4 ms·
The way Google sees it is that even with those theoretical scenarios - where it's forced to choose between what it thinks is the least harmful - the Google car
by danso 11y ago
The way Google sees it is that even with those theoretical scenarios - where it's forced to choose between what it thinks is the least harmful - the Google car is still far smarter than a human, and, crucially, will save thousands of lives by existing in the first place.
I dislike this being described as smarter. So far, what we've seen as described is behavior that is more predictable and consistent. In the scenario described by the OP, in which the car slammed its brakes because of a jogger on the opposite side of the road...that doesn't strike me as a decision based off of what we'd traditionally consider "intelligence", but a strict adherence to a set of rules that could use a little more refinement and complexity.
Even if self-driving cars do dominate future roads, it's going to be an interesting few years of transition...human drivers are going to quickly realize that their automated counterparts are almost always going to follow the rules, allowing humans to cut them off without worry...Maybe at some point, these incidents are going to be logged as evidence (using dashboard cams that are almost certainly going to be standard on all driverless-cars) to prosecute those overly aggressive human drivers?
- icebraining 11y agoI dislike this being described as smarter. So far, what we've seen as described is behavior that is more predictable and consistent. In the scenario described by the OP, in which the car slammed its brakes because of a jogger on the opposite side of the road...that doesn't strike me as a decision based off of what we'd traditionally consider "intelligence", but a strict adherence to a set of rules that could use a little more refinement and complexity. In a way, the rules are a kind of "codified intelligence", and a computer that follows them can be said to be smarter, at least if we defined that based on the results, eg. "able to take a better path to achieve the same goal" (in that case, hurting less people). Even if self-driving cars do dominate future roads, it's going to be an interesting few years of transition...human drivers are going to quickly realize that their automated counterparts are almost always going to follow the rules, allowing humans to cut them off without worry...Maybe at some point, these incidents are going to be logged as evidence (using dashboard cams that are almost certainly going to be standard on all driverless-cars) to prosecute those overly aggressive human drivers? Maybe, but there's also the 'glasshole' effect - others drivers will already be anxious about driveless cars, you don't want to add reasons to make them angry at them as well.
- anon4 11y agoEven self-driving cars aren't perfect. The reason you don't cut in front of a human driver is because human reaction time is finite and you're likely to get hit. The same goes for a computer driver - it has a hard limit on how much it can track and if you happen to cut in front when it's taxed... you'll get hit. You're still gambling on the other driver noticing you on time and hitting the brakes.
- skybrian 11y agoThe trick is not caring when people cut in front of you, and even leaving extra space for them to take if they want. I'd say that traditionally falls under "wisdom" rather than "intelligence". It's easier for a machine than a human, but it can be learned. I doubt it measurably affects my commute times.
- acdha 11y agoAgreed – I have spent so much time in traffic consistently going at the average speed, not tailgating, etc. and repeating the cycle of passing and being passed by aggressive drivers who are too busy making crazy lane changes to notice that they've spent an hour not getting any further ahead.
- danso 11y agoI'm reluctant to call this "wisdom", though...I've learned not to be surprised when friends and colleagues who are otherwise near-paragons in wisdom in work and life can suddenly turn into road-ragers. For some people, getting angry in the car is not a typical characteristic but may result after a series of stresses that day. So the machine isn't being "wise" when it avoids road rage, it's just being a machine.
- skybrian 11y agoI call it wisdom because the ability to remain calm and ego-less in all situations seems to be the sort of thing taught by certain religious groups who are big on meditation. But of course, it doesn't require that. Truck drivers need to learn to drive this way too. Humans seem to need some kind of training let go of our natural instinct to punish "cheaters". A machine can just do it, as can a stone for that matter. So: artificial wisdom.
- azernik 11y agoIt's not just more predictable - it is smarter. Your human "intelligence" in such a situation is only as good as your snap judgments, and because a computer works so much faster it is absolutely smarter than you or I in that particular setting.
- Steko 11y agoI find the human vs machine scenarios that tend to dominate these discussions less interesting than the machine vs machine scenarios. There's going to be a huge shakeout as the auto industry transitions to self-driving cars and companies are going to do desperate things to stay in business. There will absolutely be self-driving cars that are marketed on their superior "safe" speed and supposed better AI to get through traffic quickly but in practice just means they cut off overly cautious cars all the time.
- npunt 11y agoAgree. I think the way it will shake out is having a standardized communication protocol for driverless cars that allows them to tap into collective intelligence to make decisions together. This will probably be mandated, with testing to ensure that in certain scenarios all AIs respond in the same predictable way. Competing AIs sounds like it could quickly get out of hand. I don't think driverless cars will act as individual units for a very long time when the opportunity to have them operate collectively can produce meaningful efficiency gains. For example, drafting on freeways to reduce drag, or being in communication with local streetlights to shape traffic patterns. That's one of the great benefits of moving away from human controlled cars - collective intelligence is possible.