized paying mine off with my earnings for the first half-dozen years out of school. Just imagine what I could have done with those tens of thousands of dollars instead...
- littletimmy 11y agoI know right! Someone else would be better off without making you worse off... The horror! If I can't have it, they can't!
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Someone else would be better off without making you worse off That money doesn't come from nowhere; someone is paying for it. Student loans are already provided at below-market interest rates[0], which means they're being subsidized by taxpayers, either explicitly or implicitly. [0] Not all student loans, but the majority if not all of undergraduate federal student loans
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 11y agoIt's not just about who's better or worse off. It's about the basic principles of meeting one's obligations and of applying the law equally. Would you be equally flippant about a law allowing any other group to shed their obligations without consequences? Bankers, perhaps? Or members of any ethnic group other than your own? It wouldn't affect you directly, as you'd be neither the debtor nor the creditor. Those people would be better off without you being worse off . . . except that we're all worse off when the foundations of civil society are weakened. The situation with corrupt lenders and pseudo-educational institutions leaving others with nothing but massive debt cries out for relief. However, that relief should extend to a ll those who have been victimized - not just those who have yet to pay. Laughing or sneering at those who paid already, because it was both legally required and financially prudent that they do so, is pretty abhorrent.
- littletimmy 11y agoOne way to deal with the student loans crisis is for a nationwide student loan bailout. You don't have to erase the loans, just refinance them at a much lower interest rate. Currently the rate is 7%, which is just insane. For a virtually no-risk loan, which cannot even be discharged in default, that is a terribly high rate. Refinancing will be a transfer of wealth from the rich to the poor. Good for the economy, shores up consumption, and all that. Has the added side-benefit of freeing indentured slaves.
- evanpw 11y agoIf the current interest rate is high compared to default risk, why hasn't some private company come in to undercut the government and make a killing? I don't think it's because the banks aren't greedy enough. My guess would be that it's because of the extremely high default rate on student loans, and the extremely favorable repayment terms that government loans offer: payments capped at 10% of discretionary income, and forgiveness after 20 years (10 if working in non-profit or government)[1]. [1] https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/understand/plans/income-driven https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/understand/plans/in...
- littletimmy 11y agoIf that were true, why would private student interest rate be 7% also? It has no such favorable repayment terms.
- evanpw 11y agoIt's my impression that there isn't much private student-loan industry left, having been driven out by federal loans. What's left probably targets a different demographic from the usual one, like borrowers who have already maxed out their federal loans, which might be a riskier group.
- pkaye 11y agoI would be okay with this but other things need reform. They need to cut down on bloated middle management layer in colleges. They need to cut out the shitty diploma mills that don't give graduates much success in getting jobs after graduating.
- WeAllDieByBan 11y agoDon't pay it and default. You'll only have to pay the income tax on the defaulted loan. It's not like you need credit anyways since almost no one in this generation is going to be able to afford a house down payment.
- evanpw 11y agoIf it's a federal loan, the government will garnish your wages [1] and eventually your social security payments [2], and will withold any tax refunds. And since student loans usually can't be discharged in bankruptcy, you'll have bad credit for literally the rest of your life. Also, you pay income tax on forgiven loans, not defaulted ones. [1] https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/default#consequences https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/default#consequence... [2] http://money.cnn.com/2014/08/24/news/economy/social-security-student-debt/ http://money.cnn.com/2014/08/24/news/economy/social-security...
- icewater0 11y agoI think part of "the system" involves learning and lending institutions informally forecasting what the lifetime return on a student's education will be, and then attempting to maximize the return on the student loan(s) as an investment on those future earnings. The learning and lending institutions clearly fucked up big-time in their forecasting, along with everyone else who was irrationally exuberant in their optimism about the future economy. Now they are stuck between students on one hand (who have been sold a bill of goods and are seriously pissed about the pittance left over after their loan payments, if they're able to pay back at all), and the investors on the other hand (which includes not only evil bankers' money but also people who have been sacrificing in good faith for decades to contribute to their retirement accounts). So the stage is set for a nice messy society-destroying generational war that should distract everyone from the forecasting mistakes.