5 ms·
New evidence suggests we can learn while we sleep, but do we really want to?
- DiabloD3 11y agoDo we really want to? I want to, this is the type of science fiction I adored as a kid, and, well, we do live in the future, after all. We're getting self driving cars, we carry computers we can use natural language with in our pockets (along with the sum total of all human knowledge, and a communicator that can talk to anyone else on Earth almost instantaneously), we have televisions half the size of a wall regularly in homes, normal computers are getting smaller and more power efficient, and the portable ones have insane battery life compared to just a decade ago, and I can get IEMs for under $300 that sound as good as thousands of dollars of conventional speakers. So, why does learning while you sleep even sound surprising, yet the rest of this stuff that is clearly from the future doesn't and is now the norm?
- littletimmy 11y agoIn theory, yeah it might be cool. In practice, parents will push their kinds into learning while asleep. Millions of Chinese and Indian students will cram while sleeping. Sheryl Sandberg will write a book about how women need to sleep learn with more vigor. Corporations will require workers to do overnight sleep-learning in preparation for tomorrow's meetings. People who don't utilize their sleep time effectively will be outcompeted by those who want to succeed at all costs. Human "rest" will be relegated to the books of history. Is that really the sort of world you want to live in?
- camillomiller 11y agoNice pitch for the setting of a distopian novel
- Radim 11y agoSome nice material for a sci-fi novel you've got there :) To answer your question: I want to live in a world where humans continue to evolve, yes. I don't want to live in a world where armchair philosophers and do-gooders decide what's best and "proper" for everybody. Their predictions always fall flat in the face of reality's complexity. Not that there's much risk of them succeeding... nature has built-in ways of bypassing (outcompeting) such regulatory efforts, sooner or later. Still, in my region (eastern Europe, communism) it took a few decades... and their aftermaths are still palpable.
- Zigurd 11y agoPeople already take alertness-enhancing drugs to work longer, with more focus. That's fine if it's truly a choice. But if it isn't, that dystopian future is already here. What we really need is to have control over our lives and environments. That means we need to tune the culture away from valuing success at all costs.
- shas3 11y agoWhy Chinese and Indians? Seriously, I'd like to know why your humor presupposes they'll be the ones to do it first.
- thehoff 11y agoBut is this not the way things are almost now? Kids of all stripes are forced to study once they get home until they go to bed. Go to bed, wake up and go to school (you better get straight A's) then go home and study. Adding in more time for studying? We'd have numerous studies on the pros and cons of this method. I'm sure one could point to a time period in our past where people would think that the way we live now is 'dystopia'. There could also be novel ways to use this time. For instance, it would be kind of cool to study while sleeping, maybe some math or science or art or history. Then during the waking hours, instead of studying more, I'd love to do something with that knowledge, stuff that you can't do while you are asleep. Like experiments, make a software program that does something, draw some art that mimics a particular period. Utilize that knowledge and expand on it but in a more hands on fun way. My $0.01.
- wodenokoto 11y agoThe way the article lays out the history of sleep learning make it sound like there was a huge scientific misstep. First, psychologists shows through experimentation that it works, then a neuro scientist show that our current understanding of the brain says that this should be impossible. Instead of revising our brain-model, we throw out the experimental evidence. But why?
- NPMaxwell 11y agoGreat question! At the time of this glitch, Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions had not yet been published (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Structure_of_Scientific_Revolutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Structure_of_Scientific_Re...). But even current researchers have not fully adapted to Kuhn's lessons. For example, last I saw, you couldn't pick up an intro text on the sociology of science and read a clear explanation of what academic, funding, and social structures allow scientists to be open minded and what structures prevent that. We don't really know. We haven't yet fully answered your question.
- wodenokoto 11y agoI'm not really blaming the neuro scientist for standing his ground, I'm more blaming the psychologists for not standing theirs. Or maybe they did, but the consensus was to believe a "real" scientist.